组织话语研究述评及展望

A Literature Review of Organizational Discourse and Prospects

张慧玉,杨俊

2016 第 38 卷 第 07 期 页码 57-75

DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.2016.07.004

PDF全文下载 HTML全文

摘要

组织话语研究在本质上将组织视为话语性社会构建过程,以组织情境中的口头与书面话语文本为直接研究对象,以此剖析组织行为、现象、关系、要素及组织本身,这一特殊理论框架与研究方法以社会科学中的“语言转向”为发展契机,挑战实证主义传统,重思语言与现实的关系,对组织研究具有变革性意义,被广泛运用到制度、战略、身份认同、变革等关键组织研究领域。本文在系统梳理这四个领域主要相关成果的基础上,综合述评话语分析对组织研究的主要贡献,进而提出组织及其要素的话语构建过程理论研究模型,并从语言关注程度、理论基础、研究方法、研究主题等方面指出现有研究中存在的主要问题及未来研究方向,特别就中国组织话语体系建设及研究提出基本建议,以期在向中国组织研究界推介这一研究方法和理论框架的同时,为后续相关研究,尤其是中国组织话语研究做铺垫。

Organizational discourse studies essentially regard the organizations as discourse-based social construction process, and analyze organizational behavior, phenomena, relationships, elements and even the organizations themselves by directly exploring verbal and written discourse texts in organizational context. The special theoretical framework and research method take the “linguistic turn” in social sciences as the development opportunity, challenge the tradition of empiricism, rethink the relationship between language and reality, have reform significance to organization research, and have been extensively used in such organization research fields as institution, strategy, identity and change. Based on a systematic review of major findings in the four critical areas, this paper sums up main contributions of discourse analysis to organization research, and then proposes theoretical model of discourse construction process of organizations and their elements. It points out main problems in current research and future research directions from perspectives of language attention degree, theoretical basis, research method and research topics, and especially makes basic suggestions about the construction of Chinese organizational discourse system and related studies, to introduce organizational discourse studies into Chinese organizational management field, and pave ways for future related studies, especially organizational discourse in Chinese context.

参考文献

1 吕源, 彭长桂. 话语分析:开拓管理研究新视野[J]. 管理世界, 2012, (10):157-171.
2 彭长桂, 吕源. 组织正当性的话语构建:谷歌和苹果框架策略的案例分析[J]. 管理世界, 2014, (2):152-169.
3 彭长桂, 吕源. 制度如何选择:谷歌与苹果案例的话语分析[J]. 管理世界, 2016, (2):149-169.
4 Balogun J, Jacobs C, Jarzabkowski P, et al. Placing strategy discourse in context:Sociomateriality, sensemaking, and power[J]. Journal of Management Studies, 2014, 51(2):175-201.
5 Bitektine A, Haack P. The “macro” and the “micro” of legitimacy:Toward a multilevel theory of the legitimacy process[J]. Academy of Management Review, 2015, 40(1):49-75.
6 Clemente M, Roulet T J. Public opinion as a source of deinstitutionalization:A “spiral of silence” approach[J]. Academy of Management Review, 2015, 40(1):96-114.
7 Cornelissen J P, Durand R, Fiss P C, et al. Putting communication front and center in institutional theory and analysis[J]. Academy of Management Review, 2015, 40(1):10-27.
8 Cornelissen J P, Werner M D. Putting framing in perspective:A review of framing and frame analysis across the management and organizational literature[J]. The Academy of Management Annals, 2014, 8(1):181-235.
9 Cornelissen J P, Holt R, Zundel M. The role of analogy and metaphor in the framing and legitimization of strategic change[J]. Organization Studies, 2011, 32(12):1701-1716.
10 Dameron S, Torset C. The discursive construction of strategists' subjectivities:Towards a paradox lens on strategy[J]. Journal of Management Studies, 2014, 51(2):291-319.
11 Deephouse D L, Jaskiewicz P. Do family firms have better reputations than non-family firms? An integration of socioemotional wealth and social identity theories[J]. Journal of Management Studies, 2013, 50(3):337-360.
12 Dewulf A, Bouwen R. Issue framing in conversations for change:Discursive interaction strategies for “doing differences”[J]. The Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, 2012, 48(2):168-193.
13 Easley C A. Expanding a conversation:Is how we live as a culturally diverse society congruent with our underlying assumptions, methodologies, and theories regarding change?[J]. The Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, 2010, 46(1):55-72.
14 Ezzamel M, Willmott H. Strategy as discourse in a global retailer:A supplement to rationalist and interpretive accounts[J]. Organization Studies, 2008, 29(2):191-217.
15 Foss S K, Foss K A, Trapp R. Contemporary perspectives on rhetoric(30th Anniversary edition)[M]. Prospect Heights:Waveland Press, 2014.
16 Grant D, Marshak R J. Toward a discourse-centered understanding of organizational change[J]. The Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, 2011, 47(2):204-235.
17 Gray B, Purdy J M, Ansari S. From interactions to institutions:Microprocesses of framing and mechanisms for the structuring of institutional fields[J]. Academy of Management Review, 2015, 40(1):115-143.
18 Green Jr S E, Li Y. Rhetorical institutionalism:Language, agency, and structure in institutional theory since Alvesson 1993[J]. Journal of Management Studies, 2011, 48(7):1662-1697.
19 Green Jr S E, Li Y, Nohria N. Suspended in self-spun webs of significance:A rhetorical model of institutionalization and institutionally embedded agency[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2009, 52(1):11-36.
20 Hardy C, Maguire S. Discourse, field-configuring events, and change in organizations and institutional fields:Narratives of DDT and the Stockholm Convention[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2010, 53(6):1365-1392.
21 Hardy C, Thomas R. Discourse in a material world[J]. Journal of Management Studies, 2015, 52(5):680-696.
22 Hardy C, Thomas R. Strategy, discourse and practice:The intensification of power[J]. Journal of Management Studies, 2014a, 51(2):320-348.
23 Harmon D J, Green Jr S E, Goodnight G T. A model of rhetorical legitimation:The structure of communication and cognition underlying institutional maintenance and change[J]. Academy of Management Review, 2015, 40(1):76-95.
24 Ibarra H, Barbulescu R. Identity as narrative:Prevalence, effectiveness, and consequences of narrative identity work in macro work role transitions[J]. Academy of Management Review, 2010, 35(1):135-154.
25 Jones C, Maoret M, Massa F G, et al. Rebels with a cause:Formation, contestation, and expansion of the de novo category “modern architecture”, 1870-1975[J]. Organization Science, 2012, 23(6):1523-1545.
26 Khaire M, Wadhwani R D. Changing landscapes:The construction of meaning and value in a new market category-Modern Indian art[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2010, 53(6):1281-1304.
27 Kwon W, Clarke I, Wodak R. Micro-level discursive strategies for constructing shared views around strategic issues in team meetings[J]. Journal of Management Studies, 2014, 51(2):265-290.
28 Liu F, Maitlis S. Emotional dynamics and strategizing processes:A study of strategic conversations in top team meetings[J]. Journal of Management Studies, 2014, 51(2):202-234.
29 Maguire S, Hardy C. Discourse and deinstitutionalization:The decline of DDT[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2009, 52(1):148-178.
30 Martens M L, Jennings J E, Jennings P D. Do the stories they tell get them the money they need? The role of entrepreneurial narratives in resource acquisition[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2007, 50(5):1107-1132.
31 Ocasio W, Loewenstein J, Nigam A. How streams of communication reproduce and change institutional logics:The role of categories[J]. Academy of Management Review, 2015, 40(1):28-48.
32 Paroutis S, Heracleous L. Discourse revisited:Dimensions and employment of first-order strategy discourse during institutional adoption[J]. Strategic Management Journal, 2013, 34(8):935-956.
33 Phillips N, Tracey P, Karra N. Building entrepreneurial tie portfolios through strategic homophily:The role of narrative identity work in venture creation and early growth[J]. Journal of Business Venturing, 2013, 28(1):134-150.
34 Rouleau L, Balogun J. Middle managers, strategic sensemaking, and discursive competence[J]. Journal of Management Studies, 2011, 48(5):953-983.
35 Sonenshein S. We're changing-or are we? Untangling the role of progressive, regressive, and stability narratives during strategic change implementation[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2010, 53(3):477-512.
36 Sonenshein S, Dholakia U. Explaining employee engagement with strategic change implementation:A meaning-making approach[J]. Organization Science, 2012, 23(1):1-23.
37 Teram E. Organizational change within morally ambiguous contexts:A case study of conflicting postmerger discourses[J]. The Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, 2010, 46(1):38-54.
38 Thomas R, Sargent L D, Hardy C. Managing organizational change:Negotiating meaning and power-resistance relations[J]. Organization Science, 2011, 22(1):22-41.
39 Vaara E. Struggles over legitimacy in the Eurozone crisis:Discursive legitimation strategies and their ideological underpinnings[J]. Discourse & Society, 2014, 25(4):500-518.
40 Vaara E, Tienari J. On the narrative construction of multinational corporations:An antenarrative analysis of legitimation and resistance in a cross-border merger[J]. Organization Science, 2011, 22(2):370-390.