面值退市制度对企业高送转行为的治理效应研究
The Governance Effects of the Par-value Delisting Rule on Corporate High Stock Dividend Practices
DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.jfe.20260731.401
[1]黄欣怡,付广燕,蔡祥.面值退市制度对企业高送转行为的治理效应研究[J/OL].财经研究,2026,52(09):64-78[2026-11-11].https://doi.org/10.16538/j.cnki.jfe.20260731.401.
摘要
文章基于面值退市的视角考察监管制度改革对企业股票送转行为的治理作用。文章研究发现,在面值退市制度颁布实施后,该制度出台前股票送转比例较高的企业送转比例明显减小,实施高送转的概率显著下降。导致上述结果的内在机制在于:第一,企业通过减少高送转行为以避免股票价格的大幅度除权调整,从而降低面值退市风险;第二,在低股价的情形下,风险较高的企业因股价过度波动触发面值退市的可能性更高,因此上市公司有更强烈的意愿抑制送转行为;第三,面值退市制度促使投资者更为理性地看待高送转行为,从而降低了高送转公告的正向超额收益,弱化了企业实施高送转的动机。基于股权特征的进一步研究显示,面值退市制度对高送转行为的抑制作用在大股东与机构投资者持股比例较高的企业、非国有企业与进行定向增发的企业中更为显著。文章的结论为检验面值退市制度的实施效果及其对高送转行为的治理成效提供了经验证据。
High stock dividend plans are widely adopted by listed firms in China and are often met with favorable market reactions. When undertaken to cater to investors’ irrational preferences, high stock dividend plans may not only mislead investors but also adversely affect firms’ long-term performance.
Focusing on the disciplining role of regulation, this paper employs a DID design to examine how the par-value delisting rule affects corporate stock dividend decisions. It thereby provides evidence on both the effectiveness of the par-value delisting policy and its governance effect on the “high stock dividend” phenomenon. The results show that firms with higher pre-policy stock dividend ratios become significantly less likely to undertake high stock dividend plans following the introduction of the par-value delisting rule. The study further investigates the mechanisms through which the rule affects corporate stock dividend decisions. First, high stock dividends result in substantial downward ex-rights adjustments in share prices, thereby increasing exposure to par-value delisting risks and directly inducing listed firms to modify their stock dividend strategies. Second, when high stock dividend plans result in low share prices, firms with greater risks may experience more pronounced stock price volatility and are therefore more likely to breach the par-value delisting threshold. These firms consequently have stronger incentives to reduce high stock dividend practices. Finally, the par-value delisting rule weakens investors’ favorable expectations regarding high stock dividends and significantly reduces the positive abnormal returns associated with their announcements, which diminishes firms’ incentives to implement such plans.
This paper makes the following contributions: First, it extends the literature on the determinants of high stock dividend practices from the perspective of delisting system reform. Second, whereas prior studies have primarily focused on how financial delisting criteria affect corporate behavior, this paper investigates the par-value delisting rule and thus offers a new perspective on the economic consequences of delisting regulation. Third, it provides useful implications for securities regulators, listed firms, and investors seeking a deeper understanding of the governance effects of the par-value delisting rule.
关键词: 面值退市,高送转,股利政策