经济学和心理学的整合与行为经济学的拓展及其应用——2017年度诺贝尔经济学奖得主理查德•塞勒主要经济理论贡献述评
The Integration of Economics and Psychology and Extension of Behavioral Economics with Applications——A Review of Main Contributions by 2017 Nobel Economics Laureate
DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.2017.11.010
[1]李宝良,郭其友.经济学和心理学的整合与行为经济学的拓展及其应用——2017年度诺贝尔经济学奖得主理查德•塞勒主要经济理论贡献述评[J/OL].外国经济与管理,2017,39(11):138-152[2026-11-11].https://doi.org/10.16538/j.cnki.fem.2017.11.010.
摘要
理查德•塞勒因其对行为经济学的贡献而被授予2017年度诺贝尔经济学奖。本文对塞勒在经济学和心理学整合及行为经济学理论的拓展与应用方面的主要贡献做了较为系统的述评。首先,在简要概述塞勒的学术生涯及主要论著后,着重阐明塞勒在行为经济学由学术异端到主流经济学分支演变过程中所扮演的角色;其次,在概述有限理性、有限意志力和有限自利三个行为经济学基本要素的基础上,着重阐述塞勒对禀赋效应与心理账户、时间偏好的动态不一致性与自我控制、公平与社会偏好理论及应用方面的主要研究;再次,阐述塞勒在应对传统金融学质疑中对夯实有限理性和有限套利这两个行为金融学基石所做的主要贡献;最后,简要评析塞勒的理论研究特点及其理论的应用借鉴意义。
The American economist Richard Thaler was awarded the 2017 Nobel Prize in Economics for his contributions to behavioral economics. This paper systematically reviews the main contributions to the development and application of behavioral economics made by Thaler in the process of integrating economics and psychology. Firstly, we briefly overview Thaler’s academic career and major works, highlighting the role played by Thaler in the making of behavioral economics and the transition of behavioral economics from an interdisciplinary subject to a branch of mainstream economics. Secondly, based on an overview of the three basic elements of behavioral economics, namely bounded rationality, bounded willpower and bounded self-interest, we emphasize the main contributions made by Thaler to the theories and applications of mental accounting, time preference inconsistency and the problem of self-control as well as fairness and social preference. Specifically, Thaler used loss aversion to explain the endowment effect, developed mental accounting to explain how people make financial decisions by creating different accounts for different expenditures in their minds, and then examined how such mental accounting leads to desirable and undesirable effects; he provided evidence of time-inconsistent preference, developed the planner-doer model to analyze the self-control problem and then applied to the design of savings plan; Thaler documented the characteristics of fairness through experiments and surveys and explored the role that fairness played in the economic life. These contributions consist of the basic elements of behavioral economics on which the framework of behavioral economics is established. Thirdly, we discuss how Thaler responded to the challenges raised by traditional financial economists when applying behavioral economics to finance, and review the main researches to establish the two building blocks of behavioral finance, namely investor psychology and limited arbitrage, which makes Thaler one of the founders of behavioral finance. Specifically, Thaler’s contributions to investor psychology on asset prices included his documentation of the evidence of overreaction and his new explanation of equity premium puzzle based on myopic loss aversion; and his contributions to limited arbitrage included his examination of closed-end fund puzzle and the negative equity value. Finally, Some characteristics of the research of Thaler and the theoretical significance and practical value of behavioral economics is discussed. Thaler is skilled at observing the difference of theory and reality and finding out the theory-induced blindness; more importantly, he is good at using suitable situation to demonstrate the effect of different human traits. Thus, Thaler’s contributions have important implications for economic research and education. Moreover, we discuss the implication of Thaler’s contributions to economic transition, of which we pay special attention to potential value nudging in promoting the modernization of national governance system and governance capacity.
关键词: 理查德·塞勒,有限理性,有限意志力,有限自利,行为经济学,行为金融学