新企业商业模式形成过程中认知与行动的互动:一项跨案例研究
A Research on the Cognition-Action Interaction in the Formation of New Venture Business Models: A Cross-Case Study
DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.2019.02.004
[1]张敬伟,杜鑫,成文,田志凯.新企业商业模式形成过程中认知与行动的互动:一项跨案例研究[J/OL].外国经济与管理,2019,41(02):44-57[2026-11-20].https://doi.org/10.16538/j.cnki.fem.2019.02.004.
摘要
近年来,新企业商业模式形成过程研究得到了学者们的广泛关注,学习与认知视角展开的研究分别从行动与认知切入,却忽略了认知与行动的互动演化。本文借鉴已有的认知与行动互动的观点,建立了“认知引发行动,行动反馈认知”的概念框架,用以解读新企业商业模式的形成过程。基于对两家互联网企业的跨案例研究得到如下初步结论:创业者的初始商业模式认知体现为商业概念假设和商业逻辑假设,这些认知内容来源于创业者的先前经验、信息扫描与心理活动机制;初始商业模式认知是新企业开展探索行动的起点,有助于指引创业者有目的地开展行动,以提升行动的有效性;创业者采取内部检验、外部检验、直接检验和间接检验等多种行动方式检验初始商业模式认知,虽然资源匮乏的创业者更倾向于短期内低成本的检验方式,但综合使用上述行动方式更为有效;创业者接受行动反馈后的认知调整是创业推理的结果,相比商业逻辑假设,源自创业者长期从业经验的商业概念假设更难发生变动。这些发现丰富并拓展了创业情境下的商业模式研究,对于新企业创业和初期成长实践也具有重要启发意义。
It is a well-accepted argument that the most important strategy for a new venture is to explore and build a viable business model. How to accomplish this task is explicated by two dominant perspectives. The first line of research emphasizes learning actions such as trial-and-error and experimentation while the other stream believes that the viable business model originates from the entrepreneur’s cognitions. Building on an emerging field of research which explores the relationship between cognition and action and across-case approach, we draw several tentative conclusion. First, initial business model cognitions are composed of business concept hypothesis and business logic hypothesis. The former originates from such mental mechanisms as analogical thinking and/or concept combination which is triggered by experience and perception, while the latter comes from prior experience and new information processing. Second, initial business model cognitions provide a starting point for learning actions. Initial business model cognitions, aiming at guiding actions purposefully and improving action effects, can iterate through an entrepreneurship theorizing process. Third, entrepreneurs can use the combination of internal and/or external, immediate and/or indirect methods to validate initial business model hypothesis. Resource differences may influence the way new ventures validate initial hypothesis(resource-constrained new ventures would prefer low cost methods in the short run). A combination of such methods contributes to a better performance in searching for a viable business model. Finally, the influence of feedbacks from learning actions on business model adaptation decisions is the outcome of an entrepreneurship theorizing process. Evidence shows that business logic hypothesis is subjected to more pivots than business concept hypothesis since the latter is usually supported by long-term prior experiences. This study adds to the knowledge of the following research streams. First, by inquiry into the interaction between cognitions and actions, we provide the dimension of initial cognitions which acts as the starting point for learning actions. We also add to the learning school that the content being learned during the process. Second, we provide an empirical investigation of business model schema research. We provide empirical support for the view of entrepreneurship theorizing, and specify the source and evolution of initial cognitions. We also find four learning actions which serve as major means to validate initial business model hypothesis and provide a better understanding of their effectiveness. Finally, by investigating the source of the cognition inertia of business concept hypothesis, we provide two possible explanations from the perspectives of prior experience and entrepreneurial theorizing, thus shed light on the cognition mechanism of new venture business model adaptation.
关键词: 商业模式,认知,行动,互动,案例研究