企业师徒制一定充满正能量吗?——失调性指导关系研究述评与展望

Is Enterprise Mentorship Definitely Full of Positive Energy? A Literature Review and Prospects of Dysfunctional Mentorship

崔琦,何燕珍

2019 第 41 卷 第 08 期 页码 73-85

DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.2019.08.006

PDF全文下载 HTML全文

摘要

企业师徒制在推动企业师徒个体发展和提升企业价值的同时,也会出现“留一手”“裙带帮派”等失调现象。指导关系的失调性研究是企业师徒制研究领域的一个重点前沿课题,本文以指导主体、内容转移为出发点,对失调性指导关系的概念内涵、决定机制和影响效应进行了系统梳理。文章从个体、师徒交互、任务、组织四个层面阐述了指导关系失调的形成机制,分析了师徒制失调对徒弟、师傅和组织的影响效应,厘清了失调性指导关系的研究脉络,形成了一套全面的失调性指导关系因果研究框架,并为失调性指导关系的未来研究提出了四个方面的针对性建议,以期为企业师徒制的理论研究和实践创新提供思路借鉴。

While mentorship promotes the individual development of protégés and the value of enterprise interests, the disorder phenomena of " church protégés, starving mentors” " mentors are unwilling to train protégés” " hold back a trick or two in teaching a trade or skill” " nepotistic or gangs between mentors and protégés” and so on are commonplace. The research on dysfunctional mentorship is a key frontier subject in the study on enterprise mentorship. According to the relevant literature and social network analysis methods, this paper clarifies and defines the concept and characteristics of dysfunctional mentorship. From the perspective of the guiding subject, dysfunctional mentorship includes apprentices’ perception disorder and mentors’ perception disorder; from the perspective of content transfer, dysfunctional mentorship includes knowledge hoarding, knowledge exclusion, and economic cost differences. Meanwhile, through a systematic review of existing research, this paper finds that the formation of dysfunctional mentorship is composed of four aspects of capacity characteristics: individual level factors, mentor-protégé exchange level factors, task level factors, and organizational level factors. Among them, the individual level includes personality trait factors and individual impression management strategies; the mentor-protégé exchange level includes the homology and consistency of the mentoring, the interpersonal reciprocity of the mentoring and the form of mentorship; the task level includes task characteristics and task binding commitment; the organizational level includes factors such as organizational culture and organizational rewards. In addition, this paper further explores the impact of dysfunctional mentorship. At the individual level, the impact on protégés is mainly reflected in the psychological pressure and negative emotions, the attitudes and work intentions, and the negative behaviors in the workplace. The negative impact on mentors is mainly reflected in the individual behavior, workplace guidance behavior and other aspects. The organizational impact is mainly reflected in the lack of organizational trust, weakening of cohesion, internal discrimination within the organization, and nepotism. Based on the above research, this paper constructs an integration model of dysfunctional mentorship, and puts forward future research directions. It believes that the follow-up research can further develop the localization research of dysfunctional mentorship, explore the behavioral characteristics of dysfunctional mentorship in the Chinese cultural context(including Confucian culture, paternalistic culture, collectivist culture, face culture, etc.)for a breakthrough in the content structure. Finally, this paper provides breakthrough suggestions for the influential effect and the formation mechanism of dysfunctional mentorship. It also provides a systematic theoretical framework for the follow-up research, which is conducive to the effective research and practice of enterprise mentorship.

参考文献

2 陈涛, 朱智洺, 王铁男. 影子连带对企业知识转移影响研究: 以动态环境为调节变量[J]. 科技进步与对策,2014, (10): 131-137. DOI:10.6049/kjjbydc.2013070284
6 童俊, 王凯, 韩翼, 等. 师傅面子需要对徒弟敬业度的影响——师徒关系与情绪智力的作用[J]. 科技进步与对策,2017, (8): 140-146. DOI:10.6049/kjjbydc.2016110473
7 Allen T D, Eby L T, Poteet M L, et al. Career benefits associated with mentoring for protégés: A meta-analysis[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology,2004, 89(1): 127-136. DOI:10.1037/0021-9010.89.1.127
8 Allen T D, Johnson H A M, Xu X, et al. Mentoring and protégé narcissistic entitlement[J]. Journal of Career Development,2009, 35(4): 385-405. DOI:10.1177/0894845308327735
10 Bolino M C, Varela J A, Bande B, et al. The impact of impression-management tactics on supervisor ratings of organizational citizenship behavior[J]. Journal of Organizational Behavior,2006, 27(3): 281-297. DOI:10.1002/job.379
11 Burk H G, Eby L T. What keeps people in mentoring relationships when bad things happen? A field study from the protégé’s perspective[J]. Journal of Vocational Behavior,2010, 77(3): 437-446. DOI:10.1016/j.jvb.2010.05.011
12 De Cremer D, Mayer D M, Van Dijke M, et al. When does self-sacrificial leadership motivate prosocial behavior? It depends on followers’ prevention focus[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology,2009, 94(4): 887-899. DOI:10.1037/a0014782
13 Dougherty T W, Dreher G F, Arunachalam V, et al. Mentor status, occupational context, and protégé career outcomes: Differential returns for males and females[J]. Journal of Vocational Behavior,2013, 83(3): 514-527. DOI:10.1016/j.jvb.2013.08.001
14 Eby L T, Allen T D, Evans S C, et al. Does mentoring matter? A multidisciplinary meta-analysis comparing mentored and non-mentored individuals[J]. Journal of Vocational Behavior,2008, 72(2): 254-267. DOI:10.1016/j.jvb.2007.04.005
15 Eby L T, Butts M M, Durley J, et al. Are bad experiences stronger than good ones in mentoring relationships? Evidence from the protégé and mentor perspective[J]. Journal of Vocational Behavior,2010, 77(1): 81-92. DOI:10.1016/j.jvb.2010.02.010
16 Eby L T, McManus S E. The protégé’s role in negative mentoring experiences[J]. Journal of Vocational Behavior,2004, 65(2): 255-275. DOI:10.1016/j.jvb.2003.07.001
17 Eby L T, McManus S E, Simon S A, et al. The protégé’s perspective regarding negative mentoring experiences: The development of a taxonomy[J]. Journal of Vocational Behavior,2000, 57(1): 1-21. DOI:10.1006/jvbe.1999.1726
18 Feldman D C. Toxic mentors or toxic protégés? A critical re-examination of dysfunctional mentoring[J]. Human Resource Management Review,1999, 9(3): 247-278. DOI:10.1016/S1053-4822(99)00021-2
19 Ferris G R, Treadway D C, Perrewé P L, et al. Political skill in organizations[J]. Journal of Management,2007, 33(3): 290-320. DOI:10.1177/0149206307300813
20 Ghosh R, Dierkes S, Falletta S. Incivility spiral in mentoring relationships: Reconceptualizing negative mentoring as deviant workplace behavior[J]. Advances in Developing Human Resources,2011, 13(1): 22-39. DOI:10.1177/1523422311410639
21 Herrbach O, Mignonac K, Richebe N. Undesired side effect? The promotion of non-commitment in formal vs. informal mentorships[J]. The International Journal of Human Resource Management,2011, 22(7): 1554-1569. DOI:10.1080/09585192.2011.561965
22 Husted K, Michailova S, Minbaeva D B, et al. Knowledge-sharing hostility and governance mechanisms: An empirical test[J]. Journal of Knowledge Management,2012, 16(5): 754-773. DOI:10.1108/13673271211262790
25 Kumar P, Irudayaraj I S F, Jomon M G, et al. The shadow of negative mentoring at the workplace: Is negative affect a mediator between mentoring experiences and a decline in organizational citizenship behaviour of the protégé?[J]. Management and Labour Studies,2013, 38(4): 357-371. DOI:10.1177/0258042X13513134
26 Labianca G, Brass D J. Exploring the social ledger: Negative relationships and negative asymmetry in social networks in organizations[J]. Academy of Management Review,2006, 31(3): 596-614. DOI:10.5465/amr.2006.21318920
27 Liu D, Wang S, Wayne S J. Is being a good learner enough? An examination of the interplay between learning goal orientation and impression management tactics on creativity[J]. Personnel Psychology,2015, 68(1): 109-142. DOI:10.1111/peps.2015.68.issue-1
28 Mahajan A, Toh S M. Group cultural values and political skills: A situationist perspective on interpersonal citizenship behaviors[J]. Journal of International Business Studies,2017, 48(1): 113-121. DOI:10.1057/s41267-016-0036-x
29 Mulder L B, Nelissen R M A. When rules really make a difference: The effect of cooperation rules and self-sacrificing leadership on moral norms in social dilemmas[J]. Journal of Business Ethics,2010, 95(S1): 57-72. DOI:10.1007/s10551-011-0795-z
30 Ragins B R, Cotton J L, Miller J S. Marginal mentoring: The effects of type of mentor, quality of relationship, and program design on work and career attitudes[J]. Academy of Management Journal,2000, 43(6): 1177-1194. DOI:10.2307/1556344
31 Rechberg I, Syed J. Ethical issues in knowledge management: Conflict of knowledge ownership[J]. Journal of Knowledge Management,2013, 17(6): 828-847. DOI:10.1108/JKM-06-2013-0232
32 Robinson S L, Rousseau D M. Violating the psychological contract: Not the exception but the norm[J]. Journal of Organizational Behavior,1994, 15(3): 245-259. DOI:10.1002/job.4030150306
33 Scandura T A. Dysfunctional mentoring relationships and outcomes[J]. Journal of Management,1998, 24(3): 449-467. DOI:10.1177/014920639802400307
34 Schmader T, Johns M, Forbes C. An integrated process model of stereotype threat effects on performance[J]. Psychological Review,2008, 115(2): 336-356. DOI:10.1037/0033-295X.115.2.336
35 Steele C M. A threat in the air: How stereotypes shape intellectual identity and performance[J]. American Psychologist,1997, 52(6): 613-629. DOI:10.1037/0003-066X.52.6.613
36 Topa G, Perez-Larrazabal J. Newcomers’ learning and co-worker undermining: Moderated mediation analysis[J]. Journal of Managerial Psychology,2016, 31(5): 914-929. DOI:10.1108/JMP-03-2015-0106
38 Yi J, Kwan H K, Hu Y L, et al. Revenge exacerbates the effects of interpersonal problems on mentors’ emotional exhaustion and work-family conflict: A self-defeating perspective[J]. Human Resource Management,2017, 56(5): 851-866. DOI:10.1002/hrm.2017.56.issue-5