勇敢追随行为研究述评与展望

The Courageous Followership Behavior: A literature Review and Prospects

曹元坤,周青,刘善仕,祝振兵

2019 第 41 卷 第 09 期 页码 47-60

DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20190603.002

PDF全文下载 HTML全文

摘要

勇敢追随行为是指追随者为达到辅佐领导共同实现组织目标但又不违背良知的目的,与领导者建立密切互动的关系,并采取主动负责、勇于服务、勇于挑战、勇于变革和采取道德行为(离开)等一系列行为,对组织成功以及监督、规范和约束不良领导力起助推作用。本文梳理了1995—2018年国外勇敢追随行为实证研究脉络,从哲学、心理学、组织行为学视角,构建了勇敢追随行为路径,对勇敢追随行为的前因和结果变量进行了推理,对勇敢追随行为的两面性、适应性和跨文化适用性等问题的研究前景进行了展望。勇敢追随行为的实证研究,是对职场勇敢行为研究的拓展和追随力研究领域的丰富;勇敢追随行为的理论发展,对组织成员的职业发展和组织预测、选拔和培养勇敢追随者具有指导意义。

The Courageous Followership Behavior(CFB)means that followers are courageous to build up good interdynamic relations with leaders, take responsibility, serve, challenge, change and take moral action(leave)for the purpose of reaching organizational goals. CFB plays a role in supervising, regulating, and restraining the toxic leadership, furthermore, it is also a key point for organizations to find success. Considering there does exist CFB in Chinese context,and the cultural differences between China and the West, we deem it necessary to implement the related studies for the sake of practical application and theory development.This paper reviews the English literature on CFB from 1995 to 2018, compares CFB with Positive Deviance/Voice Behavior/Proactive Behavior/other Active Followership Behaviors.We find that previous studies mainly focus on the relationship between follower behaviors and levels within an organization, the relationship existed between leadership styles/organizational culture/industry and followership styles, the relationship between the supervisor’s satisfaction with an employee’s performance and CFB. The researcher’s work show that Courageous Followers assist leaders and organizations in getting to goals by taking the moral high ground. Beyond that, the CFB theory provides a comprehensive explanation and description of followers, follower behaviors, and followership. Again, the antecedents and outcome variables of CFB are analyzed and summarized in this study, and the pathway of CFB is given from the perspectives of philosophy/psychology/organizational behavior. When followers feel a challenging situation such as a workplace error, an abuse of power,or someone in need, they will engage in courageous actions or give up after careful deliberation. By analyzing the mediating effect of leadership/LMX and the moderating effect of circumstance factors, we find that CFB has two-blade function for organizations, leaders and followers themselves. In the end, the future directions in CFB research are prospected as belows:  Dimension and measurement of CFB in the Chinese context. Most foreign scholars use the Followership Profile, an instrument developed by Dixon(2003). Due to the rare study on CFB in China, domestic scholars have a big part to play, such as improving the scale, examining the dimensions, or carrying out empirical research through interviews, measurements and questionnaire methods.  Two-side effect and adaptability of CFB. Given that humans have an adaptive followership psychology which enables them to make a favorable choice, and the effect of courageous action will have a marked impact on other individuals, it will be interesting and meaningful to build a map of CFB paths within Chinese organizations through positive studies.  Cross-cultural applicability. The preponderance of research and literature on followership has been focused on North American and European culture. We suggest some attempts at comparative research across national/cultural boundaries and relevant assessments of followership styles/growth paths by using Boccialetti’s (1995)instrument, which is organized around the study of distance, deference, and divergence in authority relations. To sum up, the research on CFB in China will not only enrich the Followership Theory and the Workplace Courage Theory, but also contribute to personal career development and organizations developing courageous followers.

参考文献

1 曹元坤, 许晟. 对追随力理论中若干观点的思考[J]. 江西社会科学,2013, (2): 203-206. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1004-518X.2013.02.038
7 Bastardoz N, Van Vugt M. The nature of followership: Evolutionary analysis and review[J]. The Leadership Quarterly,2019, 30(1): 81-95. DOI:10.1016/j.leaqua.2018.09.004
8 Batcheller J. Learning how to dance: Courageous followership: A CNO case study[J]. Nurse Leader,2012, 10(2): 22-24. DOI:10.1016/j.mnl.2011.12.006
9 Bennett R J, Robinson S L. Development of a measure of workplace deviance[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology,2000, 85(3): 349-360. DOI:10.1037/0021-9010.85.3.349
10 Benson A J, Hardy J, Eys M. Contextualizing leaders’ interpretations of proactive followership[J]. Journal of Organizational Behavior,2016, 37(7): 949-966. DOI:10.1002/job.2077
11 Blair B A, Bligh M C. Looking for leadership in all the wrong places: The impact of culture on proactive followership and follower dissent[J]. Journal of Social Issues,2018, 74(1): 129-143. DOI:10.1111/josi.2018.74.issue-1
12 Chaleff I. The courageous follower: Standing up to and for our leaders[J]. NASSP Bulletin,1997, 81(586): 119. DOI:10.1177/019263659708158616
13 Chaleff I. In praise of followership style assessments[J]. Journal of Leadership Studies,2016, 10(3): 45-48. DOI:10.1002/jls.2016.10.issue-3
15 Collinson D. Rethinking followership: A post-structuralist analysis of follower identities[J]. The Leadership Quarterly,2006, 17(2): 179-189. DOI:10.1016/j.leaqua.2005.12.005
16 Crant J M. Proactive behavior in organizations[J]. Journal of Management,2000, 26(3): 435-462. DOI:10.1177/014920630002600304
18 Dedahanov A T, Lee D H, Rhee J, et al. Entrepreneur’s paternalistic leadership style and creativity: The mediating role of employee voice[J]. Management Decision,2016, 54(9): 2310-2324. DOI:10.1108/MD-11-2015-0537
21 Duff R A. Courage: A philosophical investigation by Douglas Walton[J]. Canadian Journal of Philosophy,1989, 19(1): 131-144. DOI:10.1080/00455091.1989.10716473
22 Epitropaki O, Kark R, Mainemelis C, et al. Leadership and followership identity processes: A multilevel review[J]. The Leadership Quarterly,2017, 28(1): 104-129. DOI:10.1016/j.leaqua.2016.10.003
23 Finfgeld D L. Courage as a process of pushing beyond the struggle[J]. Qualitative Health Research,1999, 9(6): 803-814. DOI:10.1177/104973299129122298
24 Fobbs T. The evaluation of a paradigm: The critical examination of the influence of followership styles and courageous follower attributes on hotel customer-contact employee job satisfaction[D]. Minneapolis: Capella University, 2010.
27 Goud N H. Courage: Its nature and development[J]. The Journal of Humanistic Counseling, Education and Development,2005, 44(1): 102-116. DOI:10.1002/(ISSN)2164-490X
28 Hannah S T, Sweeney P J, Lester P B. Toward a courageous mindset: The subjective act and experience of courage[J]. The Journal of Positive Psychology,2007, 2(2): 129-135. DOI:10.1080/17439760701228854
29 Jit R, Sharma C S, Kawatra M. Servant leadership and conflict resolution: A qualitative study[J]. International Journal of Conflict Management,2016, 27(4): 591-612. DOI:10.1108/IJCMA-12-2015-0086
31 Kayser D N, Greitemeyer T, Fischer P, et al. Why mood affects help giving, but not moral courage: Comparing two types of prosocial behaviour[J]. European Journal of Social Psychology,2010, 40(7): 1136-1157. DOI:10.1002/ejsp.v40:7
33 Kilmann R H, O’Hara L A, Strauss J P. Developing and validating a quantitative measure of organizational courage[J]. Journal of Business and Psychology,2010, 25(1): 15-23. DOI:10.1007/s10869-009-9125-1
35 Krasikova D V, Green S G, Lebreton J M. Destructive leadership: A theoretical review, integration, and future research agenda[J]. Journal of Management,2013, 39(5): 1308-1338. DOI:10.1177/0149206312471388
36 Mansur J, Sobral F, Goldszmidt R B, et al. Shades of paternalistic leadership across cultures[J]. Journal of World Business,2017, 52(5): 702-713. DOI:10.1016/j.jwb.2017.06.003
38 Ng T W H, Feldman D C. Employee voice behavior: A meta-analytic test of the conservation of resources framework[J]. Journal of Organizational Behavior,2012, 33(2): 216-234. DOI:10.1002/job.754
39 Oc B, Bashshur M R. Followership, leadership and social influence[J]. The Leadership Quarterly,2013, 24(6): 919-934. DOI:10.1016/j.leaqua.2013.10.006
40 Parker S K, Bindl U K, Strauss K. Making things happen: A model of proactive motivation[J]. Journal of Management,2010, 36(4): 827-856. DOI:10.1177/0149206310363732
41 Parker S K, Williams H M, Turner N. Modeling the antecedents of proactive behavior at work[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology,2006, 91(3): 636-652. DOI:10.1037/0021-9010.91.3.636
42 Rate C R, Clarke J A, Lindsay D R, et al. Implicit theories of courage[J]. The Journal of Positive Psychology,2007, 2(2): 80-98. DOI:10.1080/17439760701228755
43 Schilpzand P, Hekman D R, Mitchell T R. An inductively generated typology and process model of workplace courage[J]. Organization Science,2015, 26(1): 52-77. DOI:10.1287/orsc.2014.0928
44 Sekerka L E, Bagozzi R P. Moral courage in the workplace: Moving to and from the desire and decision to act[J]. Business Ethics: A European Review,2007, 16(2): 132-149. DOI:10.1111/beer.2007.16.issue-2
45 Shih H A, Wijaya N H S. Team-member exchange, voice behavior, and creative work involvement[J]. International Journal of Manpower,2017, 38(3): 417-431. DOI:10.1108/IJM-09-2015-0139
46 Shin Y, Kim M J. Antecedents and mediating mechanisms of proactive behavior: Application of the theory of planned behavior[J]. Asia Pacific Journal of Management,2015, 32(1): 289-310. DOI:10.1007/s10490-014-9393-9
47 Spreitzer G M, Sonenshein S. Toward the construct definition of positive deviance[J]. American Behavioral Scientist,2004, 47(6): 828-847. DOI:10.1177/0002764203260212
48 Tang M Z. How to enhance employee voice behavior based on game theory[J]. Modern Economy,2015, 6(3): 398-403. DOI:10.4236/me.2015.63037
51 Uhl-Bien M, Riggio R E, Lowe K B, et al. Followership theory: A review and research agenda[J]. The Leadership Quarterly,2014, 25(1): 83-104. DOI:10.1016/j.leaqua.2013.11.007
53 Woodard C R. Hardiness and the concept of courage[J]. Consulting Psychology Journal: Practice and Research,2004, 56(3): 173-185. DOI:10.1037/1065-9293.56.3.173
54 Zhu W C, He H W, Treviño L K, et al. Ethical leadership and follower voice and performance: The role of follower identifications and entity morality beliefs[J]. The Leadership Quarterly,2015, 26(5): 702-718. DOI:10.1016/j.leaqua.2015.01.004