定性比较分析法在管理学构型研究中的应用:述评与展望

The Application of Qualitative Comparative Analysis(QCA)in Configuration Research in Business Administration Field:Commentary and Future Directions

张驰,郑晓杰,王凤彬

2017 第 39 卷 第 04 期 页码 68-83

DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.2017.04.006

PDF全文下载 HTML全文

摘要

构型(configuration)视角在管理学研究领域方兴未艾,但由于方法局限,该视角在实证研究中进展缓慢。自Fiss(2007)提出可以用定性比较分析法(QCA)解决构型视角的实证研究难题后,该方法在国外管理学研究中得到迅速推广。与之相比,国内对此方法的应用还处于起步阶段,成果相对匮乏。本文通过对国内外管理学领域采用QCA方法的相关文献进行系统梳理,分析总结出此方法可帮助管理研究者解决的三类难题:探究引致同一结果的多种路径、处理多个前因间复杂的互动关系以及对分类方法做出深化和补充;并提炼出六大优势:对样本量和数据来源要求较低、便于应对前因复杂性、主张因果非对称性、无须对跨层变量进行特殊处理、降低现象复杂性和可完整解读案例。面对此方法应用中最受质疑的稳健性问题,本文归纳出了几种具体的应对策略。在总结QCA最新进展的基础上,本文还提出了深挖既往研究、开拓未来研究和时序研究三个维度的研究框架。

The configuration perspective in business management research is growing, but the lack of supportive research method slows it down. Since Fiss(2007)proposed to use the qualitative comparative analysis(QCA)to solve the problem of empirical research from the configuration perspective, the method has been widely used in management research overseas. Conversely, QCA is still in its initial stage with few achievements in China. Based on a systematic review of related literature adopting QCA in the management field at home and abroad, this paper summarizes that three major problems can be solved in management configuration research by QCA: exploring multiple routes resulting in the equifinality, dealing with complex interactions between antecedents and deepening & supplementing classification. Secondly, this paper summarizes QCA’s six advantages, including the low demand of quantity and sources of data, cause complexity, casual asymmetry, no need to deal with multilevel variables, the reduction in phenomenon complexity and complete case explanation. Facing the most questioned robustness in the application of QCA, this paper sums up a number of specific coping strategies. Finally, supported by the latest development of QCA, this paper proposes a three-dimensional research framework consisting of digging the past research, and cultivating the future research and time-series research.

参考文献

3 彭娟. 基于构型理论的人力资源系统与组织绩效的关系研究[R]. 广州: 华南理工大学, 2013.
6 Bakker R M, Camber B, Korlaar L, et al. Managing the project learning paradox: A set-theoretic approach toward project knowledge transfer[J]. International Journal of Project Management, 2011, 29(5): 494–503. DOI:10.1016/j.ijproman.2010.06.002
7 Baumgartner M. Inferring causal complexity[J]. Sociological Methods & Research, 2009, 38(1): 71–101.
8 Baumgartner M, Epple R. A coincidence analysis of a causal chain: The Swiss minaret vote[J]. Sociological Methods & Research, 2014, 43(2): 280–312.
9 Bell R G, Filatotchev I, Aguilera R V. Corporate governance and investors’ perceptions of foreign IPO value: An institutional perspective[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2014, 57(1): 301–320. DOI:10.5465/amj.2011.0146
10 Bensaou M, Venkatraman N. Configurations of interorganizational relationships: A comparison between U.S. and Japanese automakers[J]. Management Science, 1995, 41(9): 1471–1492. DOI:10.1287/mnsc.41.9.1471
11 Campbell J T, Sirmon D G, Schijven M. Fuzzy logic and the market: A configurational approach to investor perceptions of acquisition announcements[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2016, 59(1): 163–187. DOI:10.5465/amj.2013.0663
12 Cárdenas J. Varieties of corporate networks: Network analysis and fsQCA[J]. International Journal of Comparative Sociology, 2012, 53(4): 298–322.
13 Crilly D, Zollo M, Hansen M T. Faking it or muddling through? Understanding decoupling in response to stakeholder pressures[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2012, 55(6): 1429–1448. DOI:10.5465/amj.2010.0697
14 Crowley M. Control and dignity in professional, manual and service-sector employment[J]. Organization Studies, 2012, 33(10): 1383–1406. DOI:10.1177/0170840612453529
15 Delery J E, Doty D H. Modes of theorizing in strategic human resource management: Tests of universalistic, contingency and configurational performance predictions[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 1996, 39(4): 802–835. DOI:10.2307/256713
16 Dess G G, Lumpkin G T, Covin J G. Entrepreneurial strategy making and firm performance: Tests of contingency and configurational models[J]. Strategic Management Journal, 1997, 18(9): 677–695. DOI:10.1002/(ISSN)1097-0266
17 Doty D H, Glick W H. Typologies as a unique form of theory building: Toward improved understanding and modeling[J]. Academy of Management Review, 1994, 19(2): 230–251.
18 Ferguson T D, KetchenJr D J. Organizational configurations and performance: The role of statistical power in extant research[J]. Strategic Management Journal, 1999, 20(4): 385–395. DOI:10.1002/(ISSN)1097-0266
19 Fiss P C. Building better causal theories: A fuzzy set approach to typologies in organization research[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2011, 54(2): 393–420. DOI:10.5465/AMJ.2011.60263120
20 Fiss P C. A set-theoretic approach to organizational configurations[J]. Academy of Management Review, 2007, 32(4): 1180–1198. DOI:10.5465/AMR.2007.26586092
21 Garcia-Castro R, Casasola M J. A set-theoretic analysis of the components of family involvement in publicly listed and major unlisted firms[J]. Journal of Family Business Strategy, 2011, 2(1): 15–25. DOI:10.1016/j.jfbs.2011.01.002
22 Greckhamer T. Cross-cultural differences in compensation level and inequality across occupations: A set-theoretic analysis[J]. Organization Studies, 2011, 32(1): 85–115. DOI:10.1177/0170840610380806
23 Hotho J J. From typology to taxonomy: A configurational analysis of national business systems and their explanatory power[J]. Organization Studies, 2014, 35(5): 671–702. DOI:10.1177/0170840613502767
24 Houthoofd N,Heene A. Strategic groups as subsets of strategic scope groups in the Belgian brewing industry[J]. Strategic Management Journal, 1997, 18(8): 653–666. DOI:10.1002/(ISSN)1097-0266
25 Judge W Q, Fainshmidt S, Brown Ⅲ J L. Which model of capitalism best delivers both wealth and equality[J]. Journal of International Business Studies, 2014, 45(4): 363–386. DOI:10.1057/jibs.2014.13
26 Ketchen D J,Combs J G, Russell C J, et al. Organizational configurations and performance: A meta-analysis[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 1997, 40(1): 223–240. DOI:10.2307/257028
27 Kim M. Many roads lead to Rome: Implications of geographic scope as a source of isolating mechanisms[J]. Journal of International Business Studies, 2013, 44(9): 898–921. DOI:10.1057/jibs.2013.39
28 Kogut B, MacDuffie J P, Ragin C. Prototypes and strategy: Assigning causal credit using fuzzy sets[J]. European Management Review, 2004, 1(2): 114–131. DOI:10.1057/palgrave.emr.1500020
29 Kogut B, Ragin C. Exploring complexity when diversity is limited: Institutional complementarity in theories of rule of law and national systems revisited[J]. European Management Review, 2006, 3(1): 44–59. DOI:10.1057/palgrave.emr.1500048
30 Koll O, Woodside A G, Mühlbacher H. Balanced versus focused responsiveness to core constituencies and organizational effectiveness[J]. European Journal of Marketing, 2005, 39(9–10): 1166–1183.
31 Korczynski M, Evans C. Customer abuse to service workers: An analysis of its social creation within the service economy[J]. Work, Employment and Society, 2013, 27(5): 768–784. DOI:10.1177/0950017012468501
32 Kvist J. Fuzzy set ideal type analysis[J]. Journal of Business Research, 2007, 60(5): 474–481. DOI:10.1016/j.jbusres.2007.01.005
33 Leask G, Parker D. Strategic groups, competitive groups and performance within the U.K. pharmaceutical industry: Improving our understanding of the competitive process[J]. Strategic Management Journal, 2007, 28(7): 723–745. DOI:10.1002/(ISSN)1097-0266
34 Martín-de Castro G, Delgado-Verde M, Amores-Salvadó J, et al. Linking human, technological, and relational assets to technological innovation: Exploring a new approach[J]. Knowledge Management Research & Practice, 2013, 11(2): 123–132.
35 Meyer A D, Tsui A S, Hinings C R. Configurational approaches to organizational analysis[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 1993, 36(6): 1175–1195. DOI:10.2307/256809
36 Miles R E, Snow C C, Meyer A D, et al. Organizational strategy, structure, and process[J]. Academy of Management Review, 1978, 3(3): 546–562.
37 Milgrom P, Roberts J. Complementarities and fit strategy, structure, and organizational change in manufacturing[J]. Journal of Accounting and Economics, 1995, 19(2–3): 179–208. DOI:10.1016/0165-4101(94)00382-F
38 Miller D, Friesen P H. Organizations: A quantum view[J]. Academy of Management Review,1984, 9(4): 765–768.
39 Mintzberg H. Strategy-making in three modes[J]. California Management Review, 1973, 16(2): 44–53. DOI:10.2307/41164491
40 Ordanini A, Maglio P P. Market orientation, internal process, and external network: A qualitative comparative analysis of key decisional alternatives in the new service development[J]. Decision Sciences, 2009, 40(3): 601–625. DOI:10.1111/deci.2009.40.issue-3
41 Ragin C C. The comparative method: Moving beyond qualitative and quantitative strategies[M]. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1987.
42 Stokke O S. Qualitative comparative analysis, shaming, and international regime effectiveness[J]. Journal of Business Research, 2007, 60(5): 501–511. DOI:10.1016/j.jbusres.2007.01.003
43 Takahashi T, Nakamura M. Bureaucratization of environmental management and corporate greening: An empirical analysis of large manufacturing firms in Japan[J]. Corporate Social Responsibility and Environmental Management, 2005, 12(4): 210–219. DOI:10.1002/(ISSN)1535-3966
44 Thiem A. Unifying configurational comparative methods: Generalized-set qualitative comparative analysis[J]. Sociological Methods & Research, 2014, 43(2): 313–337.
45 Vink M P, Van Vliet O. Not quite crisp, not yet fuzzy? Assessing the potentials and pitfalls of multi-value QCA[J]. Field Methods, 2009, 21(3): 265–289.
46 Vis B, Dul J. Analyzing relationships of necessity not just in kind but also in degree: Complementing fsQCA With NCA[J]. Sociological Methods & Research, 2016, doi: 10.1177/0049124115626179. DOI:10.1177/0049124115626179