社会信用体系建设能否抑制企业环保失信?
Does the Construction of Social Credit System Inhibit Corporate Environmental Dishonesty?
DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20220905.203
[1]左静静,邱保印,蒋挺.社会信用体系建设能否抑制企业环保失信?[J/OL].外国经济与管理,2023,45(03):101-117[2026-11-20].https://doi.org/10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20220905.203.
摘要
本文利用国家发展和改革委员会、中国人民银行等国务院组成部门推动的社会信用体系改革试点为准自然实验,以2012—2019年中国沪深A股重污染上市企业为研究样本,检验社会信用体系建设是否降低了企业环保失信行为。研究发现:与社会信用体系改革试点设立前相比,设立试点地区比未设立试点地区的企业环境违规频率平均减少了13.49%,即社会信用体系改革试点显著抑制了企业的环保失信行为。这一结论在考虑交叠DID的偏误、安慰剂检验、改变变量的衡量方式、考虑是否通过验收成为社会信用体系建设示范城市、地区层面的遗漏变量以及其他替代性解释后依然成立。异质性分析发现,政府信任、媒体报道和居民的环保意识加强了社会信用体系建设对企业环境违规的抑制作用,这意味着政府、媒体及社会大众在社会信用体系建设中发挥着关键作用。进一步研究表明,社会信用体系建设对企业环境违规的抑制作用在普遍信任较低和方言多样性较高的地区更显著,这表明制度化社会信任建设弥补了关系型社会信任的不足,为当前社会信任重构提供了新的证据。
With the development of the economy and the increasingly prominent environmental problems, the opportunism of firms in the environmental decision-making leads to more common environmental violations. Illegal pollution discharge, falsification of monitoring data and failing to install environmental protection equipment as required are common, which forces us to explore the causes of environmental violations. Environmental governance has the characteristics of morality and pro-society, so a few studies focus on the impact of informal institutional norms such as religious belief, hometown identity and national culture on corporate environmental information disclosure, environmental investment and carbon emission. The values and ethics of social trust constitute the yardstick of social members’ interaction, which can curb the immoral behavior of firms, so firms subject to social trust may also reduce environmental violations by making more moral commitments to stakeholders.
This paper takes the pilot reform of the social credit system as a quasi-natural experiment to study whether the construction of the institutionalized social credit system will inhibit corporate environmental violations. It is found that compared with that before the establishment of the social credit system reform, the frequency of environmental violations in pilot areas is reduced by 13.49% on average compared with that in non-pilot areas. The conclusion is still valid after considering a series of robustness tests and alternative explanations. Heterogeneity analysis finds that government trust, media coverage and local awareness of environmental protection strengthen the inhibitory effect of the establishment of social credit system on corporate environmental violations. Further research shows that the inhibitory effect of the establishment of social credit system on corporate environmental violations is more significant in areas with a lack of general trust and higher dialect diversity, indicating that institutionalized social trust makes up for the deficiency of relational social trust.
The possible contributions are as follows: First, existing literature studies the influencing factors of corporate environmental governance from the perspective of environmental regulation and capital market participants. This paper finds that social trust, as an informal system, can reduce the unethical behavior of firms in the environment, which enriches and expands the literature on the influencing factors of environmental governance from a cultural perspective. Second, this paper takes the pilot reform of social credit system as a shock of social trust, which establishes the causal relationship between social trust and corporate environmental violations, and supplements the literature on the economic consequences of social trust. Third, this paper finds that institutionalized social trust can make up for the deficiency of relational social trust, which has new enlightenment for understanding the effect of social credit system construction and the reconstruction of social trust.
关键词: 社会信任,环境违规,政府信任,媒体报道,环保意识