本土管理研究何以重要?对质疑观点的回应及对未来研究的建议

Why Is Indigenous Management Research Important? Responses to Previous Questioning Views and Suggestions for Future Development

井润田,程生强,袁丹瑶

2020 第 42 卷 第 08 期 页码 3-16

DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20200308.101

PDF全文下载 HTML全文

摘要

中国本土企业的管理实践正在得到国内外学术界的广泛关注,与之相关的本土管理研究的重要性也日益凸显。然而,当前学术界依然存在一些质疑本土管理研究目的和价值的观点,例如:本土研究是否就是区域研究?为什么管理研究需要本土化理论?为什么本土研究可以贡献普适性理论?这些观点削弱了学术界对本土研究意义的认识,妨碍着本土管理研究的进一步发展。本文结合“中国企业本土视角下的组织变革与领导行为”国际研讨会的嘉宾演讲和观点讨论,运用已有本土管理研究的一些成功范例,对以上质疑观点进行了辨析和澄清,阐述了本土管理研究的性质、特点、面临的困难等。最后,本文对进一步发展本土管理研究提出了建议,例如:扎根本土情境寻求有意义的研究问题,遵循入世治学精神,选择适合的研究方法和策略,辩证地看待文化思维对理论开发的影响,积极开展本土与主流理论之间的对话,建立本土研究的学术社区。

As Chinese management practices have received wide attention from academy at home and abroad, the importance of indigenous management research is becoming increasingly prominent. However, there are still views that question the purpose and value of indigenous management research. For example, is indigenous research equal to regional research? Why does management research need indigenous theory? Why can indigenous research contribute to general theory? These views weaken understanding of the significance of indigenous research and hinder further development of indigenous management research. This paper combines speeches and viewpoint discussions at the International Symposium on “Research on Organizational Change and Leadership Behavior from the Perspective of Chinese Enterprises”, presents some successful examples of management research, analyzes and clarifies above-mentioned doubts, and expounds the nature, characteristics and difficulties of indigenous management research. Specifically, this paper elaborates the “indigenous” from three aspects: the different definitions between indigenous research and local research, the legitimacy of indigenous research, and the perspectives needed for indigenous management research. In addition, this research illustrates the necessity of indigenous theory in management research through the lens that one good theory will make compromise among generality, accuracy and simplicity. Moreover, indigenous management research can also contribute to the general theory through theorizing about the indigenous research context. Finally, this paper puts forward suggestions for further development of indigenous management research. For example, seeking meaningful indigenous research problems, following the research paradigm based upon the spirit of engaged scholarship, choosing appropriate research methods and strategies, considering dialectically about holistic thinking while building theories, carrying out dialogue actively between indigenous and mainstream theories, and building indigenous research communities following three stages which can interact recursively, that is, differentiation, mobilization and legitimacy building.

参考文献

2 郭毅. 地方性知识: 通往学术自主性的自由之路——“管理学在中国”之我见[J]. 管理学报,2010, (4): 475-488. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1672-884X.2010.04.001
3 郭重庆. 中国管理学者该登场了[J]. 管理学报,2011, (12): 1733-1736, 1747. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1672-884X.2011.12.001
4 韩巍, 曾宪聚. 本土管理的理论贡献: 基于中文研究成果的诠释[J]. 管理学报,2019, (5): 644-651. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1672-884x.2019.05.002
5 井润田, 卢芳妹. 中国管理理论的本土研究: 内涵、挑战与策略[J]. 管理学报,2012, (11): 1569-1576. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1672-884X.2012.11.001
7 李磊, 席酉民, 葛京, 等. 领导研究中的“情境”——内容、方法与未来展望[J]. 管理工程学报,2013, (3): 1-10. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1004-6062.2013.03.001
8 李平. 中国管理本土研究: 理念定义及范式设计[J]. 管理学报,2010, (5): 633-641, 648. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1672-884X.2010.05.001
9 李平. 中国本土管理研究与中国传统哲学[J]. 管理学报,2013, (9): 1249-1261. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1672-884x.2013.09.001
10 卢芳妹, 井润田, 尹守军. 中国管理本土研究的困境与路径[J]. 管理学报,2013, (12): 1717-1724. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1672-884x.2013.12.001
12 马塞尔·莫斯著, 汲喆译. 礼物: 古式社会中交换的形式与理由[M]. 上海: 上海人民出版社, 2005.
13 齐宝鑫, 武亚军. 转型经济中民营企业成长的中长期激励机制研究——华为推行TUP的产权制度创新实践与理论启示[J]. 复旦学报(社会科学版),2018, (3): 156-169. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.0257-0289.2018.03.022
14 孙黎. 蓝军战略[M]. 北京: 机械工业出版社, 2018.
19 谢佩洪, 魏农建. 中国管理学派本土研究的路径探索[J]. 管理学报,2012, (9): 1255-1262. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1672-884X.2012.09.001
20 徐淑英, 李绪红, 贾良定, 等. 负责任的管理研究: 哲学与实践[M]. 北京: 北京大学出版社, 2018.
21 徐淑英, 吕力. 中国本土管理研究的理论与实践问题: 对徐淑英的访谈[J]. 管理学报,2015, (3): 313-321. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1672-884x.2015.03.001
23 闫红, 井润田, 黄雪莲. 组织势: 研究现状与未来研究展望[J]. 管理学报,2016, (1): 148-156. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1672-884x.2016.01.019
24 张毅恒, 曹祖毅, 伊真真. 经济转型中的管理理论创新——2015’中国本土管理研究论坛(第2届)述评[J]. 管理学报,2015, (10): 1436-1441. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1672-884x.2015.10.004
28 Child J. Context, comparison, and methodology in Chinese management research[J]. Management and Organization Review,2009, 5(1): 57-73. DOI:10.1111/j.1740-8784.2008.00136.x
29 DiMaggio P J. Comments on “What Theory is Not”[J]. Administrative Science Quarterly,1995, 40(3): 391-397. DOI:10.2307/2393790
31 Hambrick D C. The field of management’s devotion to theory: Too much of a good thing?[J]. Academy of Management Journal,2007, 50(6): 1346-1352. DOI:10.5465/amj.2007.28166119
32 Hambrick D C, Chen M J. New academic fields as admittance-seeking social movements: The case of strategic management[J]. Academy of Management Review,2008, 33(1): 32-54. DOI:10.5465/amr.2008.27745027
33 Honig B, Lampel J, Baum J A C, et al. Reflections on scientific misconduct in management: Unfortunate incidents or a normative crisis?[J]. Academy of Management Perspectives,2018, 32(4): 412-442. DOI:10.5465/amp.2015.0167
34 Hwang K K. Face and favor: The Chinese power game[J]. American Journal of Sociology,1987, 92(4): 944-974. DOI:10.1086/228588
35 Jing R T, Dong M. Management scholars’ learning from history: Direct vs. Indirect approach[J]. Management and Organization Review,2017, 13(4): 905-911. DOI:10.1017/mor.2017.59
36 Jing R T, Van de Ven A H. A yin‐yang model of organizational change: The case of Chengdu Bus Group[J]. Management and Organization Review,2014, 10(1): 29-54. DOI:10.1111/more.12045
37 Jing R T. Momentum for change: Connecting Chinese and western perspectives[A]. Best paper proceedings of the seventy-seventh annual meeting of the academy of management[C]. NY: Academy of Management, 2017.
39 Kuhn T S. The structure of scientific revolutions[M]. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1996.
40 March J G. Parochialism in the evolution of a research community: The case of organization studies[J]. Management and Organization Review,2005, 1(1): 5-22. DOI:10.1111/j.1740-8784.2004.00002.x
41 Marquis C, Battilana J. Acting globally but thinking locally? The enduring influence of local communities on organizations[J]. Research in Organizational Behavior,2009, 29: 283-302. DOI:10.1016/j.riob.2009.06.001
42 Nisbett R E, Peng K P, Choi I, et al. Culture and systems of thought: Holistic versus analytic cognition[J]. Psychological Review,2001, 108(2): 291-309. DOI:10.1037/0033-295X.108.2.291
43 Pellegrini E K, Scandura T A. Paternalistic leadership: A review and agenda for future research[J]. Journal of Management,2008, 34(3): 566-593. DOI:10.1177/0149206308316063
45 Raynard M, Lu F M, Jing R T. Reinventing the state-owned enterprise? Negotiating change during profound environmental upheaval[J/OL]. Academy of Management Journal, 2019. https://journals.aom.org/doi/abs/10.5465/amj.2017.1162.
46 Silin R H. Leadership and values: The organization of large-scale Taiwanese enterprises[M]. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University, 1976.
47 Smith L T. Decolonizing methodologies: Research and indigenous peoples[M]. New York: Zed Books Limited, 1999.
48 Thorngate W. Possible limits on a science of social behavior[A]. Strickland J H, Aboud F E, Gergen K J. Social psychology in transition[M]. Boston: Springer, 1976.
49 Tsui A S. Contributing to global management knowledge: A case for high quality indigenous research[J]. Asia Pacific Journal of Management,2004, 21(4): 491-513. DOI:10.1023/B:APJM.0000048715.35108.a7
50 Tsui A S. From homogenization to pluralism: International management research in the academy and beyond[J]. Academy of Management Journal,2007, 50(6): 1353-1364. DOI:10.5465/amj.2007.28166121
51 Van de Ven A H. Engaged scholarship: A guide for organizational and social research[M]. Oxford: U. K. Oxford University Press, 2007.
52 Van de Ven A H, Jing R T. Indigenous management research in China from an engaged scholarship perspective[J]. Management and Organization Review,2012, 8(1): 123-137. DOI:10.1111/j.1740-8784.2011.00281.x
53 Van de Ven A H, Meyer A D, Jing R T. Opportunities and challenges of engaged indigenous scholarship[J]. Management and Organization Review,2018, 14(3): 449-462. DOI:10.1017/mor.2018.28
55 Xi Y M, Cao X W, Xiangli L X. A Chinese view on rebuilding the integrity of management research: The evolving He-Xie management theory[J]. Chinese Management Studies,2010, 4(3): 197-211. DOI:10.1108/17506141011074101
56 Zhang Y, Han Y L. Paradoxical leader behavior in long-term corporate development: Antecedents and consequences[J]. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes,2019, 155: 42-54. DOI:10.1016/j.obhdp.2019.03.007
57 Zhang Y, Waldman D A, Han Y L, et al. Paradoxical leader behaviors in people management: Antecedents and consequences[J]. Academy of Management Journal,2015, 58(2): 538-566. DOI:10.5465/amj.2012.0995