The debate over whether capital controls are needed is very common at home and abroad. By improving the DSGE model of China’s open economy with some important features such as high economic growth, which was originally established by Chang et al. （2015）, and applying it to a different situation with the original case, this paper demonstrates the difficulties of international monetary long-term cooperation about the policy interest rates and inflation rates between China and the United States and the necessity to implement a normalized capital control for China, because of their different stages of economic development. Obviously, this conclusion not only implies that it is difficult for each country in the world to conduct the long-term international currency cooperation on policy target interest rates and inflation rates in the normal period, but also implies that it is difficult for Western and Eastern European countries in the eurozone to implement the unified policy target interest rate and inflation rate, due to their different stages of economic development. Its policy implication is that the process of China’s capital account liberalization must be compatible with the present and future stages of China’s economy development. And this is an objective economic law that we need to follow. Only when China’s economy development level is similar to the developed countries such as the United States, and when its economic growth rate converges with the growth rates of the developed countries, it is possible for China to complete the full capital account liberalization, thereby completely abandoning the long-term normalized capital controls. Of course, this paper is not intended to prevent the normal opening process of China’s financial service industry and the normal capital account liberalization process that is compatible with the stage of economic development. Especially in the case of the US " increasing the interest rate, shrinking the Fed’s balance sheet and cutting the government’s taxes”, which has led to increase the capital outflow pressure, the acceleration of the opening process of China’s financial service industry and the implementation of appropriate capital outflow controls are complementary, and not contradictory. Compared with those developed countries, the capital controls in China and some other developing countries are the combination of a long-term normalized capital control and a loose or tight temporary countercyclical capital outflow or inflow control. The function of normalized capital controls is to maintain the stability of the open economy that is compatible with the development stage; while the role of temporary countercyclical capital outflow or inflow controls is a macro-prudential management tool. The contribution of this paper is that it demonstrates the necessity of the former for the developing countries such as China, and consolidates the former and the latter under the same theoretical framework. This is the main difference between this paper and other literature. It should be emphasized that although this paper demonstrates the reasons for international monetary long-term non-cooperation and the necessity to implement a normalized capital control over a longer period of time, this does not mean that the capital controls have always been required in the real economy. Obviously, the result of the combination of long-term normalized capital control and temporary countercyclical capital outflow or inflow control in the real economy is that some periods are capital outflow controls; some periods are capital inflows; some periods may also be free movement of capital. Currently, a typical example for the latter is that under the background of the increasing of interest rate of the US dollar, the shrinking of the Fed’s balance sheet and the tax cutting of the US government, if those other conditions remain unchanged, for China and some other developing countries, the implementing of interest rate rules about the monetary policy and the floating exchange rate system, combined with a moderate temporary countercyclical capital outflow control, will be more beneficial to the stability of their macroeconomic variables such as capital accounts, output and social welfare. At present, the developing countries such as Turkey are suffering from the consequences of a sharp fall in the exchange rate and capital flight because they have not properly managed their domestic and international economic and financial issues. In contrast, another typical example is that when faced with the impact of the cutting of the US dollar’s interest rate, if the interest rate rule is adopted, the exchange rate of RMB will experience a larger appreciation, and the export will decline. And if other conditions remain unchanged, in order to promote economic growth and improve social welfare, the Chinese government needs to moderately tighten the capital inflow control at this moment.
The Necessity of Normalized Capital Controls: An Analysis based on a DSGE Model with the Perspective of Different Economic Development Stages between the Developing and Developed Countries
Journal of Finance and Economics Vol. 45, Issue 01, pp. 135 - 152 (2019) DOI:10.16538/j.cnki.jfe.2019.01.009
Cao T, Zhao R. Analyzing RMB internationalization from a multi-polarity region perspective[J]. Journal of Financial Research, 2014, (8): 47-63. (In Chinese)
Feng X M. Managing capital inflows: Alternative policy tools for developing countries[J]. The Journal of World Economy, 2001, (6): 23-30. (In Chinese)
Ge Q. The application and effect of macro-prudential measures and capital control measures for policy framework of both capital inflows and outflows of EMEs: Analysis of China’s policy selections for capital flow management during capital account liberalization[J]. Studies of International Finance, 2017, (3): 3-14. (In Chinese)
Guo H Y, Zhang Y L. A study on the spillover effects of central bank balance sheet policies based on portfolio rebalancing transmission channel[J]. World Economy Studies, 2016, (6): 32-42. (In Chinese)
Jin W. A research on China’s capital control intensity[J]. Journal of Financial Research, 2004, (12): 9-23. (In Chinese)
Walsh C E. Monetary Theory and Policy[M]. Peng X Y, Zeng G (Translated). Shanghai: Truth & Wisdom Press, 2012. (In Chinese)
Li X F. The theory and reality of China’s capital flight[J]. Management World, 2000, (4): 123-133. (In Chinese)
Liu J F. A theory about dual currencies area (DCA) & international public currency (IPC): One common area, two kinds of commodity markets, two sets monetary systems[J]. China Economic Quarterly, 2010, (3): 985-1006. (In Chinese)
Liu L Y. Does the overseas “hot money” promote the rise of the stock market and the housing market? Evidence from the Chinese market[J]. Journal of Financial Research, 2008, (10): 48-70. (In Chinese)
Liu Y W. Dilemma of global current account imbalance adjustment: A discussion based on monetary policies[J]. Studies of International Finance, 2013, (3): 22-29. (In Chinese)
Pan Y L, et al. The future reform of the international monetary system and RMB internationalization[M]. Shanghai: Truth & Wisdom Press, Shanghai People’s Publishing House, 2014. (In Chinese)
Xiao L Z, Liu Y Y. Uncovered interest rate parity puzzle: Four hypothesis tests[J]. Management World, 2016, (7): 51-62. (In Chinese)
Yang H Z, Chen J X. Capital flight in China: An estimation and international comparison[J]. The Journal of World Economy, 2000, (1): 21-29. (In Chinese)
Yin D S. Power, interdependence and international monetary cooperation: A study based on the history of the international monetary system[J]. World Economy and Politics, 2011, (8): 30-46. (In Chinese)
You Y, Huang Z Y. Capital controls on debt structure and economic growth[J]. Journal of Financial Research, 2016, (10): 32-47. (In Chinese)
Yu Y D, Xiao L Z. Estimation of China’s capital flight[J]. International Economic Review, 2017, (5): 97-115. (In Chinese)
Yu Y D, Zhang M. The new international trends of capital control and capital account liberalization[J]. International Economic Review, 2012, (5): 68-74. (In Chinese)
Zhang C S. A research on the capital flow management framework devised by IMF[J]. Studies of International Finance, 2016, (4): 13-25. (In Chinese)
Zhang M. The capital account liberalization in China: Operational logic and scenario analysis[J]. World Economy and Politics, 2016, (4): 139-155. (In Chinese)
Zhou X C. Reflections on reforming the international monetary system[J]. China Finance, 2009, (7): 8-9. (In Chinese)
Zhu H. A measurement on the actual degree of capital control in China based on the AB-SETAR model[J]. Studies of International Finance, 2015, (10): 76-86. (In Chinese)
Ahmed S, Zlate A. Capital flows to emerging market economies: A brave new world?[J]. Journal of International Money and Finance, 2014, 48: 221-248. DOI:10.1016/j.jimonfin.2014.05.015
Aviat A, Coeurdacier N. The geography of trade in goods and asset holdings[J]. Journal of International Economics, 2007, 71(1): 22-51. DOI:10.1016/j.jinteco.2006.02.002
Basu S. Intermediate goods and business cycles: Implications for productivity and welfare[J]. The American Economic Review, 1995, 85(3): 512-531.
Basu S, Fernald J G. Returns to scale in U.S. production: Estimates and implications[J]. Journal of Political Economy, 1997, 105(2): 249-283. DOI:10.1086/262073
Bruno V, Shin H S. Capital flows and the risk-taking channel of monetary policy[J]. Journal of Monetary Economics, 2015, 71: 119-132. DOI:10.1016/j.jmoneco.2014.11.011
Chang C, Liu Z, Spiegel M M. Capital controls and optimal Chinese monetary policy[J]. Journal of Monetary Economics, 2015, 74: 1-15. DOI:10.1016/j.jmoneco.2015.04.003
Chari V V, Kehoe P J, McGrattan E R. Sticky price models of the business cycle: Can the contract multiplier solve the persistence problem?[J]. Econometrica, 2000, 68(5): 1151-1179. DOI:10.1111/ecta.2000.68.issue-5
Chen Q Y, Filardo A, He D, et al. Financial crisis, US unconventional monetary policy and international spillovers[J]. Journal of International Money and Finance, 2016, 67: 62-81. DOI:10.1016/j.jimonfin.2015.06.011
Chen S K, Chang M J. Capital control and exchange rate volatility[J]. The North American Journal of Economics and Finance, 2015, 33: 167-177. DOI:10.1016/j.najef.2015.04.005
Eichengreen B, Rose A. Capital controls in the 21st century[J]. Journal of International Money and Finance, 2014, 48: 1-16. DOI:10.1016/j.jimonfin.2014.08.001
Farhi E, Werning I. Dealing with the trilemma: Optimal capital controls with fixed exchange rates[R]. NBER Working Paper No.18199, 2012.
Farhi E, Werning I. Dilemma not trilemma? Capital controls and exchange rates with volatile capital flows[J]. IMF Economic Review, 2014, 62(4): 569-605. DOI:10.1057/imfer.2014.25
Feenstra R C, Luck P A, Obstfeld M, et al. In search of the armington elasticity[R]. NBER Working Paper No.20063, 2014.
Fernández A, Rebucci A, Uribe M. Are capital controls countercyclical?[J]. Journal of Monetary Economics, 2015, 76: 1-14. DOI:10.1016/j.jmoneco.2015.07.001
Han X H, Wei S J. International transmissions of monetary shocks: Between a trilemma and a dilemma[J]. Journal of International Economics, 2018, 110: 205-219. DOI:10.1016/j.jinteco.2017.11.005
Liu Z, Pappa E. Gains from international monetary policy coordination: Does it pay to be different?[J]. Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control, 2008, 32(7): 2085-2117. DOI:10.1016/j.jedc.2007.08.004
 McKinnon R. Optimum currency areas[J]. The American Economic Review, 1963, 53(4): 717-725.
Mundell R A. A theory of optimum currency areas[J]. The American Economic Review, 1961, 51(4): 657-665.
Obstfeld M, Rogoff K. Exchange rate dynamics redux[J]. Journal of Political Economy, 1995, 103(3): 624-660. DOI:10.1086/261997
Ostry J D, Ghosh A R. Obstacles to international policy coordination, and how to overcome them[R]. IMF Staff Discussion Note No.13/11, 2013.
Ostry J D, Ghosh A R, Habermeier K, et al. Capital inflows: The role of controls[R]. IMF Staff Position Note No.10/04, 2010.
Pencavel J. Labor supply of men: A survey[A]. Ashenfelter O C, Layard R. Handbook of labor economics[C]. Amsterdam: Elsevier, 1986.
Prasad E, Rumbaugh T, Wang Q. Putting the cart before the horse? Capital account liberalization and exchange rate flexibility in China[R]. IMF Policy Discussion Paper No.05/1, 2005.
Rey H. Dilemma not trilemma: The global cycle and monetary policy independence[A]. Proceedings-economic policy symposium-jackson hole[C]. Kansas: Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City, 2013.
Rotemberg J J. Sticky prices in the United States[J]. Journal of Political Economy, 1982, 90(6): 1187-1211. DOI:10.1086/261117
Taylor J B. Discretion versus policy rules in practice[J]. Carnegie-Rochester Conference Series on Public Policy, 1993, 39: 195-214. DOI:10.1016/0167-2231(93)90009-L
Taylor J B. International monetary coordination and the great deviation[J]. Journal of Policy Modeling, 2013, 35(3): 463-472. DOI:10.1016/j.jpolmod.2013.03.010
Cite this article
Liu Jianfeng, Pan Yingli. The Necessity of Normalized Capital Controls: An Analysis based on a DSGE Model with the Perspective of Different Economic Development Stages between the Developing and Developed Countries[J]. Journal of Finance and Economics, 2019, 45(1): 135-152.
Previous: The Intergenerational Transition of Family Business and the Thoughts of Pan-Familizational Equity Financing in Modern China