“重利润”还是“重增长”?新兴市场企业战略导向对企业绿色创新的影响研究
“Profit Priority” or “Growth Priority”? A Study on the Impact of Strategic Orientations of Emerging Market Enterprises on Corporate Green Innovation
DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20260310.401
[1]刘新韬,邓新明,张亦驰,李东升,龙贤义.“重利润”还是“重增长”?新兴市场企业战略导向对企业绿色创新的影响研究[J/OL].外国经济与管理,2026,48(06):40-59[2026-11-20].https://doi.org/10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20260310.401.
摘要
在加快经济社会发展全面绿色转型的关键时期,制造业企业在利润和增长之间的战略权衡对绿色创新产出起到重要作用,企业应该“重利润”还是“重增长”?本文立足于中国的新兴市场背景,探讨了战略导向(利润导向战略和增长导向战略)对绿色创新(能动型绿色创新和反应型绿色创新)的差异化影响及边界条件。本文使用2010—2021年中国A股制造业上市企业数据进行了实证检验,研究发现:(1)利润导向战略能够促进企业绿色创新,并对能动型绿色创新的促进作用更强;增长导向战略会抑制企业绿色创新。(2)组织冗余既削弱了利润导向战略对绿色创新的积极作用,同时也缓解了增长导向战略对绿色创新的消极影响。(3)制度环境强化了利润导向战略对绿色创新的促进作用,但也加剧了增长导向战略对绿色创新的抑制作用。(4)利润导向战略对绿色创新的影响具有生命周期异质性。本文解决了在转型关键期企业绿色创新能动性不足的核心痛点问题,从细分的维度丰富了绿色创新的理论研究,为深入理解利润导向战略、增长导向战略的影响提供了系统的理论解释,也为制造业企业的绿色创新实践和政府的政策实践提供了经验证据。
Based on the context of China’s emerging markets, this paper explores the heterogeneous impacts of strategic orientations (profit-oriented strategy and growth-oriented strategy) on green innovation (proactive green innovation and reactive green innovation), as well as the corresponding boundary conditions. This paper conducts an empirical test using panel data of China’s A-share listed manufacturing enterprises from 2010 to 2021. The study finds that: First, a profit-oriented strategy can promote corporate green innovation, with a stronger facilitating effect on proactive green innovation, whereas a growth-oriented strategy inhibits corporate green innovation. Second, organizational slack weakens the positive effect of a profit-oriented strategy on green innovation and simultaneously mitigates the negative impact of a growth-oriented strategy on green innovation. Third, the institutional environment strengthens the facilitating effect of a profit-oriented strategy on green innovation yet exacerbates the inhibitory effect of a growth-oriented strategy on green innovation. Fourth, the impact of a profit-oriented strategy on green innovation exhibits significant life cycle heterogeneity. This paper addresses the core pain point of insufficient corporate initiative in green innovation during the critical transition period. It enriches the theoretical research on green innovation from a disaggregated dimensional perspective, provides a systematic theoretical explanation for an in-depth understanding of the impacts of profit-oriented and growth-oriented strategies, and offers empirical evidence for the green innovation practices of manufacturing enterprises and the policy practices of governmental authorities.
关键词: 利润导向战略,增长导向战略,绿色创新,组织冗余,制度环境