距离产生美感还是隔阂?国家间距离与跨国并购绩效的元分析
Does Distance Produce Beauty or Estrangement? A Meta-analysis Review on the Relationship between Cross-national Distance and Cross-border M&A Performance
DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20200801.201
[1]乔璐,赵广庆,吴剑峰.距离产生美感还是隔阂?国家间距离与跨国并购绩效的元分析[J/OL].外国经济与管理,2020,42(12):119-133[2026-11-20].https://doi.org/10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20200801.201.
摘要
国家间距离是跨国并购能否成功的重要影响因素,但现有研究结论尚存在较大分歧。针对这一现象,本文使用元分析的方法来检验并购双方所属国家间的距离(包括文化距离、制度距离、地理距离和经济距离)对跨国并购绩效(包括跨国并购宣告时市场反应、跨国并购完成与否和跨国并购长期绩效)的影响,并考虑了国家间距离的“方向性”和“时间性”。通过对44篇独立的实证文献进行元分析后,本文发现:(1)从整体效应来看,国家间距离对跨国并购绩效产生负向影响。(2)当并购方来自新兴市场时,国家间距离对跨国并购绩效的负向影响更为显著。(3)从时间上看,对2008年之前的跨国并购来说,国家间距离对跨国并购绩效的负向影响更加显著。基于元分析的结果,本文系统地分析了国家间距离对跨国并购绩效的影响,并且讨论了未来研究的方向。
How to improve the performance of cross-border M&As has been an important research topic in the field of international business. Scholars find that one key explanatory variable for cross-border acquisition performance relates to cross-national distance, i.e., the distance between the acquirer’s home country and its host country. Existing literature has extensively studied the influence of cross-national distance on cross-border M&A performance, and tried to discover whether and how various types of such a distance affect the completion of acquisition event, the stock market reaction to event announcement, and long-term post-acquisition performance. However, empirical findings on the above relationship remain inconclusive. For instance, some scholars draw arguments from the institutional theory, and propose that cross-national distance create additional transaction costs and have a negative impact on cross-border acquisition performance; some researchers rely on the knowledge-based view and suggest that cross-national distance help acquirers access complementary resources and technological skills, thus improving cross-border acquisition performance; and others apply the theory of information asymmetry to contend that extreme distance or proximity between two nations lead to poor cross-border acquisition performance. Therefore, the answer to the question of how cross-national distance affects cross-border acquisition performance remains unclear.
This study attempts to use the Meta-analysis method to make a comprehensive comparative analysis of previous studies, and verify the relationship between cross-national distance (including cultural distance, institutional distance, geographic distance and economic distance) and the performance of cross-border M&As (including market returns at announcement, acquisition completion or not, and long-term performance). In addition, this study takes the direction and timing of cross-national distance into consideration and treats them as two contextual moderators. To ensure the completeness and accuracy of literature collection, this study conducts a rigorous and thorough literature search. Relevant literature comes from two major academic databases – CNKI and Web of Science – and must meet the methodological requirements of Meta-analysis. Eventually, this study selects 44 independent articles, and conducts subsequent coding, measurement and statistics by utilizing the Comprehensive Meta-analysis (CMA) software.
Meta-analysis findings show a negative relationship between cross-national distance and cross-border acquisition performance. In addition, the degree of home country’s economic development and the sampling time have significant moderating effects: When the acquirer comes from an emerging market, or when the sampling time is before 2008, the negative relationship between cross-national distance and cross-border acquisition performance will be more prominent. Drawing upon the insights from the Meta-analysis findings, this study identifies three directions for future research by considering industry- and firm-level distance, multi-dimensional distance, and directional distance.
关键词: 国家间距离,跨国并购绩效,元分析