领导过程中的下属归因:一个整合性理解框架

The Role of Follower Attributions in the Leadership Process: An Integrated Framework for Understanding

宋瑶,王震

2023 第 45 卷 第 06 期 页码 84-100

DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20221202.301

PDF全文下载 HTML全文

摘要

领导行为及其有效性是组织管理领域的重要议题。早期文献大多围绕领导行为本身展开讨论,新近研究开始从下属归因的视角探讨领导行为有效性问题。然而,这些研究考察了不同的归因内容,采用了不同的作用机制,论证了不同的作用形式,使得学界对领导过程中的下属归因缺乏系统的认识。本文提出了一个旨在系统地理解领导过程中下属归因作用的整合框架。该框架包括归因对象、归因内容和归因后反应及其机制。具体而言,该框架指出:(1)在“对何”归因(即归因对象)方面,下属会对积极、消极和中性领导行为进行归因。(2)在做出“何种”归因(即归因内容)方面,下属会归因于情境和归因于人。其中归因于人按性质(积极和消极)和指向(下属、领导和下属–领导关系)可分为六类(自我肯定型、自我指责型、善意服务型、恶意自利型、高质量型、低质量型)。(3)下属对领导行为的归因会通过情感、动机、评价、互惠、资源五种主要机制产生影响。在此框架的基础上,文章从深入融合归因理论、丰富下属归因的作用形式、拓展下属归因的作用效果及完善下属归因的作用机制四个角度提出未来研究方向,以启发学术研究并指导管理实践。

Exploring leadership behavior and its effectiveness is a topic of great concern in the field of organizational management. Recent research has begun to explore the effectiveness of leadership behavior from the perspective of follower attributions. However, they have examined different attribution contents, adopted different interpretation mechanisms and demonstrated different functional forms, which makes the research from this perspective into different schools and lacks dialogue with each other. This is not conducive to promoting the integration and development of attribution theory and leadership research, nor is it conducive for enterprises and managers to master and intervene in follower attributions.

This paper integrates the disparate research into a systematic framework through the analysis of 42 literatures. To be specific, we propose that followers make attributions about the positive, negative and neutral behaviors of leaders. Attribution-toward-person and attribution-toward-situation are the two basic forms of attribution. Further, attribution-toward-person is divided into six categories based on its nature and orientation. The effect of follower attributions is closely related to its nature. The general principle is that positive attributions from followers bring positive reactions, while negative attributions from followers bring negative reactions. Follower attributions work through five mechanisms: emotion, motivation, evaluation, reciprocity, and resource. Based on the framework, this paper puts forward future directions from four perspectives: deeply integrating the attribution theory, enriching the functional form of follower attributions, expanding the functional effect of follower attributions, and improving the functional mechanism of follower attribution, so as to inspire academic research and guide management practice.

The contributions of this paper are that: First, by integrating the research on follower attributions of leadership behavior, it helps scholars sort out the existing context of this research perspective. Second, it refines the multidimensional follower attribution framework and presents the application of attribution theory in the leadership research. Third, it points out the possible directions to promote the integration and development of leadership and attribution theory. Fourth, it provides enlightenment for the organization to improve the effectiveness of leadership and provides experience-based guidance for the management of follower attributions.

参考文献

10 Andersson L M, Pearson C M. Tit for tat? The spiraling effect of incivility in the workplace[J]. Academy of Management Review,1999, 24(3): 452-471. DOI:10.2307/259136
11 Bowler W M, Halbesleben J R B, Paul J R B. If you’re close with the leader, you must be a brownnose: The role of leader–member relationships in follower, leader, and coworker attributions of organizational citizenship behavior motives[J]. Human Resource Management Review,2010, 20(4): 309-316. DOI:10.1016/j.hrmr.2010.04.001
12 Bowling N A, Michel J S. Why do you treat me badly? The role of attributions regarding the cause of abuse in subordinates’ responses to abusive supervision[J]. Work & Stress,2011, 25(4): 309-320.
13 Burton J P, Taylor S G, Barber L K. Understanding internal, external, and relational attributions for abusive supervision[J]. Journal of Organizational Behavior,2014, 35(6): 871-891. DOI:10.1002/job.1939
14 Cha S E, Edmondson A C. When values backfire: Leadership, attribution, and disenchantment in a values-driven organization[J]. The Leadership Quarterly,2006, 17(1): 57-78. DOI:10.1016/j.leaqua.2005.10.006
15 Chen S C, Liu N T. When and how vicarious abusive supervision leads to bystanders’ supervisor-directed deviance: A moderated-mediation model[J]. Personnel Review,2019, 48(7): 1734-1755. DOI:10.1108/PR-09-2018-0368
16 Chernyak-Hai L, Tziner A. Attributions of managerial decisions, emotions, and OCB. The moderating role of ethical climate and self-enhancement[J]. Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology,2021, 37(1): 36-48.
17 Eberly M B, Holley E C, Johnson M D, et al. Beyond internal and external: A dyadic theory of relational attributions[J]. Academy of Management Review,2011, 36(4): 731-753.
18 Eberly M B, Holley E C, Johnson M D, et al. It’s not me, it’s not you, it’s us! An empirical examination of relational attributions[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology,2017, 102(5): 711-731. DOI:10.1037/apl0000187
19 Elliot A J, Church M A. A hierarchical model of approach and avoidance achievement motivation[J]. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,1997, 72(1): 218-232. DOI:10.1037/0022-3514.72.1.218
20 Festinger L. A theory of social comparison processes[J]. Human relations,1954, 7(2): 117-140. DOI:10.1177/001872675400700202
21 Fiset J, Robinson M A, Saffie-Robertson M C. Masking wrongs through brilliance: The moderating effect of vision on the relationship between abusive supervision and employee outcomes[J]. European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology,2019, 28(6): 756-768. DOI:10.1080/1359432X.2019.1637853
22 Follmer K B, Neely B H, Jones K S, et al. To lead is to err: The mediating role of attribution in the relationship between leader error and leader ratings[J]. Journal of Leadership & Organizational Studies,2019, 26(1): 18-31.
23 Gardner W L, Karam E P, Tribble L L, et al. The missing link? Implications of internal, external, and relational attribution combinations for leader–member exchange, relationship work, self-work, and conflict[J]. Journal of Organizational Behavior,2019, 40(5): 554-569. DOI:10.1002/job.2349
24 Gouldner A W. The norm of reciprocity: A preliminary statement[J]. American Sociological Review,1960, 25(2): 161-178. DOI:10.2307/2092623
25 Heider F. The psychology of interpersonal relations[M]. New York: John Wiley and Sons, 1958.
26 Hemphill K J, Lehman D R. Social comparisons and their affective consequences: The importance of comparison dimension and individual difference variables[J]. Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology,1991, 10(4): 372-394. DOI:10.1521/jscp.1991.10.4.372
27 Huh E, Lee E S. Can abusive supervision create positive work engagement? The interactive moderating role of positive causal attribution and workplace friendship[J]. Management Decision,2022, 60(3): 531-549. DOI:10.1108/MD-10-2020-1356
28 Judge T A, Piccolo R F. Transformational and transactional leadership: A meta-analytic test of their relative validity[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology,2004, 89(5): 755-768. DOI:10.1037/0021-9010.89.5.755
29 Kelley H H. The processes of causal attribution[J]. American Psychologist,1973, 28(2): 107-128. DOI:10.1037/h0034225
30 Kim K Y, Atwater L, Latheef Z, et al. Three motives for abusive supervision: The mitigating effect of subordinates attributed motives on abusive supervision’s negative outcomes[J]. Journal of Leadership & Organizational Studies,2019, 26(4): 476-494.
31 Liao Z Y, Lee H W, Johnson R E, et al. Seeing from a short-term perspective: When and why daily abusive supervisor behavior yields functional and dysfunctional consequences[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology,2021, 106(3): 377-398. DOI:10.1037/apl0000508
32 Lin C S, Huang P C, Chen S J, et al. Pseudo-transformational leadership is in the eyes of the subordinates[J]. Journal of Business Ethics,2017, 141(1): 179-190. DOI:10.1007/s10551-015-2739-5
33 Liu C E, Yu S, Chen Y, et al. Supervision incivility and employee psychological safety in the workplace[J]. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health,2020, 17(3): 840. DOI:10.3390/ijerph17030840
34 Liu D, Liao H, Loi R. The dark side of leadership: A three-level investigation of the cascading effect of abusive supervision on employee creativity[J]. Academy of Management Journal,2012, 55(5): 1187-1212. DOI:10.5465/amj.2010.0400
35 Lyu Y, Wu L Z, Ye Y J, et al. Rebellion under exploitation: How and when exploitative leadership evokes employees’ workplace deviance[J]. Journal of Business Ethics, 2022, doi: 10.1007/s10551-022-05207-w.
36 Lyu Y, Zhu H, Zhong H J, et al. Abusive supervision and customer-oriented organizational citizenship behavior: The roles of hostile attribution bias and work engagement[J]. International Journal of Hospitality Management,2016, 53: 69-80. DOI:10.1016/j.ijhm.2015.12.001
37 Mackey J D, Frieder R E, Brees J R, et al. Abusive supervision: A meta-analysis and empirical review[J]. Journal of Management,2017, 43(6): 1940-1965. DOI:10.1177/0149206315573997
38 Matta F K, Sabey T B, Scott B A, et al. Not all fairness is created equal: A study of employee attributions of supervisor justice motives[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology,2020, 105(3): 274-293. DOI:10.1037/apl0000440
39 Moher D, Liberati A, Tetzlaff J, et al. Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: The PRISMA statement[J]. International Journal of Surgery,2010, 8(5): 336-341. DOI:10.1016/j.ijsu.2010.02.007
40 Muir C P, Sherf E N, Liu J T. It’s not only what you do, but why you do it: How managerial motives influence employees’ fairness judgments[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology,2022, 107(4): 581-603. DOI:10.1037/apl0000898
41 Pelletier K L, Bligh M C. The aftermath of organizational corruption: Employee attributions and emotional reactions[J]. Journal of Business Ethics,2008, 80(4): 823-844. DOI:10.1007/s10551-007-9471-8
42 Qin X, Chen C, Yam K C, et al. The double-edged sword of leader humility: Investigating when and why leader humility promotes versus inhibits subordinate deviance[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology,2020, 105(7): 693-712. DOI:10.1037/apl0000456
43 Salancik G R, Pfeffer J. A social information processing approach to job attitudes and task design[J]. Administrative Science Quarterly,1978, 23(2): 224-253. DOI:10.2307/2392563
44 Schyns B, Felfe J, Schilling J. Is it me or you? — How reactions to abusive supervision are shaped by leader behavior and follower perceptions[J]. Frontiers in Psychology,2018, 9: 1309. DOI:10.3389/fpsyg.2018.01309
45 Shepherd W J, Ployhart R E, Kautz J. The neglected role of collective customer perceptions in shaping collective employee satisfaction, service climate, voluntary turnover, and involuntary turnover: A cautionary note[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology,2020, 105(11): 1327-1337. DOI:10.1037/apl0000480
46 Shi Y W, Xie J L, Zhou Z E, et al. Family supportive supervisor behaviors and work engagement: A social information processing perspective[J]. Current Psychology,2022, 41(1): 347-359. DOI:10.1007/s12144-019-00574-6
47 Sun J Q, Liden R C, Ouyang L Y. Are servant leaders appreciated? An investigation of how relational attributions influence employee feelings of gratitude and prosocial behaviors[J]. Journal of Organizational Behavior,2019, 40(5): 528-540. DOI:10.1002/job.2354
48 Wang C, Wei Y C, Zhao X, et al. Abusive supervision and creativity: Investigating the moderating role of performance improvement attribution and the mediating role of psychological availability[J]. Frontiers in Psychology,2021, 12: 658743. DOI:10.3389/fpsyg.2021.658743
49 Wang D W, Li X W, Zhou M M, et al. Effects of abusive supervision on employees’ innovative behavior: The role of job insecurity and locus of control[J]. Scandinavian Journal of Psychology,2019, 60(2): 152-159. DOI:10.1111/sjop.12510
50 Wang R, Jiang J. How abusive supervisors influence employees’ voice and silence: The effects of interactional justice and organizational attribution[J]. The Journal of Social Psychology,2015, 155(3): 204-220. DOI:10.1080/00224545.2014.990410
51 Weiner B. An attributional theory of achievement motivation and emotion[J]. Psychological Review,1985, 92(4): 548-573. DOI:10.1037/0033-295X.92.4.548
52 Weiner B. Attribution theory and attributional therapy: Some theoretical observations and suggestions[J]. British Journal of Clinical Psychology,1988, 27(1): 99-104. DOI:10.1111/j.2044-8260.1988.tb00757.x
53 Weiner B. Reflections on the history of attribution theory and research: People, personalities, publications, problems[J]. Social Psychology,2008, 39(3): 151-156. DOI:10.1027/1864-9335.39.3.151
54 Xing L, Sun J M, Jepsen D, et al. Supervisor negative feedback and employee motivation to learn: An attribution perspective[J]. Human Relations,2023, 76(2): 310-340. DOI:10.1177/00187267211038514
55 Xu E, Huang X, Robinson S L. When self-view is at stake: Responses to ostracism through the lens of self-verification theory[J]. Journal of Management,2017, 43(7): 2281-2302. DOI:10.1177/0149206314567779
56 Yang J, Liu Y H, Stackhouse M, et al. Forgiveness and attribution: When abusive supervision enhances performance[J]. Journal of Managerial Psychology,2020, 35(7-8): 575-587.
57 Yu L T, Duffy M K. The whiplash effect: The (moderating) role of attributed motives in emotional and behavioral reactions to abusive supervision[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology,2021, 106(5): 754-773. DOI:10.1037/apl0000810