保障性住房供应如何影响商品房价——挤出供给抑或分流需求?

How does Affordable Housing Supply Affect Commercial Housing Prices:Crowd out Supply or Divert Demand?

邹旭,马贤磊,石晓平

2021 第 47 卷 第 11 期 页码 49-63

DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.jfe.20210813.401

PDF全文下载 HTML全文

语音预告

摘要

市场和保障是实现住房小康梦的主要途径,如何认识两者关系成为各级政府制定住房政策的重要参考。文章通过构建供需均衡模型,结合我国特殊的住房保障和土地制度安排,在理论上分析了保障性住房供应可能对商品住房市场的影响。文章基于2007−2016年中国248个城市的面板数据,利用固定效应模型和工具变量法对理论假说进行了检验。研究表明:在统计意义上,保障性住房通过土地资源的竞争性配给挤出了商品住房供应,但在分割的住房市场中无法替代商品住房需求,因此最终导致商品房价格上涨。进一步研究发现,供给挤出效应在土地财政依赖程度较低的地区更为明显。但实证结果的实际经济含义较弱,供给挤出效应与房价影响可以忽略,这意味着保障性住房供应基本不对其他群体的福利带来损害。文章的研究从土地与住房市场的双重角度,为完善住房保障制度提供了参考,对于正在广泛推行的共有产权房、保障性租赁住房的政策设计也具有借鉴意义。

Since the housing system reform in 1998, China’s commercial housing prices have risen rapidly, and far exceeded the affordability of commonality. In order to solve the housing problems of middle and low income families, China launched the construction of affordable housing, which has greatly improved people’s livelihood and social welfare. The impact of affordable housing supply on the real estate market is also related to the interests of social groups. How to understand the relationship between the two types of housing has become an important reference for building an internally coordinated and efficient housing supply system.

Combined with China’s special housing security and land system, this study theoretically analyzes the possible impact of affordable housing supply on the commercial housing market by constructing the equilibrium model of supply and demand. Based on the panel data of 248 prefecture-level cities in China from 2007 to 2016, the FEM and IV models are used to test the theoretical hypothesis, and the mechanism and heterogeneity are further discussed.

The results show that: In the statistical sense, we find that affordable housing crowds out commercial housing supply through the competitive allocation of land, but it cannot replace demand in the segmented housing market, which eventually raises housing prices. Furthermore, the crowding-out effect is more obvious in the regions with low land financial dependence. But the economic meaning of empirical results is weak, and the crowding-out effect and the impact of housing prices can be ignored. This means that the supply of affordable housing basically does not harm the welfare of other groups.

In general, this study has strong policy implications. On the one hand, China should establish multi-agent supply channels. Collective construction land and idle land owned by enterprises can be used to build affordable housing to ensure the independence of the land supply mechanism. On the other hand, some cities can gradually relax the access restrictions on affordable housing according to the actual situation. They can provide talent housing for college graduates and professional and technical personnel, and provide affordable rental housing for urban “new citizens” and migrant workers, so as to effectively divert the demand for commercial housing and stabilize the price of commercial housing.

参考文献

1 巴曙松. 保障房建设提速对商品房冲击有限[N]. 中国证券报, 2011-06-08.
2 陈杰,王文宁. 经济适用房供应对商品住房价格的影响效应[J]. 广东社会科学,2011,(2):11−18. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1000-114X.2011.02.002
3 邓宏乾,黄冠,徐升. 人口结构变动对住房需求的影响−基于2002-2016年省际面板数据的实证分析[J]. 华中师范大学学报(人文社会科学版),2019,(3):51−59. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1000-2456.2019.03.007
5 刘斌. 经济适用房存在挤出效应吗?−基于中国35个大中城市的面板数据[J]. 经济管理,2014,(10):157−168. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1671-0975.2014.10.066
6 龙奋杰,董黎明. 经济适用房政策绩效评析[J]. 城市问题,2005,(4):48−52. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1002-2031.2005.04.012
7 罗孝玲,马世昌,王维. 保障性住房对商品房价格的影响研究−基于供需结合的视角[J]. 软科学,2013,(10):1−4. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1001-8409.2013.10.001
8 茅于轼. 大建限价房和经济适用房可能推高房价[N]. 信息时报, 2008-04-28.
9 潘爱民,韩正龙. 经济适用房、土地价格与住宅价格−基于我国29个省级面板数据的实证研究[J]. 财贸经济,2012,(2):106−113. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1005-913X.2012.02.054
10 唐云锋,马春华. 财政压力、土地财政与"房价棘轮效应"[J]. 财贸经济,2017,(11):39−54. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1002-8102.2017.11.003
15 Chen J W,Hui E C M,Seiler M J,et al. Household tenure choice and housing price volatility under a binding home-purchase limit policy constraint[J]. Journal of Housing Economics,2018,41: 124−134. DOI:10.1016/j.jhe.2018.06.004
16 Eriksen M D,Rosenthal S S. Crowd out effects of place-based subsidized rental housing:New evidence from the LIHTC program[J]. Journal of Public Economics,2010,94(11-12): 953−966. DOI:10.1016/j.jpubeco.2010.07.002
17 Hu F Z Y,Qian J W. Land-based finance,fiscal autonomy and land supply for affordable housing in urban China:A prefecture-level analysis[J]. Land Use Policy,2017,69: 454−460. DOI:10.1016/j.landusepol.2017.09.050
18 Lee C I. Does provision of public rental housing crowd out private housing investment?A panel VAR approach[J]. Journal of Housing Economics,2007,16(1): 1−20. DOI:10.1016/j.jhe.2006.09.004
19 Li L H,Wu F,Dai M J,et al. Housing affordability of university graduates in Guangzhou[J]. Habitat International,2017,67: 137−147. DOI:10.1016/j.habitatint.2017.07.007
20 Liang W Q,Lu M,Zhang H. Housing prices raise wages:Estimating the unexpected effects of land supply regulation in China[J]. Journal of Housing Economics,2016,33: 70−81. DOI:10.1016/j.jhe.2016.07.002
21 Zhou J,Musterd S. Housing preferences and access to public rental housing among migrants in Chongqing,China[J]. Habitat International,2018,79: 42−50. DOI:10.1016/j.habitatint.2018.07.001