产业集群生态系统:主题、演进和方法
Industrial Cluster Ecosystems: Topics, Evolution and Approach
DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20220223.101
[1]胡雅蓓.产业集群生态系统:主题、演进和方法[J/OL].外国经济与管理,2022,44(05):114-135[2026-11-20].https://doi.org/10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20220223.101.
摘要
产业集群生态系统是由产业种群和产业环境构成的包含经济—社会—环境属性的复合体。本文以中国知网和Web of Science核心合集中产业集群生态系统文献为研究对象,利用关键词共现和聚类分析、时间线图和突现分析以及文献共被引分析,全面梳理经管领域关于产业集群生态系统的国内外研究成果。研究结论显示:(1)相关文献归纳为四大研究主题:多中心治理的组织共治,环境要素支撑的环境共洽,价值协同实现的价值共创,种群间竞合演化的生态共生。(2)知识演进脉络分为2004年前起步阶段、2005—2016年探索阶段和2017—2020年扩展阶段;研究起步于基于类比思维的概念隐喻,发展于以创新为焦点的系统探索,目前呈现出一定的整合趋势。(3)研究方法多偏重于建构性、个案性、静态性的定性分析方法,但近来在系统特征评估和测度指标方面的定量研究有所增加。最后,本文构建了产业集群生态系统未来研究的五重螺旋理论框架,并据此探讨了引入异质性产业情景、探索创新网络重构、关注适应性制度变迁、深化平台架构支撑、强调公众参与等未来研究方向。
Based on research literature retrieved from China National Knowledge Infrastructure database (CNKI) and Web of Science Core Collection database (WoS CC), this study conducts a systematic literature review of industrial cluster ecosystems in the field of economics and management at home and abroad. Data analysis employs bibliometric techniques and visualization tools, such as keyword co-occurrence and cluster analysis, timeline view map and burst detection analysis, and article co-citation analysis. The results are as follows: (1) The overall stream of related researches can be summarized into four topics. The first topic is the organizational co-governance perspective, which highlights multi-actor governance systems based on the stakeholder theory. The second is the environmental harmony perspective, which is mainly associated with environmental factors supporting sustainable development. Within the value co-creation perspective, industrial cluster ecosystems provide a context that is conducive for value creation and realization, which represents the third topic. The final topic shown is the ecological symbiosis perspective, which contributes to the roles of both competition and cooperation in cluster co-evolution. (2) Tracking knowledge evolution in industrial cluster ecosystem research, the process of development is divided into three stages, namely, the initial stage (1992-2004), the exploration stage (2005-2016) and the rapid development stage (2017-present). The discussion of the three stages shows how the literature has evolved from the early conceptual metaphor based on analogical thinking, to systematic exploration focusing on innovation, and reflected a growing trend toward theoretical integration among social sciences. (3) The major research methods used in the literature reviewed are qualitative analysis methods, including constructive approaches, case studies and static analyses. However, quantitative methods for assessing and measuring characteristics and performance of cluster ecosystems are increasing recently. As a result of the review, a quintuple helix model of industrial cluster ecosystems has been developed to build a theoretical framework that reflects the complex interconnection among internal mechanisms, external conditions and research foundations. Finally, future research efforts in this area should be directed towards introducing specific analysis to understand heterogeneous industrial scenarios, exploring innovation network reconstruction of virtual industrial clusters, focusing on adaptive institutional change by integrating explicit and implicit coordination mechanisms, improving cluster platform architecture to support ecological upgrading, and emphasizing public participation in value co-creation and sharing within clusters.
关键词: 产业集群,生态系统,知识图谱,五重螺旋