制度工作:研究回顾与展望

A Review and Prospects of Institutional Work Literatures

李雷,李倩

2023 第 45 卷 第 05 期 页码 3-21

DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20221026.103

PDF全文下载 HTML全文

摘要

制度工作是指个人和组织为创建、维持或破坏制度而进行的有目的的行动,它的出现为新制度理论的发展打开了一扇新门。本文基于“六何”分析框架,遵循“何谓”“为何”“何人”“何时”“何地”“如何”的脉络,对制度工作的定义、触发机制、行动者、时点、地点、策略的现有研究成果进行回顾与展望。结果表明:第一,现有的制度工作定义缺乏对制度扩散的阐释;第二,合法性机制与效率机制的辩证统一触发了制度工作;第三,个人或组织是制度工作的行动者,不同行动者如何协同开展制度工作的问题尚缺少关注;第四,行动者面对制度压力或制度矛盾时倾向于开展制度工作,但在面对多种制度压力或制度矛盾时如何开展制度工作有待探讨;第五,行动者可以立足六个层次开展制度工作,其中组织子系统、世界系统层次关注不足,组织场域层次最为重要;第六,制度工作策略可归纳为实践工作策略、边界工作策略和情绪工作策略,制度工作策略选择的动因与作用效果尚缺少研究。本文有助于我国学者把握制度工作的研究进展及后续的研究议题,也可以为相关行动者开展制度工作提供实践启示。

Institutional work refers to “the purposive actions of individuals and organizations aimed at creating, maintaining and disrupting the institutions”, including creating institutions, maintaining institutions and disrupting institutions, and its emergence has opened a new door for the development of neo-institutional theory. Although the theory of institutional work has had great influence abroad, it has not yet attracted the attention of scholars in China, and the research on institutional work in domestic academia is still in its infancy, which is difficult to demonstrate the important theoretical significance and practical value of the theory of institutional work.

Therefore, following the research context of “what” “why” “who” “when” “where” and “how”, this paper reviews and prospects the existing achievements of the definition, trigger mechanism, actors, time, place and strategy of institutional work based on the “5W1H” analysis framework, so as to help Chinese scholars grasp the existing research achievements and follow-up important research topics of institutional work.

The research shows that: First, the existing definition of institutional work only includes three parts: creating institutions, maintaining institutions and disrupting institutions, lacking the interpretation of institutional diffusion. Second, the dialectical unity of legitimacy mechanism and efficiency mechanism triggers the institutional work, and their dialectical unity in the thinking of actors is a key to explaining why institutional work happens, and the relative importance of the two mechanisms will change with the change of the formation logic of actors’ behavior patterns. Third, individuals or organizations are the actors of institutional work, but the existing literature usually only discusses the role of a certain type of actors in institutional work, and ignoring how different types of actors collaborate to carry out institutional work and their impact on the effectiveness of institutional work. Fourth, actors tend to carry out institutional work when they feel functional pressure, political pressure, social pressure or institutional contradiction, but how to carry out institutional work in the face of multiple institutional pressures or institutional contradictions at the same time remains to be explored. Fifth, actors can carry out institutional work based on six levels, but the organizational subsystem and the world system level lack attention, and the organizational field level is the most important level. Sixth, institutional work strategies can be summarized as practical work strategies, boundary work strategies and emotional work strategies. This paper holds that the practical work strategies and boundary work strategies that belong to the macro external level must ultimately act on the emotions of external audiences in order to promote the implementation of institutional work. However, there is a lack of attention on the motivation and effect of institutional work strategy selection.

Overall, this paper can help Chinese scholars grasp the existing research results and follow-up important research topics of institutional work, help to alleviate the situation of extreme lack of institutional work research in China, and provide practical enlightenment for actors to carry out institutional work.

参考文献

1 代江虹, 葛京. 制度领导力研究述评与展望[J]. 外国经济与管理,2020, 42(7): 108-120. DOI:10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20200226.203
2 樊霞, 何昊, 刘毅. 政府制度工作、价值共创与孵化器集群形成机制[J]. 科学学研究,2021, 39(12): 2179-2190. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1003-2053.2021.12.008
6 朱秀梅, 杨姗. 数字创业生态系统研究述评与展望[J]. 外国经济与管理,2022, 44(5): 48-63. DOI:10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20211222.102
7 Chandler J D, Danatzis I, Wernicke C, et al. How does innovation emerge in a service ecosystem?[J]. Journal of Service Research,2019, 22(1): 75-89. DOI:10.1177/1094670518797479
8 Cloutier C, Denis J L, Langley A, et al. Agency at the managerial interface: Public sector reform as institutional work[J]. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,2016, 26(2): 259-276. DOI:10.1093/jopart/muv009
9 Creed W E D, Hudson B A, Okhuysen G A, et al. Swimming in a sea of shame: Incorporating emotion into explanations of institutional reproduction and change[J]. Academy of Management Review,2014, 39(3): 275-301. DOI:10.5465/amr.2012.0074
10 Czarniawska B. Emerging institutions: Pyramids or anthills?[J]. Organization Studies,2009, 30(4): 423-441. DOI:10.1177/0170840609102282
12 DiMaggio P J, Powell W W. The iron cage revisited: Institutional isomorphism and collective rationality in organizational fields[J]. American Sociological Review,1983, 48(2): 147-160. DOI:10.2307/2095101
13 Dover G, Lawrence T B. A gap year for institutional theory: Integrating the study of institutional work and participatory action research[J]. Journal of Management Inquiry,2010, 19(4): 305-316. DOI:10.1177/1056492610371496
14 Durose C. Revisiting lipsky: Front-Line work in UK local governance[J]. Political Studies,2011, 59(4): 978-995. DOI:10.1111/j.1467-9248.2011.00886.x
15 Goodrick E, Jarvis L C, Reay T. Preserving a professional institution: Emotion in discursive institutional work[J]. Journal of Management Studies,2020, 57(4): 735-774. DOI:10.1111/joms.12535
16 Greenwood R, Suddaby R. Institutional entrepreneurship in mature fields: The big five accounting firms[J]. Academy of Management Journal,2006, 49(1): 27-48. DOI:10.5465/amj.2006.20785498
17 Hardy C, Maguire S. Institutional entrepreneurship[A]. Greenwood R, Oliver C, Sahlin K, et al. The sage handbook of organizational institutionalism[M]. London, UK: SAGE, 2008.
18 Hargadon A B, Douglas Y. When Innovations meet institutions: Edison and the design of the electric light[J]. Administrative Science Quarterly,2001, 46(3): 476-501. DOI:10.2307/3094872
19 Kaine S J, Josserand E. Mind the gap: Grass roots ‘brokering’ to improve labour standards in global supply chains[J]. Human Relations,2018, 71(4): 584-609. DOI:10.1177/0018726717727046
20 Kurtmollaiev S, Fjuk A, Pedersen P E, et al. Organizational transformation through service design: The institutional logics perspective[J]. Journal of Service Research,2018, 21(1): 59-74. DOI:10.1177/1094670517738371
21 Lamin A, Zaheer S. Wall street vs. Main street: Firm strategies for defending legitimacy and their impact on different stakeholders[J]. Organization Science,2012, 23(1): 47-66. DOI:10.1287/orsc.1100.0631
22 Lawrence T B, Leca B, Zilber T B. Institutional work: Current research, new directions and overlooked issues[J]. Organization Studies,2013, 34(8): 1023-1033. DOI:10.1177/0170840613495305
23 Lawrence T B, Mauws M K, Dyck B, et al. The politics of organizational learning: Integrating power into the 4I framework[J]. Academy of Management Review,2005, 30(1): 180-191. DOI:10.5465/amr.2005.15281451
24 Lawrence T B, Suddaby R. Institutions and institutional work[A]. Clegg S R, Hardy C, Lawrence T B, et al. The SAGE handbook of organization studies[M]. 2nd ed. London: SAGE, 2006.
25 Mena S, Suddaby R. Theorization as institutional work: The dynamics of roles and practices[J]. Human Relations,2016, 69(8): 1669-1708. DOI:10.1177/0018726715622556
26 Meyer J W, Rowan B. Institutionalized organizations: Formal structure as myth and ceremony[J]. American Journal of Sociology,1977, 83(2): 340-363. DOI:10.1086/226550
27 Moisander J K, Hirsto H, Fahy K M. Emotions in institutional work: A discursive perspective[J]. Organization Studies,2016, 37(7): 963-990. DOI:10.1177/0170840615613377
28 Oliver C. The antecedents of deinstitutionalization[J]. Organization Studies,1992, 13(4): 563-588. DOI:10.1177/017084069201300403
29 Perkmann M, Spicer A. How are management fashions institutionalized? The role of institutional work[J]. Human Relations,2008, 61(6): 811-844. DOI:10.1177/0018726708092406
30 Scott W R. Institutions and organizations: Ideas, interests and identities[M]. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE, 2014.
31 Slager R, Gond J P, Moon J. Standardization as institutional work: The regulatory power of a responsible investment standard[J]. Organization Studies,2012, 33(5-6): 763-790. DOI:10.1177/0170840612443628
32 Smolka K M, Heugens P P M A R. The emergence of proto-institutions in the new normal business landscape: Dialectic institutional work and the Dutch drone industry[J]. Journal of Management Studies,2020, 57(3): 626-663. DOI:10.1111/joms.12540
33 Suchman M C. Managing legitimacy: Strategic and institutional approaches[J]. Academy of Management Review,1995, 20(3): 571-610. DOI:10.2307/258788
34 Suddaby R, Greenwood R. Rhetorical strategies of legitimacy[J]. Administrative Science Quarterly,2005, 50(1): 35-67. DOI:10.2189/asqu.2005.50.1.35
35 Tracey P, Phillips N, Jarvis O. Bridging institutional entrepreneurship and the creation of new organizational forms: A multilevel model[J]. Organization Science,2011, 22(1): 60-80. DOI:10.1287/orsc.1090.0522
37 Xiao Q J, Klarin A. Subordinate actors’ institutional maintenance in response to coercive reforms[J]. Journal of Management Inquiry,2021, 30(1): 24-39. DOI:10.1177/1056492619868027
38 Zara A, Delacour H. On the fluidity of institutional change: Complex interrelations between multiple types of institutional work during the Serbian transition[J]. Journal of Management Inquiry,2021, 30(4): 421-437. DOI:10.1177/1056492620949688
39 Zietsma C, Lawrence T B. Institutional work in the transformation of an organizational field: The interplay of boundary work and practice work[J]. Administrative Science Quarterly,2010, 55(2): 189-221. DOI:10.2189/asqu.2010.55.2.189