集聚环境“升级”抑或“降级”:对企业“创新惰性”的新解释

“Upgradation” or “Degradation” of Industrial Agglomeration Environment: A New Interpretation of “Innovation Inertia”

胡彬,万道侠

2019 第 45 卷 第 05 期 页码 16-29

DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.jfe.2019.05.002

PDF全文下载 HTML全文

摘要

与大多数研究集聚外部性影响企业创新的静态视角不同,文章基于世界银行对中国企业营商环境的调查数据和《中国工业企业数据库》,考察了产业集聚环境对企业创新偏好的分层影响以及企业进入动态的叠加影响。研究发现,专业化集聚环境显著增强了企业的低端创新偏好,而相关多样化集聚环境则显著增强了企业的高端创新偏好。不仅如此,产业集聚环境对企业创新偏好的分层影响会因企业进入动态的存在而显著增强。这一过程中,不同类型的产业集聚环境沿“升级”或“降级”方向的演化,在现实经济中不仅可以为“政策租”淡化后的开发区转型问题提供分析思路,而且还从产业集聚环境升级受阻和功能锁定的角度对企业的“创新惰性”提供了新的解释。进一步的分析表明,产品市场管制能够减弱专业化对企业低端创新偏好的正向影响,而诸如金融服务和法律服务等生产性服务业功能供给则能够增强相关多样化对企业高端创新偏好的正向影响。因此,在以创新为目的的企业进入环节,应根据集聚类型增强差异化的制度供给。

In addition to being influenced by its own characteristics, policy preferences and external factors, industrial development cannot ignore the dynamic evolution of industrial agglomeration environment and its effects. When discussing the problems of industrial agglomeration and development zones, most existing literature does not consider the remolding effect of enterprise dynamic factors on the evolution of industrial agglomeration environment under open conditions, which is an obvious deficiency in the research on industrial agglomeration in the period of " post-policy rent”. This paper argues that when industrial agglomeration (in China, mainly represented by the government-developed development zone) becomes the ubiquitous environment for the survival, development and innovation of enterprises, the lack of enterprise innovation caused by the environmental upgrading dilemma is a more alarming practical problem than the lack of enterprise innovation ability.  This paper attempts to clarify the microcosmic influence and function mechanism of different types of industry agglomeration environment on enterprise innovation preferences, and believes that the layering of corporate innovation preferences is caused by industrial agglomeration environment due to its external differences causing, and the firm entry dynamics for acquiring knowledge and promoting innovation will enhance the differential impact on industrial agglomeration environment through the " screening mechanism” so as to promote the evolution of industrial agglomeration environment. If the homogeneity of firm entry dynamics is high, those highly specialized areas are likely to fall into a state of " selective locking”. Under the action of the market mechanism, the continuous superposition of this state will further lead to the self-closing and recession of the whole industrial agglomeration environment, while enterprises in the agglomeration area will experience the loss of collective innovation vitality. On this occasion, in addition to the existing literature (Hu Bin and Wan Daoxia, 2017), this paper proposes another kind of enterprise " innovation inertia” caused by the " degradation” of industrial agglomeration environment, which is mainly affected by market selection.  Empirical results show that the specialized agglomeration environment significantly enhances the company’s low-end innovation preference, while the related diversified agglomeration environment significantly enhances the company’s high-end innovation preference. Moreover, the stratified impact of agglomeration environment on corporate innovation preferences is significantly enhanced by the presence of firm entry dynamics. In this process, the evolution of different types of agglomeration environment along the direction of " upgradation”or " degradation” can not only provide analysis ideas for the transformation of the development zone after the " policy rent” diluted in the real economy, but also provide a new explanation for the " innovation inertia” of enterprises from the perspective of the obstacles to the upgrading of agglomeration environment and the locking of functions. Further analysis shows that product market regulation can reduce the positive impact of specialization on the low-end innovation preference of enterprises, while the supply of producer services such as financial services and legal services can enhance the positive impact of relevant diversification on the high-end innovation preference. Therefore, in the entry of enterprises for innovation purposes, the differentiated institutional supply should be enhanced according to the type of agglomeration.

参考文献

7 Aarstad J,Kvitastein O A,Jakobsen S E. Related and unrelated variety as regional drivers of enterprise productivity and innovation:A multilevel study[J]. Research Policy,2016,45(4): 844−856. DOI:10.1016/j.respol.2016.01.013
8 Ballot G,Fakhfakh F,Galia F,et al. The fateful triangle:Complementarities in performance between product,process and organizational innovation in France and the UK[J]. Research Policy,2015,44(1): 217−232. DOI:10.1016/j.respol.2014.07.003
11 Callois J M. The two sides of proximity in industrial clusters:The trade-off between process and product innovation[J]. Journal of Urban Economics,2008,63(1): 146−162. DOI:10.1016/j.jue.2007.01.002
12 Fisman R,Svensson J. Are corruption and taxation really harmful to growth?Firm level evidence[J]. Journal of Deve- lopment Economics,2007,83(1): 63−75. DOI:10.1016/j.jdeveco.2005.09.009
13 Frenken K,Van Oort F,Verburg T. Related variety,unrelated variety and regional economic growth[J]. Regional Studies,2007,41(5): 685−697. DOI:10.1080/00343400601120296
14 Goedhuys M,Veugelers R. Innovation strategies,process and product innovations and growth:Firm-level evidence from Brazil[J]. Structural Change and Economic Dynamics,2012,23(4): 516−529. DOI:10.1016/j.strueco.2011.01.004
15 Gómez J,Salazar I,Vargas P. Sources of information as determinants of product and process innovation[J]. PLoS One,2016,11(4): e0152743. DOI:10.1371/journal.pone.0152743
16 Guan J C,Yam R C M,Tang E P Y,et al. Innovation strategy and performance during economic transition:Evidences in Beijing,China[J]. Research Policy,2009,38(5): 802−812. DOI:10.1016/j.respol.2008.12.009
17 Hullova D,Trott P,Simms C D. Uncovering the reciprocal complementarity between product and process innovation[J]. Research Policy,2016,45(5): 929−940. DOI:10.1016/j.respol.2016.01.012
19 Zhang H Y. How does agglomeration promote the product innovation of Chinese firms?[J]. China Economic Review,2015,35: 105−120. DOI:10.1016/j.chieco.2015.06.003