政府财会监督的网络溢出效应研究
A Research on the Network Spillover Effect of Governmental Financial Supervision: A Perspective Based on Common Ownership
DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.jfe.20260430.101
[1]李星,丁文甫,祝继高.政府财会监督的网络溢出效应研究[J/OL].财经研究,2026,52(09):19-33, 63[2026-11-11].https://doi.org/10.16538/j.cnki.jfe.20260430.101.
摘要
政府财会监督是维护资本市场稳定、提升会计信息质量的重要制度安排。当前,监督对象规模庞大与监督资源有限之间的矛盾较为突出。在此背景下,如何借助市场力量放大政府监督效能,是国家监督体系设计中需要关注的重要问题。文章将市场监督视角引入财会监督治理效应研究中,考察了政府财会监督能否通过机构投资者共同所有权网络向未被检查企业外溢。研究发现,政府财会监督的治理效应能够通过共同所有权网络实现溢出,显著改善未被检查企业的会计信息质量,具体表现为异常应计水平下降。机制分析结果显示,机构投资者的主动监督是溢出效应产生的重要推动因素,当机构投资者具有较强的监督意愿和监督能力时,该溢出效应更加显著。进一步研究发现,溢出效应主要通过机构投资者派驻董事并参与公司治理实现,且更倾向于出现在市场化程度较高、政府干预较弱、交通基础设施完善的地区,这说明监督成本会对溢出效应的方向和强度产生影响。文章拓展了政府财会监督研究的理论边界,揭示了政府监督与市场监督协同治理的潜力,为完善国家监督体系提供了经验证据和政策启示。
Governmental financial supervision is an important mechanism for improving accounting information quality and maintaining capital market order. Yet the large number of regulated firms and the limited scope of direct inspections raise a critical question: Will the governance effects of financial supervision extend beyond inspected firms through market-based channels? Taking the quality inspections of accounting information by the Ministry of Finance as the research setting, this paper examines whether governmental financial supervision spills over to non-inspected firms through common ownership networks formed by institutional investors.
Using manually-collected inspection data, institutional ownership data, and financial information on A-share listed companies from 2008 to 2024, this paper constructs a novel measure of firms’ exposure to financial supervision spillovers through common ownership. The results show that non-inspected firms more closely connected to inspected firms through common institutional investors exhibit significantly lower abnormal accruals, indicating improved accounting information quality. Further analysis shows that the spillover effect is mainly driven by institutional investors’ active monitoring, especially when they have stronger moni- toring incentives and longer holding horizons. The effect operates through active governance engagement, as higher exposure is associated with a greater likelihood of institutional investors appointing directors or senior governance personnel. It is also stronger in regions with higher marketization, weaker government intervention, and better transportation infrastructure, suggesting that monitoring costs shape the direction and strength of the spillover effect.
This paper extends research on governmental financial supervision from direct regulatory effects to network-based external spillovers and identifies common institutional investors as collaborative governance actors linking public supervision with market monitoring. Unlike studies emphasizing information intermediaries, this paper highlights how institutional investors transform regulatory signals and cross-firm comparisons into governance actions. The findings suggest that regulators can improve supervisory efficiency by considering firms’ network positions, enhancing inspection-result disclosure, and encouraging institutional investors’ gover- nance participation, thereby amplifying the effects of limited regulatory resources and improving information quality in the capital market.
关键词: 政府财会监督,溢出效应,共同所有权理论,市场监督,协同治理
参考文献
数据公开
| 标题 | 文件大小 | 下载 |
|---|---|---|
| 数据及程序代码 | 4.5 MB | |
| 图表 | 39.2 KB |