党委党组“讨论前置”决策机制能提高国有企业绩效吗?——基于准自然实验的研究
Can the “Pre-discussion” Decision-making Mechanism of the Party Committee and Party Group Improve SOE Performance? Based on a Quasi-natural Experiment
DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20220630.202
[1]陈其安,唐书香.党委党组“讨论前置”决策机制能提高国有企业绩效吗?——基于准自然实验的研究[J/OL].外国经济与管理,2022,44(12):3-18[2026-11-20].https://doi.org/10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20220630.202.
摘要
党委党组对“三重一大”事项(重要人事任免、重大决策事项、重大项目安排与大额资金使用)的“讨论前置”决策机制是将党组织深度嵌入国有企业公司治理结构、优化国有企业公司治理机制的重要举措。本文以2010—2020年中国沪深A股上市公司为样本,运用双重差分倾向得分匹配法实证检验了党委党组“讨论前置”决策机制对国有企业绩效的影响。研究发现:(1)党委党组“讨论前置”决策机制在不显著降低国有企业社会绩效的情况下,显著地提高了国有企业的经济绩效,实现了国有企业绩效的帕累托改进。(2)降低委托代理成本是党委党组“讨论前置”决策机制提升国有企业经济绩效的重要途径。(3)相较于地方国有企业和市场环境健全地区国有企业,党委党组“讨论前置”决策机制对中央国有企业和市场环境落后地区国有企业的帕累托改进作用更为明显。本文的研究结论明确了党委党组“讨论前置”决策机制对国有企业社会绩效和经济绩效的政策效应,为进一步优化党组织参与国有企业公司治理提供了经验证据。
The “Regulations on the Work of the Party Group of the Communist Party of China (for Trial Implementation)” issued by the Central Committee of the CPC in June 2015 established the “pre-discussion” decision-making mechanism for important personnel appointments and dismissals, major decision-making matters, major project arrangements, and the use of large funds for central SOEs.
Based on the in-depth analysis of the theoretical mechanism and the role of the “pre-discussion” decision-making mechanism in affecting the performance of SOEs, this paper proposes research hypotheses. Then, taking the implementation of the “pre-discussion” decision-making mechanism in central SOEs and local SOEs in 2015 and 2016 as a quasi-natural experiment, using China’s Shanghai and Shenzhen A-share listed companies from 2010 to 2020 as samples, this paper employs the PSM-DID method to empirically test the impact of the “pre-discussion” decision-making mechanism on the economic and social performance of SOEs and the role of agency costs in it. It is found that: The “pre-discussion” decision-making mechanism can significantly improve the economic performance of SOEs without significantly reducing the social performance of SOEs, thus realizing the Pareto improvement of SOE performance; reducing principal-agent costs is an important way for the “pre-discussion” decision-making mechanism to improve the economic performance of SOEs; compared with local SOEs and SOEs in sound market environments, the “pre-discussion” decision-making mechanism has a more obvious Pareto improvement effect on central SOEs and SOEs in backward market environments.
This paper examines the impact of the “pre-discussion” decision-making mechanism on the social and economic performance of SOEs from theoretical and empirical perspectives. The research content is more consistent with the actual situation and basic characteristics of China’s SOEs. The findings clarify the different impacts of the “pre-discussion” decision-making mechanism on the social and economic performance of SOEs and provide a precise evaluation of the “pre-discussion” decision-making mechanism, which not only deepens and complements the existing literature, but also provides theoretical and empirical evidence for further integrating Party organizations into the corporate governance system and optimizing the corporate governance mechanism of SOEs. The central and local governments should continue to promote the implementation of the “pre-discussion” decision-making mechanism in SOEs. SOEs should consciously improve their corporate governance mechanism by the requirements of the “pre-discussion” decision-making mechanism to reduce principal-agent costs and improve their economic and social performance.
关键词: “讨论前置”,国有企业绩效,帕累托改进,双重差分倾向得分匹配法