基于公司治理视角的财务重述研究综述
外国经济与管理 2007 年 第 29 卷第 11 期, 页码:32 - 37
摘要
参考文献
摘要
近年来上市公司财务重述现象日趋频繁,引起了学术界的广泛关注。本文首次从公司治理视角对财务重述相关研究进行了全面回顾,着重从财务重述动机、财务重述影响因素和财务重述是否导致管理层变更等方面进行了述评,梳理和归纳了国外最新研究进展,最后总结和论述了这些研究成果对于我国上市公司财务重述监管的借鉴和启示。
[1]Pal mrose,Z V,Richardson,VJ,and Scholz,S.Determinants of market reactions to restatement announcements[J].Journal of Ac-counting and Economics,2004,37:59-89.
[2]Hirschey,M,Pal mrose,Z V,and Scholz,S.Long-term market underreaction to accounting restatements[R].Working Paper,Uni-versity of Kansas,2005.
[3]Wu,M.Earnings restatements:Acapital market perspective[R].Working Paper,New York University,2002.
[4]US General Accounting Office.Financial statement restatements:Trends,market i mpacts,regulatory responses,and remaining chal-lenges[R].GAO-03-138,Washington D.C.,2002.
[5]US General Accounting Office.Financial restatements:Update of public company trends,market i mpacts,and regulatory enforce-ment activities[R].GAO-06-678,Washington D.C.,2006.
[6]Jensen,M,and Meckling,W.Theory of the firm:Managerial behavior,agency costs and ownership structure[J].Journal of Finan-cial Economics,1976,3:305-360.
[7]Philippon,T,et al.CEOincentives and earnings management[J].Journal of Financial Economics,2006,80(3):511-529.
[8]Beneish,M.Incentives and penalties related to earnings overstatements that violate GAAP[J].The Accounting Review,1999,74:425-457.
[9]Li,Oliver-Zhen,and Yuan,Zhang.Financial restatement announcements and insider trading[R].Working Paper,University ofNotre Dame,2006.
[10]Kedia,Si mi,and Thomas,Philippon.The economics of fraudulent accounting[J].Reviewof Financial Studies,forthcoming,2007.
[11]Agrawal,A,and Cooper,R T.Insider trading before accounting scandals[R].Working Paper,University of Alabama,2007.
[12]Burns,Natasha,and Si mi,Kedia.Thei mpact of performance-based compensation on misreporting[J].Journal of Financial Econom-ics,2006,79:35-67.
[13]Burns,Natasha,and Si mi Kedia.Executive option exercises and financial misreporting[J].Journal of Banking and Finance,forth-coming,2007.
[14]Kinney,WR,Jr,and McDaniel,L S.Characteristics of firms correcting previously reported quarterly earnings[J].Journal of Ac-counting and Economics,1989,11:71-93.
[15]Defond,ML,and Jiambalvo,J.Incidence and circumstances of accounting errors[J].The Accounting Review,1991,66:643-655.
[16]Ahmed,Kamran,and John Goodwin.An empirical investigation of earnings restatements by Australian firms[J].Accounting andFinance,2007,47:1-22.
[17]Hol mstrom,B.Moral hazardin teams[J].Bell Journal of Economics,1982,13(2):324-340.
[18]Agarwal,A,Jaffe,J F,and Karpoff,J M.Management turnover and governance changes following the revelation of fraud[J].Journal of Lawand Economics,1999,17:309-342.
[19]Srinivasan,S.Consequences of financial reporting failure for outside directors:Evidence from accounting restatements and auditcommittee members[J].Journal of Accounting Research 2005,43(2):291-334.
[20]Desai,H,Hogan C,and Wilkins,M.The reputational penalty for aggressive accounting:Earnings restatements and managementturnover[J].The Accounting Review,2006,81:83-112.
①目前对于“财务报告重新表述”(financial restatement)尚无统一的定义。美国会计总署(United States General Accounting Office,GAO)在2002年10月的一份调查报告中指出,财务报告重新表述是指公司自愿或在审计师、监管当局的敦促下修正先前报告的财务信息。Skinner(1997)认为,财务报告发布后若发现错误或误导性信息,而且发布者知道或者应该知道人们仍然相信全部或部分报告内容,那么公司管理层就有责任纠正先前的财务报告。Pal mrose和Scholz(2004)则认为,财务重述是对财务报告的确认,因为先前向公众报告和向SEC提交的财务报告不符合公认会计准则。
②财务重述通常造成4%~12%的市场价值损失,具体因样本而异(如GAO,2002;Anderson和Yohn,2002;Pal mrose等,2004;Hir-schey等,2005)。然而,财务重述造成的经济后果和影响绝不仅限于公司市场价值损失。财务重述还将导致大投资者减持股票和减少交易(Hribar等,2004;Demirkan,2006);也可能导致代价高昂的诉讼和赔偿(Jones和Weingram,1997;Pal mrose和Scholz,2004);甚至会对同行业上市公司带来负面“传染效应”(Gonen,2003;Efendi等,2005)。此外,有学者发现,财务重述还可能导致市场信息不对称性的加剧(Anderson和Yohn,2002)、公司盈余质量(进而会计信息质量)下降(Anderson和Yohn,2002;Wu,2002)以及公司资本成本显著增加(Dechow等,1996;Hribar和Jenkins,2004)等。
[2]Hirschey,M,Pal mrose,Z V,and Scholz,S.Long-term market underreaction to accounting restatements[R].Working Paper,Uni-versity of Kansas,2005.
[3]Wu,M.Earnings restatements:Acapital market perspective[R].Working Paper,New York University,2002.
[4]US General Accounting Office.Financial statement restatements:Trends,market i mpacts,regulatory responses,and remaining chal-lenges[R].GAO-03-138,Washington D.C.,2002.
[5]US General Accounting Office.Financial restatements:Update of public company trends,market i mpacts,and regulatory enforce-ment activities[R].GAO-06-678,Washington D.C.,2006.
[6]Jensen,M,and Meckling,W.Theory of the firm:Managerial behavior,agency costs and ownership structure[J].Journal of Finan-cial Economics,1976,3:305-360.
[7]Philippon,T,et al.CEOincentives and earnings management[J].Journal of Financial Economics,2006,80(3):511-529.
[8]Beneish,M.Incentives and penalties related to earnings overstatements that violate GAAP[J].The Accounting Review,1999,74:425-457.
[9]Li,Oliver-Zhen,and Yuan,Zhang.Financial restatement announcements and insider trading[R].Working Paper,University ofNotre Dame,2006.
[10]Kedia,Si mi,and Thomas,Philippon.The economics of fraudulent accounting[J].Reviewof Financial Studies,forthcoming,2007.
[11]Agrawal,A,and Cooper,R T.Insider trading before accounting scandals[R].Working Paper,University of Alabama,2007.
[12]Burns,Natasha,and Si mi,Kedia.Thei mpact of performance-based compensation on misreporting[J].Journal of Financial Econom-ics,2006,79:35-67.
[13]Burns,Natasha,and Si mi Kedia.Executive option exercises and financial misreporting[J].Journal of Banking and Finance,forth-coming,2007.
[14]Kinney,WR,Jr,and McDaniel,L S.Characteristics of firms correcting previously reported quarterly earnings[J].Journal of Ac-counting and Economics,1989,11:71-93.
[15]Defond,ML,and Jiambalvo,J.Incidence and circumstances of accounting errors[J].The Accounting Review,1991,66:643-655.
[16]Ahmed,Kamran,and John Goodwin.An empirical investigation of earnings restatements by Australian firms[J].Accounting andFinance,2007,47:1-22.
[17]Hol mstrom,B.Moral hazardin teams[J].Bell Journal of Economics,1982,13(2):324-340.
[18]Agarwal,A,Jaffe,J F,and Karpoff,J M.Management turnover and governance changes following the revelation of fraud[J].Journal of Lawand Economics,1999,17:309-342.
[19]Srinivasan,S.Consequences of financial reporting failure for outside directors:Evidence from accounting restatements and auditcommittee members[J].Journal of Accounting Research 2005,43(2):291-334.
[20]Desai,H,Hogan C,and Wilkins,M.The reputational penalty for aggressive accounting:Earnings restatements and managementturnover[J].The Accounting Review,2006,81:83-112.
①目前对于“财务报告重新表述”(financial restatement)尚无统一的定义。美国会计总署(United States General Accounting Office,GAO)在2002年10月的一份调查报告中指出,财务报告重新表述是指公司自愿或在审计师、监管当局的敦促下修正先前报告的财务信息。Skinner(1997)认为,财务报告发布后若发现错误或误导性信息,而且发布者知道或者应该知道人们仍然相信全部或部分报告内容,那么公司管理层就有责任纠正先前的财务报告。Pal mrose和Scholz(2004)则认为,财务重述是对财务报告的确认,因为先前向公众报告和向SEC提交的财务报告不符合公认会计准则。
②财务重述通常造成4%~12%的市场价值损失,具体因样本而异(如GAO,2002;Anderson和Yohn,2002;Pal mrose等,2004;Hir-schey等,2005)。然而,财务重述造成的经济后果和影响绝不仅限于公司市场价值损失。财务重述还将导致大投资者减持股票和减少交易(Hribar等,2004;Demirkan,2006);也可能导致代价高昂的诉讼和赔偿(Jones和Weingram,1997;Pal mrose和Scholz,2004);甚至会对同行业上市公司带来负面“传染效应”(Gonen,2003;Efendi等,2005)。此外,有学者发现,财务重述还可能导致市场信息不对称性的加剧(Anderson和Yohn,2002)、公司盈余质量(进而会计信息质量)下降(Anderson和Yohn,2002;Wu,2002)以及公司资本成本显著增加(Dechow等,1996;Hribar和Jenkins,2004)等。
引用本文
魏志华, 王毅辉. 基于公司治理视角的财务重述研究综述[J]. 外国经济与管理, 2007, 29(11): 32–37.
导出参考文献,格式为:
上一篇:企业非市场战略研究前沿探析