逆转的杠杆率剪刀差——国企加杠杆还是私企去杠杆

The Reversal of Leverage Scissors: State-owned Enterprises’ Leveraging or Private-owned Enterprises’ Deleveraging

胡悦,吴文锋

2019 第 45 卷 第 05 期 页码 44-57

DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.jfe.2019.05.004

PDF全文下载 HTML全文

摘要

近年来,我国企业的债务水平迅速上升。这种上升表现出怎样的结构性特征?背后的原因又是什么?文章利用中国上市公司2001−2016年年报数据,发现国有企业与私营企业的杠杆率差异从2008年开始明显上升且由负转正,两者的杠杆率剪刀差发生逆转。进一步的研究表明,在控制了企业杠杆率的常见影响因素之后,国有企业与私营企业的杠杆率差异从2008年开始与企业所在地的GDP增速呈现出显著的负相关关系,而私营企业的投资−现金流敏感性在2008年前后则没有出现明显的变化。这说明国企与私企杠杆率剪刀差的逆转主要来源于稳增长压力上升所引致的地方政府对国有企业融资决策的干预。文章的发现为2008年以来我国国企杠杆率的相对上升提出了一种全新的解释,有助于我们更加全面和深入地认识我国企业债务结构性问题的成因,也为国有企业结构性去杠杆的政策选择提供了参考。

Recently, the debt level of the Chinese corporate sector has risen rapidly. According to BIS, the ratio of debt to GDP in China’s non-financial sector has soared from 96% in 2008 to 166% in 2016, accounting for 61% of China’s non-financial sector debt growth. Behind the skyrocketing debt of the corporate sector, is there any structural difference in leverage changes of different companies? If yes, what is the reason behind it?   Using the annual report data of China’s listed companies from 2001 to 2016, we find that the leverages of China’s private-owned enterprises (POEs) are higher than those of state-owned enterprises (SOEs) before 2008. However, the leverage gap between China’s POEs and SOEs has started to turn negative since 2008, a phenomenon we called " the reversal of leverage scissors”. Our further research shows that there is no significant relationship between the leverage gap and the local GDP growth before 2008. After 2008, the negative correlated relationship began to emerge. This finding indicates that the relative increase in the leverage ratio of SOEs after 2008 is likely to come from the increasing intervention of local governments on SOEs’ financing decisions, which is sourced from local governments’ increasing pressure to stabilize economic growth. On the other hand, we also find that the degree of financing constraints that POEs are faced does not increase significantly after 2008, which means that the relative decline in the leverage ratio of POEs is probably only the spontaneous adjustment of enterprises in the context of the decline in the macroeconomic growth rate and the reduction of investment opportunities rather than a result of the deterioration of the supply-side financing environment. Moreover, the impact of changes in equity on leverage, the " four trillion” stimulus plan, and the direct financing advantage of listed companies cannot explain the reversal of the leverage ratio scissors. Our conclusions are also robust to the different measures of local government intervention and corporate financing constraints. Overall, this study shows that the reversal of the leverage ratio scissors is mainly due to the active leveraging of SOEs caused by local government intervention in the financing needs of SOEs.  The main contribution of this paper is to provide a possible explanation for the structural rise of the leverage ratio of SOEs since 2008. Although the existing literature records the time series changes and structural characteristics of the leverage ratio of Chinese enterprises,there is no consistent view on the reasons behind the structural characteristics. In contrast, from the perspective of stabilizing local economy, we have linked the downward pressure of macroeconomic growth to the structural changes of micro-enterprise leverage, forming a chain of " downward trend of the macroeconomic growth rate—the pressure of local governments—local governments’ increasing intervention—the structural changes of SOEs and POEs’ leverage—the deterioration of capital allocation efficiency—macroeconomic growth rate decrease”, thus provide a new insight with the structural increase of SOEs’ leverage. In short, our research provides a new and meaningful profile of structural problems of China’s corporate debt, and also provides a reference for the policy choice of structural deleveraging of state-owned enterprises.

参考文献

2 邓可斌,曾海舰. 中国企业的融资约束:特征现象与成因检验[J]. 经济研究,2014,(2):47−60. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1009-0657.2014.02.011
3 方军雄. 所有制、制度环境与信贷资金配置[J]. 经济研究,2007,(12):82−92. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1673-291X.2007.12.032
12 王小鲁, 樊纲, 余静文. 中国分省份市场化指数报告(2016)[M]. 北京: 社会科学文献出版社, 2017.
13 王宇伟,盛天翔,周耿. 宏观政策、金融资源配置与企业部门高杠杆率[J]. 金融研究,2018,(1):36−52. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1003-4625.2018.01.009
17 袁淳,荆新,廖冠民. 国有公司的信贷优惠:信贷干预还是隐性担保?——基于信用贷款的实证检验[J]. 会计研究,2010,(8):49−54. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1003-2886.2010.08.008
19 周黎安. 中国地方官员的晋升锦标赛模式研究[J]. 经济研究,2007,(7):36−50. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1674-8638.2007.07.011
20 Allen F,Qian J,Qian M J. Law,finance,and economic growth in China[J]. Journal of Financial Economics,2005,77(1): 57−116. DOI:10.1016/j.jfineco.2004.06.010
21 Almeida H,Campello M,Weisbach M S. The cash flow sensitivity of cash[J]. Journal of Finance,2004,59(4): 1777−1804. DOI:10.1111/j.1540-6261.2004.00679.x
22 Bailey W,Huang W,Yang Z S. Bank loans with chinese characteristics:Some evidence on inside debt in a state-controlled banking system[J]. Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis,2011,46(6): 1795−1830. DOI:10.1017/S0022109011000433
24 Borisova G,Fotak V,Holland K,et al. Government ownership and the cost of debt:Evidence from government investments in publicly traded firms[J]. Journal of Financial Economics,2015,118(1): 168−191. DOI:10.1016/j.jfineco.2015.06.011
25 Brandt L,Zhu X D. Redistribution in a decentralized economy:Growth and inflation in China under reform[J]. Journal of Political Economy,2000,108(2): 422−439. DOI:10.1086/262124
26 Deng Y H,Morck R,Wu J,et al. China’s pseudo-monetary policy[J]. Review of Finance,2015,19(1): 55−93. DOI:10.1093/rof/rfu026
27 Fazzari S M,Hubbard R G,Petersen B C,et al. Financing constraints and corporate investment[J]. Brookings Papers on Economic Activity,1988,1988(1): 141−206. DOI:10.2307/2534426
28 Fazzari S M,Hubbard R G,Petersen B C. Investment-cash flow sensitivities are useful:A comment on Kaplan and Zingales[J]. The Quarterly Journal of Economics,2000,115(2): 695−705. DOI:10.1162/003355300554773
29 Frank M Z,Goyal V K. Capital structure decisions:Which factors are reliably important?[J]. Financial Management,2009,38(1): 1−37. DOI:10.1111/fima.2009.38.issue-1
30 Givoly D,Hayn C,Ofer A R,et al. Taxes and capital structure:Evidence from firms’ response to the tax reform act of 1986[J]. Review of Financial Studies,1992,5(2): 331−355. DOI:10.1093/rfs/5.2.331
31 Guariglia A,Yang J H. A balancing act:Managing financial constraints and agency costs to minimize investment inefficiency in the Chinese market[J]. Journal of Corporate Finance,2016,36: 111−130. DOI:10.1016/j.jcorpfin.2015.10.006
32 Kaplan S N,Zingales L. Do investment-cash flow sensitivities provide useful measures of financing constraints?[J]. The Quarterly Journal of Economics,1997,112(1): 169−215. DOI:10.1162/003355397555163
33 Kayhan A,Titman S. Firms’ histories and their capital structures[J]. Journal of Financial Economics,2007,83(1): 1−32. DOI:10.1016/j.jfineco.2005.10.007
34 Kornai J. The soft budget constraint[J]. Kyklos,1986,39(1): 3−30. DOI:10.1111/kykl.1986.39.issue-1
35 Li S Y,Lin S L. The size and structure of China’s government debt[J]. The Social Science Journal,2011,48(3): 527−542. DOI:10.1016/j.soscij.2011.06.003
36 Li X, Liu X W, Wang Y. A model of China’s state capitalism[R]. Working Paper, https://iems.ust.hk/assets/publications/working-papers-2015/iemswp2015-12.pdf, 2015.
37 Lin J Y,Tan G F. Policy burdens,accountability,and the soft budget constraint[J]. The American Economic Review,1999,89(2): 426−431. DOI:10.1257/aer.89.2.426
38 Myers S C,Majluf N S. Corporate financing and investment decisions when firms have information that investors do not have[J]. Journal of Financial Economics,1984,13(2): 187−221. DOI:10.1016/0304-405X(84)90023-0
39 Shailer G,Wang K. Government ownership and the cost of debt for Chinese listed corporations[J]. Emerging Markets Review,2015,22: 1−17. DOI:10.1016/j.ememar.2014.11.002
40 Shen J F,Firth M,Poon W P H. Credit expansion,corporate finance and overinvestment:Recent evidence from China[J]. Pacific-Basin Finance Journal,2016,39: 16−27. DOI:10.1016/j.pacfin.2016.05.004
41 Xu J G,Zhang X. China’s sovereign debt:A balance-sheet perspective[J]. China Economic Review,2014,31: 55−73. DOI:10.1016/j.chieco.2014.08.004