流动人口家庭在流入城市消费不足的制度性约束*——基于城区人口100万以上城市随迁子女升学政策的实证分析

Institutional Restrictions on Insufficient Household Consumption of Migrants in Destination Cities: Evidence from High-school Entrance Exam Policy for Migrant Children in Large Cities

邹月晴,陈媛媛,宋扬

2023 第 49 卷 第 12 期 页码 106-120

DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.jfe.20230617.304

PDF全文下载 HTML全文

语音预告

摘要

要实现国内消费的长期增长,需制度的改革和完善。流动人口子女的教育问题受到了广泛关注,自2001年中央政府颁布“两为主”政策以来,流动儿童在父母流入城市的义务教育入学问题有了显著的改善,但异地中考和高考的问题日益突出,绝大多数省份的异地高考政策都要求随迁子女在当地拥有三年高中学籍,能否在流入地参加中考是更为前置的问题。据此,文章试图从随迁子女异地中考政策的视角,基于城区人口100万以上城市的随迁子女升学政策进行实证检验,分析影响流动人口家庭在流入城市消费的制度性约束。结果显示,异地中考政策的限制造成了大城市的流动人口在流入地“留居不消费”现象加剧,当子女年级越接近中考时,在异地中考门槛越高的城市,流动人口家庭在流入城市的消费越低,且这一抑制作用对中等学历、城镇户口、男孩家庭和流入超大、特大城市的家庭作用更大。机制检验表明,异地中考政策主要通过降低流动人口家庭的家庭教育期望和改变子女留守选择这两个机制来影响消费。综上,文章认为,应继续推进随迁子女升学政策的改革,进一步保障随迁子女的受教育权利,激发流动人口消费的热情与活力,这对缓解经济下行叠加复杂多变的国际政治经济环境等多重负面影响下的需求收缩,刺激城市经济复苏具有重要作用。

Due to the restriction of the household registration system, the education rights of migrant children are not well protected. Since the central government issued the policy of “two priorities” in 2001, the compulsory education enrollment of migrant children in cities has been significantly improved. However, the restrictions on high–school and college entrance exams for migrant children have become increasingly prominent, and there is still a large number of migrant children who are unable to pursue further education in their destination cities upon completion of compulsory education. Because the college entrance exam policy for migrant children generally takes the high-school entrance exam policy for migrant children as a prerequisite, this paper attempts to analyze the impact of institutional restrictions on the household consumption of migrants in destination cities from the perspective of the high-school entrance exam policy for migrant children.

This paper collects the policy documents of the high-school entrance exam for migrant children in 72 cities with a population of more than one million in central urban districts from 2013 to 2018, constructs an index to measure the barriers to the high-school entrance exam for migrant children using the analytic hierarchy process, and attempts to evaluate the impact of the high-school entrance exam for migrant children on the household consumption of migrants in destination cities using the data of China Migrants Dynamic Survey from 2014 to 2017. The findings suggest that policy restrictions have a significant impact on reducing the household consumption of migrants in destination cities. This effect is particularly noteworthy among families with moderate educational attainment and those who possess urban hukou, have sons, and are migrants in megalopolis cities.

In terms of the underlying mechanism, this paper uses both the data of China Migrants Dynamic Survey from 2014 to 2017 and China Family Panel Studies from 2014 to 2018, and finds that the policy restrictions reduce the household consumption in destination cities mainly by lowering the education expectations of migrant families and increasing the probability of children being left behind. Little evidence supports that the policy changes migrants’ willingness to stay in cities.

The results of this paper suggest that institutional restrictions directly suppress the household consumption of migrants in destination cities. The structural benefits of the spatial distribution of labor resources have not been fully realized and, as a result, cities have forfeited the economic advantages that are typically generated by migrant labor. This paper indicates that removing the education restrictions on migrant children can not only protect their education rights, but also stimulate consumption and economic development in cities.

参考文献

1 晁钢令,万广圣. 农民工家庭生命周期变异及对其家庭消费结构的影响[J]. 管理世界,2016,(11):96−109. DOI:10.19744/j.cnki.11-1235/f.2016.11.008
3 陈宣霖. 异地中考政策促进随迁子女选择高中教育吗[J]. 复旦教育论坛,2021,(1):75−81.
4 程杰, 尹熙. 内需的源泉: 新时期流动人口的消费潜力有多大? [A]. 张车伟, 高文书, 程杰. 人口与劳动绿皮书: 中国人口与劳动问题报告No.20[M]. 北京: 社会科学文献出版社, 2019.
6 胡霞,丁浩. 子女随迁政策对农民工家庭消费的影响机制研究[J]. 经济学动态,2016,(10):25−38.
12 卢海阳. 社会保险对进城农民工家庭消费的影响[J]. 人口与经济,2014,(4):33−42. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1000-4149.2014.04.004
14 王军,詹韵秋. 子女数量与家庭消费行为:影响效应及作用机制[J]. 财贸研究,2021,(1):1−13.
15 汪润泉,赵彤. 就业类型、职工养老保险与农民工城市消费[J]. 农业技术经济,2018,(2):77−88. DOI:10.13246/j.cnki.jae.2018.02.003
16 王毅杰,黄是知. 异地中考政策、父母教育参与和随迁子女教育期望[J]. 社会科学,2019,(7):67−80. DOI:10.13644/j.cnki.cn31-1112.2019.07.007
17 魏东霞,谌新民. 落户门槛、技能偏向与儿童留守−基于2014年全国流动人口监测数据的实证研究[J]. 经济学(季刊),2018,(2):549−578. DOI:10.13821/j.cnki.ceq.2018.01.05
18 吴贾,张俊森. 随迁子女入学限制、儿童留守与城市劳动力供给[J]. 经济研究,2020,(11):138−155.
19 吴开亚,张力,陈筱. 户籍改革进程的障碍:基于城市落户门槛的分析[J]. 中国人口科学,2010,(1):66−74.
22 易行健,张波,杨汝岱,等. 家庭社会网络与农户储蓄行为:基于中国农村的实证研究[J]. 管理世界,2012,(5):43−51.
23 尹志超,宋全云,吴雨. 金融知识、投资经验与家庭资产选择[J]. 经济研究,2014,(4):62−75.
24 张吉鹏,卢冲. 户籍制度改革与城市落户门槛的量化分析[J]. 经济学(季刊),2019,(4):1509−1530. DOI:10.13821/j.cnki.ceq.2019.03.16
25 张勋,刘晓光,樊纲. 农业劳动力转移与家户储蓄率上升[J]. 经济研究,2014,(4):130−142.
26 朱琳, 冯思澈, 马啸. 流动人口随迁子女入学政策友好程度研究——基于16个城市政策文本的分析[A]. 韩嘉玲, 朱琳, 刘月. 流动儿童蓝皮书: 中国流动儿童教育发展报告(2019~2020)[M]. 北京: 社会科学文献出版社, 2020.
27 Aina C, Sonedda D. Investment in education and household consumption[R]. CRENoS Working Paper No.201806, 2018.
28 Boar C. Dynastic precautionary savings[J]. The Review of Economic Studies,2021,88(6): 2735−2765. DOI:10.1093/restud/rdab012
29 Cai F, Giles J, Meng X. How well do children insure parents against low retirement income? An analysis using survey data from urban China[J]. Journal of Public Economics,2006,90(12): 2229−2255. DOI:10.1016/j.jpubeco.2006.03.004
30 Carroll C D, Rhee B K, Rhee C. Does cultural origin affect saving behavior? Evidence from immigrants[J]. Economic Development and Cultural Change,1999,48(1): 33−50. DOI:10.1086/452445
31 Cheng Z M. Education and consumption: Evidence from migrants in Chinese cities[J]. Journal of Business Research,2021,127: 206−215. DOI:10.1016/j.jbusres.2021.01.018
32 De Luca G, Lisi D, Martorana M, et al. Does higher institutional quality improve the appropriateness of healthcare provision?[J]. Journal of Public Economics,2021,194: 104356. DOI:10.1016/j.jpubeco.2020.104356
33 Galor O, Stark O. Migrants’ savings, the probability of return migration and migrants’ performance[J]. International Economic Review,1990,31(2): 463−467. DOI:10.2307/2526851
34 Lazear E. Education: Consumption or production?[J]. Journal of Political Economy,1977,85(3): 569−597. DOI:10.1086/260584
35 Poeze M, Dankyi E K, Mazzucato V. Navigating transnational childcare relationships: Migrant parents and their children’s caregivers in the origin country[J]. Global Networks,2017,17(1): 111−129. DOI:10.1111/glob.12135
36 Rosenzweig M R, Stark O. Consumption smoothing, migration, and marriage: Evidence from rural India[J]. Journal of Political Economy,1989,97(4): 905−926. DOI:10.1086/261633
37 Smetana J G. Adolescents, families, and social development: How teens construct their worlds[M]. Chichester: Wiley-Blackwell, 2011.
38 Trope Y, Liberman N. Construal-level theory of psychological distance[J]. Psychological Review,2010,117(2): 440−463. DOI:10.1037/a0018963
39 Wang C C, Zhang C L, Ni J L, et al. Family migration in China: Do migrant children affect parental settlement intention?[J]. Journal of Comparative Economics,2019,47(2): 416−428. DOI:10.1016/j.jce.2019.01.002
40 Wei S J, Zhang X B. The competitive saving motive: Evidence from rising sex ratios and savings rates in China[J]. Journal of Political Economy,2011,119(3): 511−564. DOI:10.1086/660887
41 Yang G Y, Bansak C. Does wealth matter? An assessment of China’s rural-urban migration on the education of left-behind children[J]. China Economic Review,2020,59: 101365. DOI:10.1016/j.chieco.2019.101365