定性研究可信度释疑——从历史沿革与哲学基础谈起

An Explanation on the Trustworthiness of Qualitative Research: Based on Historical Evolution and Philosophical Foundations

万倩雯,卫田

2024 第 46 卷 第 02 期 页码 135-152

DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20221209.101

PDF全文下载 HTML全文

摘要

定性研究的重要性日益凸显。然而,鉴于定性研究有其复杂的哲学基础,加之定量研究范式处于强势和主导地位,学者们对“如何评价并提升定性研究可信度”感到疑惑。为了有效地释疑解惑,本文首先回溯定性研究的历史沿革,审视实证主义、诠释主义、社会建构主义三类哲学基础,以便揭示定性研究的本质特征;其次,结合顶级期刊论文阐释、对比不同哲学基础的定性研究之可信度评价标准与提升举措,以明确定性研究可信度的内核以及哲学基础对评价标准的影响;最后,归纳研究结论,展望定性研究发展趋势,预测可信度评价标准的演化。本文试图站在历史发展和哲学基础的角度,全面审视和阐释定性研究可信度问题,系统地解答学者对定性研究可信度的疑惑,以期促进构建具有中国特色的管理学理论。

Qualitative research, with its roots deeply in practice, has been recognized as an undeniable research method in developing distinctive Chinese management theories. The trustworthiness of qualitative research ensures the explanation power and effectiveness of developed theories. However, the complexity of philosophical foundations of qualitative research confuses scholars on “how to assess and improve the trustworthiness of qualitative research”. This paper makes an attempt to explain the trustworthiness of diverse qualitative research methods from the two aspects of historical evolution and philosophical foundations, and give illustrations through published articles. Firstly, tracing the history of qualitative research, this paper finds that qualitative research tackles with the most important phenomenon in its era, with a specific focus on critical social units. Different social units require distinct qualitative research methods, so qualitative research is historically pluralistic. Second, from the perspectives of ontology and epistemology, this paper explains the three basic philosophical foundations of qualitative research methods: positivism, interpretivism, and social constructionism. After that, it selects and analyzes qualitative articles in top management journals to clearly illustrate the criteria in assessing the trustworthiness of three qualitative research methods, aiming to vividly show the approaches and actions of improving the trustworthiness of qualitative research. Third, this paper prospects the future of qualitative research and expects the evolution of the criteria in assessing the trustworthiness. In sum, from a historical and philosophical perspective, this paper provides a holistic and detailed explanation on the confusion of scholars on the trustworthiness of qualitative research, which sets the basis of developing distinctive Chinese management theories.

参考文献

1 杜运周, 贾良定. 组态视角与定性比较分析(QCA): 管理学研究的一条新道路[J]. 管理世界, 2017, 33(6): 155-167.
2 贾旭东, 何光远, 陈佳莉, 等. 基于“扎根精神”的管理创新与国际化路径研究[J]. 管理学报, 2018, 15(1): 11-19. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1672-884x.2018.01.002
3 井润田, 孙璇. 实证主义vs. 诠释主义: 两种经典案例研究范式的比较与启示[J]. 管理世界, 2021, 37(3): 198-216. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1002-5502.2021.03.013
5 毛基业, 李亮. 管理学质性研究的回顾、反思与展望[J]. 南开管理评论, 2018, 21(6): 12-16.
6 潘善琳, 崔丽丽. SPS案例研究方法: 流程、建模与范例[M]. 北京: 北京大学出版社, 2016.
7 王冰, 齐海伦, 李立望. 如何做高质量的质性研究——中国企业管理案例与质性研究论坛(2017)综述[J]. 管理世界, 2018, 34(4): 140-145. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1002-5502.2018.04.012
8 Abbott A. Department and discipline: Chicago sociology at one hundred[M]. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1999.
9 Aguinis H, Solarino A M. Transparency and replicability in qualitative research: The case of interviews with elite informants[J]. Strategic Management Journal, 2019, 40(8): 1291-1315. DOI:10.1002/smj.3015
10 Armstrong J. Naturalistic inquiry[A]. Salking N J. Encyclopedia of research design[C]. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage, 2010.
11 Bansal P, Corley K. The coming of age for qualitative research: Embracing the diversity of qualitative methods[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2011, 54(2): 233-237. DOI:10.5465/amj.2011.60262792
12 Bansal P, Smith W K, Vaara E. New ways of seeing through qualitative research[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2018, 61(4): 1189-1195. DOI:10.5465/amj.2018.4004
13 Beynon H. Working for ford[M]. Harmondsworth: Penguin, 1973.
14 Blaikie N. Approaches to social enquiry[M]. Cambridge: Polity Press, 2007.
15 Bluhm D J, Harman W, Lee T W, et al. Qualitative research in management: A decade of progress[J]. Journal of Management Studies, 2011, 48(8): 1866-1891. DOI:10.1111/j.1467-6486.2010.00972.x
16 Bruni A, Gobo G. Qualitative research in Italy[J]. Forum:Qualitative Social Research, 2005, 6(3): 41.
17 Charmaz K. Constructing grounded theory: A practical guide through qualitative analysis[M]. London: Sage Publications, 2006.
18 Comte A (Ed. ), Martineau H (Trans. ). The positive philosophy of Auguste Comte[M]. London: J. Chapman, 1853.
19 Cook T D, Campbell D T. Quasi-experimentation: Design and analysis issues for field settings[M]. Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 1979.
20 Cornelissen J P. Preserving theoretical divergence in management research: Why the explanatory potential of qualitative research should be harnessed rather than suppressed[J]. Journal of Management Studies, 2017, 54(3): 368-383. DOI:10.1111/joms.12210
21 Cunliffe A L. Crafting qualitative research: Morgan and Smircich 30 years on[J]. Organizational Research Methods, 2011, 14(4): 647-673. DOI:10.1177/1094428110373658
22 Das T H. Qualitative research in organizational behaviour[J]. Journal of Management Studies, 1983, 20(3): 301-314. DOI:10.1111/j.1467-6486.1983.tb00209.x
23 de Rond M, Lok J. Some things can never be unseen: The role of context in psychological injury at war[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2016, 59(6): 1965-1993. DOI:10.5465/amj.2015.0681
24 Denzin N K, Lincoln Y S. Handbook of qualitative research[M]. Thousand Oaks: Sage, 1994.
25 Du W Y, Pan S L. Boundary spanning by design: Toward aligning boundary-spanning capacity and strategy in IT outsourcing[J]. IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management, 2013, 60(1): 59-76. DOI:10.1109/TEM.2012.2206114
26 Eisenhardt K M. Building theories from case study research[J]. Academy of Management Review, 1989, 14(4): 532-550. DOI:10.2307/258557
27 Eisenhardt K M, Graebner M E. Theory building from cases: Opportunities and challenges[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2007, 50(1): 25-32. DOI:10.5465/amj.2007.24160888
28 Ernest P. The nature of mathematics and teaching[EB/OL]. https://education.exeter.ac.uk/research/centres/stem/publications/pmej/pome/pompart7.htm, 1996-10-31/2022-10-08.
29 Fairhurst E. Organizational rules and the accomplishment of nursing work on geriatric wards[J]. Journal of Management Studies, 1983, 20(3): 315-332. DOI:10.1111/j.1467-6486.1983.tb00210.x
30 Fineman S, Mangham I. Data, meanings and creativity: A preface[J]. Journal of Management Studies, 1983, 20(3): 295-300. DOI:10.1111/j.1467-6486.1983.tb00208.x
31 Frost N, Nolas S M, Brooks-Gordon B, et al. Pluralism in qualitative research: The impact of different researchers and qualitative approaches on the analysis of qualitative data[J]. Qualitative Research, 2010, 10(4): 441-460. DOI:10.1177/1468794110366802
32 Gephart Jr R P. Qualitative research and the academy of management journal[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2004, 47(4): 454-462. DOI:10.5465/amj.2004.14438580
33 Gioia D, Corley K, Eisenhardt K, et al. A curated debate: On using “templates” in qualitative research[J]. Journal of Management Inquiry, 2022, 31(3): 231-252. DOI:10.1177/10564926221098955
34 Gioia D A, Corley K G, Hamilton A L. Seeking qualitative rigor in inductive research: Notes on the Gioia methodology[J]. Organizational Research Methods, 2013, 16(1): 15-31. DOI:10.1177/1094428112452151
35 Glaser B G. Theoretical sensitivity: Advances in the methodology of grounded theory[M]. Mill Valley, CA: Sociology Press, 1978.
36 Glaser B G, Strauss A L. The discovery of grounded theory: Strategies for qualitative research[M]. Chicago, IL: Aldine Transaction, 1967.
37 Golden-Biddle K, Locke K. Composing qualitative research[M]. 2nd ed. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage, 2007.
38 Guba E G, Lincoln Y S. Fourth generation evaluation[M]. Newbury Park, CA: Sage, 1989.
39 Habermas J. Knowledge and interest[A]. Emmet D, Macintyre A. Sociological theory and philosophical analysis[M]. London: Palgrave Macmillan, 1970.
40 Healy C S J. Le Play’s contribution to sociology: His method[J]. American Catholic Sociological Review, 1947, 8(2): 97-110. DOI:10.2307/3707549
41 Huang P Y, Pan S L, Ouyang T H. Developing information processing capability for operational agility: Implications from a Chinese manufacturer[J]. European Journal of Information Systems, 2014, 23(4): 462-480. DOI:10.1057/ejis.2014.4
42 Latour B, Woolgar S. Laboratory life: The social construction of scientific facts[M]. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1979.
43 Lee B, Humphrey C. More than a numbers game: Qualitative research in accounting[J]. Management Decision, 2006, 44(2): 180-197. DOI:10.1108/00251740610650184
44 Lee T W. Using qualitative methods in organizational research[M]. Thousand Oakes, CA: Sage, 1998.
45 Lengermann P M. The founding of the American Sociological Review: The anatomy of a rebellion[J]. American Sociological Review, 1979, 44(2): 185-198. DOI:10.2307/2094504
46 Miles M B. Qualitative data as an attractive nuisance: The problem of analysis[J]. Administrative Science Quarterly, 1979, 24(4): 590-601. DOI:10.2307/2392365
47 Mogey J M. The contribution of Frédéric Le Play to family research[J]. Marriage and Family Living, 1955, 17(4): 310-315. DOI:10.2307/346940
48 Morgan G, Smircich L. The case for qualitative research[J]. Academy of Management Review, 1980, 5(4): 491-500. DOI:10.2307/257453
49 Okasha S. Philosophy of science: A very short introduction[M]. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2002.
50 Open Science Collaboration. Estimating the reproducibility of psychological science[J]. Science, 2015, 349(6251): aac4716. DOI:10.1126/science.aac4716
51 Ott T E, Eisenhardt K M. Decision weaving: Forming novel, complex strategy in entrepreneurial settings[J]. Strategic Management Journal, 2020, 41(12): 2275-2314. DOI:10.1002/smj.3189
52 Powell E E, Baker T. In the beginning: Identity processes and organizing in multi-founder nascent ventures[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2017, 60(6): 2381-2414. DOI:10.5465/amj.2015.0175
53 Pratt M G. Fitting oval pegs into round holes: Tensions in evaluating and publishing qualitative research in top-tier North American journals[J]. Organizational Research Methods, 2008, 11(3): 481-509. DOI:10.1177/1094428107303349
54 Pratt M G, Kaplan S, Whittington R. Editorial essay: The tumult over transparency: Decoupling transparency from replication in establishing trustworthy qualitative research[J]. Administrative Science Quarterly, 2020, 65(1): 1-19. DOI:10.1177/0001839219887663
55 Putnam H. The many faces of realism[M]. La Salle, IL: Open Court, 1987.
56 Rawls A W. The wartime narrative in US sociology, 1940-1947: Stigmatizing qualitative sociology in the name of ‘science’[J]. European Journal of Social Theory, 2018, 21(4): 526-546. DOI:10.1177/1368431018754499
57 Risjord M. Philosophy of social science: A contemporary introduction[M]. New York: Routledge, 2014.
58 Schreiber R S, Stern P N. Using grounded theory in nursing[M]. New York, NY: Springer Publishing Company, 2001.
59 Strauss A L, Corbin J M. Basics of qualitative research: Techniques and procedures for developing grounded theory[M]. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage, 1998.
60 Suddaby R. From the editors: What grounded theory is not[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2006, 49(4): 633-642. DOI:10.5465/amj.2006.22083020
61 Symon G, Cassell C, Johnson P. Evaluative practices in qualitative management research: A critical review[J]. International Journal of Management Reviews, 2018, 20(1): 134-154. DOI:10.1111/ijmr.12120
62 Tsui A S, Jia L D. Calling for humanistic scholarship in China[J]. Management and Organization Review, 2013, 9(1): 1-15. DOI:10.1111/more.12013
63 Turner B A. The use of grounded theory for the qualitative analysis of organizational behaviour[J]. Journal of Management Studies, 1983, 20(3): 333-348. DOI:10.1111/j.1467-6486.1983.tb00211.x
64 Van Maanen J. Reclaiming qualitative methods for organizational research: A preface[J]. Administrative Science Quarterly, 1979, 24(4): 520-526. DOI:10.2307/2392358
65 Van Maanen J. Hold the Mayo: Some comments on the origins of organizational ethnography[J]. Journal of Organizational Ethnography, 2013, 2(1): 105-109.
66 Wei T, Clegg J. Untangling the integration–performance link: Levels of integration and functional integration strategies in post-acquisition integration[J]. Journal of Management Studies, 2020, 57(8): 1643-1689. DOI:10.1111/joms.12571
67 Welch C, Piekkari R, Plakoyiannaki E, et al. Theorising from case studies: Towards a pluralist future for international business research[J]. Journal of International Business Studies, 2011, 42(5): 740-762. DOI:10.1057/jibs.2010.55
68 Welch C, Plakoyiannaki E, Piekkari R, et al. Legitimizing diverse uses for qualitative research: A rhetorical analysis of two management journals[J]. International Journal of Management Reviews, 2013, 15(2): 245-264. DOI:10.1111/ijmr.12001
69 Yin R K. The case study crisis: Some answers[J]. Administrative Science Quarterly, 1981, 26(1): 58-65. DOI:10.2307/2392599
70 Yin R K. Case study research: Design and methods[M]. London: Sage, 1989.