爱恨交织:上下级关系矛盾体验对员工主动性行为的影响
Love and Hate Together: The Influence of LMX Ambivalence on Employee Proactive Behavior
DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20201115.302
[1]刘燕君,徐世勇,张慧,朱金强,王艺晓.爱恨交织:上下级关系矛盾体验对员工主动性行为的影响[J/OL].外国经济与管理,2021,43(05):123-136[2026-11-20].https://doi.org/10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20201115.302.
摘要
上下级关系矛盾体验指员工对领导—成员交换关系同时具有积极和消极两种评价取向,通常会对员工工作结果产生不良影响。本研究基于社会信息加工理论,探讨了上下级关系矛盾体验对员工主动性行为的影响、员工组织地位感知在其中的中介作用以及威权领导的调节作用。通过对409份领导与员工配对数据的分析发现:(1)员工上下级关系矛盾体验越强,做出的主动性行为越少;(2)员工上下级关系矛盾体验通过组织地位感知对主动性行为产生影响;(3)威权领导调节员工上下级关系矛盾体验与组织地位感知之间的关系,并调节员工上下级关系矛盾体验通过组织地位感知影响员工主动性行为的间接效应,即威权领导水平越高,具有上下级关系矛盾体验的员工组织地位感知越低,主动性行为也越少。本研究挖掘了不利于员工做出主动性行为的个体态度与领导因素,明晰了员工上下级关系矛盾体验与主动性行为之间的关系及二者之间的具体影响过程,为激励员工从事主动性行为提供了新思路。
As the organizational environment becomes more dynamic and complex, leaders often assign conflicting work requirements on employees to achieve organizational goals effectively, thus leading to employees experiencing ambivalence towards leaders. Recently, scholars have examined ambivalence within the context of workplace relationships. Leader-Member Exchange(LMX)ambivalence refers to the subjective experience of coexisting positive and negative thoughts towards the leader-follower relationship; however, the influence of ambivalence on employees’ work outcomes is inconsistent. Moreover, there is a lack of understanding on the relationship of ambivalence and changed-oriented behavior. Based on the tenets of social information processing theory, we investigate how LMX ambivalence affects employee proactive behavior by exploring the mediating role of organizational status and the moderating role of authoritarian leadership.
We collected data with validated scales in 11 companies from Beijing, Shanghai, and Qingdao in China at two time points. At time 1, we distributed questionnaires to 462 employees to measure their demographic variables, LMX ambivalence, authoritarian leadership, organizational status and control variables. At time 2, we sent questionnaires to the corresponding supervisors to measure their demographic variables and employee proactive behavior. We obtained a dataset of 409 supervisor-subordinate dyads eventually. This study verifies the hypothesis with confirmatory factor analysis, correlation analysis, and hierarchy regression analysis.
The results show that the relationship between LMX ambivalence and employee proactive behavior is significantly negative, and such relationship is mediated by employees’ organizational status. Authoritarian leadership plays a moderating role in the relationship between LMX ambivalence and employees’ organizational status. Specifically, for employees under a high level of authoritarian leadership, the negative effect of their LMX ambivalence on employees’ organizational status is stronger. Our moderated mediation model also demonstrates that the indirect effect of LMX ambivalence on employee proactive behavior through organizational status is stronger for employees who are under a high level of authoritarian leadership. This study explores the influence of the factors of individual attitude and leadership on employee proactive behavior, providing new ideas for motivating employees to engage in proactive behavior.
This study makes the following contributions: Firstly, it extends the outcome variables of LMX ambivalence from employees’ task performance to proactive behavior, which advances our knowledge on the relationship of LMX ambivalence and change-oriented behaviors. Secondly, it reveals that organizational status is a path to explain the relationship between LMX ambivalence and employee proactive behavior from the cognitive perspective. Thirdly, it examines authoritarian leadership as a boundary condition aggravating the negative effect of LMX ambivalence on employees’ organizational status and proactive behavior. In terms of managerial implications, leaders should empower employees rather than display authoritarian behaviors to avoid strengthening the negative effect of their experience of “love and hate together”.
关键词: 上下级关系矛盾体验,组织地位,威权领导,主动性行为