加入行业协会的民营企业慈善捐赠更多吗?—基于全国民营企业调查数据的实证研究
Do Firms Joining an Industrial Association Donate More? Evidence from China’s Private Enterprises Survey
DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.jfe.2018.01.003
[1]陈贵梧,胡辉华.加入行业协会的民营企业慈善捐赠更多吗?—基于全国民营企业调查数据的实证研究[J/OL].财经研究,2018,44(01):33-46[2026-11-22].https://doi.org/10.16538/j.cnki.jfe.2018.01.003.
摘要
文章采用中国私营企业调查数据,分析和检验了行业协会对民营企业慈善捐赠行为的影响。研究发现,在控制其他因素的前提下,加入行业协会的民营企业比没有加入行业协会的民营企业进行了更多的慈善捐赠,反映出慈善捐赠是民营企业对其所面临的组织情境的一种策略性回应。在采用处理效应模型和倾向得分匹配法来克服内生性影响,以及改变变量的测度方式后,上述结果仍然稳健。进一步的分析表明,行业协会可以通过党组织这一路径,促进企业的慈善捐赠;尽管行业协会和政治关联均对企业慈善捐赠产生了显著的正向影响,但是前者的影响效应并不如后者。文章的研究结论为转型时期中国“两新组织”的党组织角色和作用提供了直接的经验证据,尤其是为行业协会可以构成稳定地影响企业行为的制度性力量这一命题提供来自转型国家的经验证据,因而具有明显的政策含义。
Charitable donation is considered as one type of corporate social responsibility(CSR). Previous researches have devoted many efforts to exploring the determinants of corporate donation, including economic motivations, political consideration, and management opportunism. However, little attention has been paid to exploring the strategic interaction between an industrial association, a government and a firm, and their consequences on the giving behaviors of private firms. Therefore, this paper attempts to answer the following questions: in China, particularly, whether private firms joining an industrial association donate more than those not belonging to any association? how does the interaction between the associations and the primary organizations of the Communist Party of China(CPC)influence the giving behaviors of private firms? what are the differences in the impacts of the association-firm connections, and political connections, namely the connections between firms and governments, on the donating behaviors of private firms? We answer the above-mentioned questions in two ways. On the one hand, theoretical analysis hypothesizes that industrial associations can foster business charitable donations by ways of sub-government administrative commands, the logic of membership, the exchange mechanisms of resources and services, as well as Party voice. In particular, CPC is likely to be one of the important channels through which an industrial association can exert influence upon firms’ giving initiatives and behaviors. On the other hand, a unique data set from China’s Private Enterprises Survey in 2010 is employed to empirically test the hypotheses. The OLS regression results show that firms that join an industrial association demonstrate higher levels of charitable donations. The potential endogeneity problem of the regressor, i.e. the dummy variable concerning whether a firm joins an industrial association, is addressed by treatment-effect model and propensity score matching method. The results are robust to alternative measures of charitable donations, different types of industrial associations, and different subsamples of the dataset. The data sets in 2002, 2004, 2006, 2008 and 2012 are also used to confirm the robustness of the results. Further analysis shows that the interaction between industrial associations and CPC control in terms of establishing a primary party organization in a firm and the business owner being a party member has a significantly positive effect on the firm’s charitable donations. Furthermore, results show that the association-firm connections demonstrate a weaker influence on the charitable donation behaviors of a firm, compared to formal political connections. The findings suggest that charitable donations can be a strategic response of a firm to organizational context it faces, and that even in the context of transitional China, industrial associations can be a stable institutional factor affecting the behaviors of firms. The implication derived from the empirical analysis is that policy makers should pay enough attention to the role of industrial associations and CPC control in improving the overall level of CSR in private firms. This study is among the first to use nationally-representative survey data from China to analyze the effects of industrial associations on private firms’ charitable donations, especially in terms of comparing the marginal effects of association-firm connections and political connections on corporate giving behaviors. It not only enriches the empirical research on corporate philanthropy, but also offers a new perspective for fully understanding how industrial associations in China exert their influences on firms’ giving behavior.
关键词: 行业协会,企业慈善捐赠,民营企业,处理效应模型,倾向得分匹配