机会不平等与社会流动预期研究——基于CGSS数据的经验分析
Study on Opportunity Inequality and Social Mobility Expectation: Empirical Analysis Based on CGSS Data
DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.jfe.2018.05.004
[1]陈晓东,张卫东.机会不平等与社会流动预期研究——基于CGSS数据的经验分析[J/OL].财经研究,2018,44(05):48-60[2026-11-22].https://doi.org/10.16538/j.cnki.jfe.2018.05.004.
摘要
随着“中国梦”的提出,对于居民社会流动预期的研究受到了广泛关注。现有文献对于社会流动预期影响因素的相关研究较为匮乏,文章在政府以实现社会公平正义为目标的改革背景之下,研究我国机会不平等对居民社会流动预期的影响,具有重要的理论和现实意义。研究表明:机会不平等作用于社会流动预期的总效应为正,即当前机会不平等程度越高的地区,人们向上的社会流动预期越显著;并且,这种正向影响在家庭背景条件较差、年龄较大、受教育程度较高以及非农业户籍群体中更加显著。文章认为,在政府以实现社会公平正义为目标的改革背景下,人们预期未来机会不平等程度会下降,导致机会不平等直接效应的不利影响受到间接效应的抵消,从而出现上述看似“有悖常理”的结论。实证结果也在一定程度上证实了间接效应的存在。因此,相对于当前现实存在的机会不平等,人们对未来机会不平等变化的预期对其社会流动预期的影响更为突出。政府部门应当在贯彻落实公平政策的同时,实施必要的预期管理,增强人们对政府部门的信任,使其保持对未来改革政策的乐观预期,从而维持当前较为良好的居民社会流动预期。
With the " Chinese Dream” put forward, the study on the social mobility expectation of residents has attracted more and more attention from the academia. This paper studies the impact of opportunity inequality on the social mobility expectation of residents under the background of the government goal of achieving social fairness and justice. Opportunity inequality refers to the part of income inequality caused by environmental factors that are uncontrolled by individuals. Social mobility expectation is defined as a positive or negative psychological expectation by individuals for the flow of future social class based on the objective social environment. Although a lot of literature has revealed the importance of social mobility expectation in influencing human cognition, redistribution preferences and well-being, there are still few studies on the factors influencing social mobility expectation. This paper aims to explore the relationship between opportunity inequality, which is a relatively prominent institution and environment factor at present, and the social mobility expectation of residents. We decompose the effects of opportunity inequality on the social mobility expectation of individuals into direct and indirect effects. The direct effect refers to that the current opportunity inequality plays an important role in affecting current economic environment that individuals face, such as entrepreneurship, employment and promotion opportunities, and then has a lasting impact on future social mobility expectation. The indirect effect refers to that the current opportunity inequality, combined with the governmental policy measures for achieving the goal of social fairness and justice, affects people’s expectation of the change in future opportunity inequality and then acts on social mobility expectation. The empirical results show that: the higher the current level of opportunity inequality is, the greater the upward social mobility expectation is. And this positive effect is more pronounced in the group with poorer family background, elder age, higher education level, or non-agricultural household registration. We argue that, in the context of the governmental goal of achieving social fairness and justice, the degree of future opportunity inequality is expected to decline. Thus the adverse result of the direct effect of the opportunity inequality is offset by indirect effect, leading to the seemingly counter-intuitive conclusion. The empirical results also prove the indirect effect to some extent. Therefore, compared with the current opportunity inequality, the expectation for the changes in future opportunity inequality has more pronounced impact on the expectation of social mobility. While implementing the fair policies, the governments should carry out necessary expectation management, in order to enhance people’s trust in government departments. This will allow people to remain optimistic about future reform policy, so as to maintain the current relatively good social mobility expectation of residents.
关键词: 机会不平等,社会流动预期,公平正义,直接效应,间接效应