教练型领导行为研究现状与展望

A Literature Review of Coaching Leadership Behavior and Prospects

王雁飞,张静茹,林星驰,周良海,朱瑜

2016 第 38 卷 第 05 期 页码 44-57

DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.2016.05.004

PDF全文下载 HTML全文

摘要

教练型领导是西方近年来兴起的一种新型领导方式,与传统领导行为不同,教练型领导行为注重通过领导者与员工的良好互动,来改善员工的心智模式、开发员工的智慧潜能,进而实现员工与组织的双赢。随着教练型领导行为对员工与组织发展作用的日益凸显,理论界对教练型领导行为的研究也越来越多。本文在文献回顾的基础上,对教练型领导行为的概念内涵、理论基础、结构与测量、影响因素与影响效应等方面的研究进行了系统的梳理与整合,探讨了该领域研究存在的问题,并展望了今后的研究方向。

Coaching leadership is a new type of leadership emerged in recent years in the western world.Unlike traditional leadership behavior,coaching leadership behavior focuses on the improvement of employees' mental modes,the development of employees' intellectual potential and thereby the achievement of a win-win situation between employees and organizations via the establishment of a good leader-member interactive relationship.With the increasingly prominent role of coaching leadership behavior in the development of employees and organizations,related research has gradually increased in the theoretical academic circles.Based on a literature research,this paper systematically sorts out and integrates the research findings of coaching leadership behavior with regard to origins and concepts,theoretical basis,structure and measurement,influencing factors and outcome variables.Furthermore,it explores the limitations of current research,and points out future directions in coaching leadership research.

参考文献

1 黄正雄.教练行为与员工效能:人力资本导向之研究[D].桃园:长庚大学,2005.
2 林屏和.金融机构教练型领导、团队工作士气及顾客服务品质之关联性探讨[D].高雄:树德科技大学,2010.
3 王雁飞,朱瑜.心理资本理论与相关研究进展[J].外国经济与管理,2007,(5):32-39.
4 曾慈育.经理人教练角色与员工绩效间关系之研究[D].桃园:长庚大学,2006.
5 张琇雯.教练型领导对个人心理拥有感影响之多层次分析——团队行为整合的中介效果[D].嘉义:国立中正大学,2011.
6 Anderson V.A Trojan horse? The implications of managerial coaching for leadership theory[J].Human Resource Development International,2013,16(3):251-266.
7 Bartlett Ⅱ J E.Advances in coaching practices:A humanistic approach to coach and client roles[J].Journal of Business Research,2007,60(1):91-93.
8 Beattie R S.Developmental managers:Line managers as facilitators of workplace learning in voluntary organizations[D].Glasgow:University of Glasgow,2002.
9 Bond C,Seneque M.Conceptualizing coaching as an approach to management and organizational development[J].Journal of Management Development,2012,32(1):57-72.
10 Boyatzis R E,Smith M L,Blaize N.Developing sustainable leaders through coaching and compassion[J].Academy of Management Learning & Education,2006,5(1):8-24.
11 Buljac-Samardzic M,van Woerkom M.Can managers coach their teams too much[J].Journal of Managerial Psychology,2015,30(3):280-296.
12 Cardoso M L A P,Ramos L H,D'Innocenzo M.Coaching leadership:Leaders' and followers' perception assessment questionnaires in nursing[J].Einstein (Sã o Paulo),2014,12(1):66-74.
13 Carey W,Philippon D J,Cummings G G.Coaching models for leadership development:An integrative review[J].Journal of Leadership Studies,2011,5(1):51-69.
14 Chen G H,Huang W,Tang Y W.Predicting managerial coaching behaviors by the big-five personality traits[J].Journal of Human Resource and Sustainability Studies,2013,1(4):76-84.
15 De Hoogh A H B,Den Hartog D N,Koopman P L.Linking the Big Five-Factors of personality to charismatic and transactional leadership; perceived dynamic work environment as a moderator[J].Journal of Organizational Behavior,2005,26(7):839-865.
16 Edmondson A.Psychological safety and learning behavior in work teams[J].Administrative Science Quarterly,1999,44(2):360-383.
17 Ellinger A D,Bostrom R P.Managerial coaching behaviors in learning organizations[J].Journal of Management Development,1999,18(9):752-771.
18 Ellinger A D,Ellinger A E,Keller S B.Supervisory coaching behavior,employee satisfaction,and warehouse employee performance:A dyadic perspective in the distribution industry[J].Human Resource Development Quarterly,2003,14(4):435-458.
19 Ellinger A D,Ellinger A E,Hamlin R G.Achieving improved performance through managerial coaching[A].Silber K H,Foshay W R (Eds.).Handbook of improving performance in the workplace:Volumes 1-3[C].San Francisco:International Society for Performance Improvement,2010.
20 Ellinger A D,Ellinger A E,Bachrach D G,et al.Organizational investments in social capital,managerial coaching,and employee work-related performance[J].Management Learning,2011,42(1):67-85.
21 Ellinger A M.Managers as facilitators of learning in learning organizations[D].Georgia:The University of Georgia,1997.
22 Ely K,Boyce L A,Nelson J K,et al.Evaluating leadership coaching:A review and integrated framework[J].The Leadership Quarterly,2010,21(4):585-599.
23 Evered R D,Selman J C.Coaching and the art of management[J].Organizational Dynamics,1989,18(2):16-32.
24 Gilley A,Gilley J W,Kouider E.Characteristics of managerial coaching[J].Performance Improvement Quarterly,2010,23(1):53-70.
25 Graham S,Wedman J F,Garvin-Kester B.Manager coaching skills:Development and application[J].Performance Improvement Quarterly,1993,6(1):2-13.
26 Haas S A.Coaching:Developing key players[J].Journal of Nursing Administration,1992,22(6):54-58.
27 Hackman J R,Wageman R.A theory of team coaching[J].Academy of Management Review,2005,30(2):269-287.
28 Hagen M,Gavrilova Aguilar M.The impact of managerial coaching on learning outcomes within the team context:An analysis[J].Human Resource Development Quarterly,2012,23(3):363-388.
29 Hagen M S.Managerial coaching:A review of the literature[J].Performance Improvement Quarterly,2012,24(4):17-39.
30 Hamlin R G,Ellinger A D,Beattie R S.Coaching at the heart of managerial effectiveness:A cross-cultural study of managerial behaviours[J].Human Resource Development International,2006,9(3):305-331.
31 Heslin P A,Vandewalle D,Latham G P.Keen to help? Managers' implicit person theories and their subsequent employee coaching[J].Personnel Psychology,2006,59(4):871-902.
32 Hofstede G H.Culture's consequences:Comparing values,behaviors,institutions and organizations across nations[M].Thousand Oaks,CA:SAGE Publications,2001.
33 Huang J T,Hsieh H H.Supervisors as good coaches:Influences of coaching on employees' in-role behaviors and proactive career behaviors[J].The International Journal of Human Resource Management,2015,26(1):42-58.
34 Hunt J M,Weintraub J R.The coaching manager:Developing top talent in business[M].2nd ed.Thousand Oaks,CA:SAGE Publications,2010.
35 Kalkavan S,Katrinli A.The effects of managerial coaching behaviors on the employees' perception of job satisfaction,organisational commitment,and job performance:Case study on insurance industry in Turkey[J].Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences,2014,150:1137-1147.
36 Kim S.Managerial coaching behavior and employee outcomes:A structural equation modeling analysis[D].Texas:Texas A& M University,2010.
37 Kim S,Egan T M,Kim W,et al.The impact of managerial coaching behavior on employee work-related reactions[J].Journal of Business and Psychology,2013,28(3):315-330.
38 Kim S,Egan T.Invited reaction:The contrasting effects of coaching style on task performance:The mediating roles of subjective task complexity and self-set goal[J].Human Resource Development Quarterly,2013,24(4):459-468.
39 Kim S.Assessing the influence of managerial coaching on employee outcomes[J].Human Resource Development Quarterly,2014,25(1):59-85.
40 Kim S,Kuo M H.Examining the relationships among coaching,trustworthiness,and role behaviors:A social exchange perspective[J].The Journal of Applied Behavioral Science,2015,51(2):152-176.
41 Kroth M.The manager as motivator[M].Westport,CT:Greenwood Publishing Group,2007.
42 Kuo M H C,Chang Y,Chang W C.Perceived organizational support as a mediator of managerial coaching skills and occupational commitment[J].Public Administration Research,2014,3(1):17-32.
43 Ladyshewsky R K.The manager as coach as a driver of organizational development[J].Leadership & Organization Development Journal,2010,31(4):292-306.
44 Lam K T W.Managerial coaching:Behaviors,the measure,antecedents and outcomes[D].Minho:University of Minho,2007.
45 Luthans F.The need for and meaning of positive organizational behavior[J].Journal of Organizational Behavior,2002,23(6):695-706.
46 McCarthy G,Ahrens J.Challenges of the coaching manager[A].25th annual Australia new Zealand academy of management conference[C].New Zealand:Anzam,2011:1-15.
47 McLean G N,Yang B,Kuo M H C,et al.Development and initial validation of an instrument measuring managerial coaching skill[J].Human Resource Development Quarterly,2005,16(2):157-178.
48 Moen F,Kvalsund R.What communications or relational factors characterize the method,skills and techniques of executive coaching[J].The International Journal of Coaching in Organizations,2008,6(2):102-123.
49 Nielsen A E,Nørreklit H.A discourse analysis of the disciplinary power of management coaching[J].Society and Business Review,2009,4(3):202-214.
50 Park S,Yang B Y,McLean G N.An examination of relationships between managerial coaching and employee development[J].Online Submission,2008a.
51 Park S,McLean G N,Yang B Y.Revision and validation of an instrument measuring managerial coaching skills in organizations[J].Online Submission,2008b.
52 Peterson D B,Hicks M D.Leader as coach:Strategies for coaching and developing others[M].Minneapolis,MN:Personnel Decisions International,1996.
53 Peterson M F.Culture,leadership,and organizations:The globe study of 62 societies[J].Administrative Science Quarterly,2004,49(3):641-647.
54 Pousa C,Mathieu A.Is managerial coaching a source of competitive advantage? Promoting employee self-regulation through coaching[J].Coaching,2015,8(1):20-35.
55 Rock D,Donde R.Driving organizational change with internal coaching programs:Part one[J].Industrial and Commercial Training,2008,40(1):10-18.
56 Rosinski P.Coaching across cultures:New tools for leveraging national,corporate & professional differences[M].Yarmouth,ME:Nicholas Brealey Publishing,2007.
57 Hawkins P,Smith N.Coaching,mentoring and organizational consultancy:Supervision,skills & development[M].New York,NY:McGraw-Hill Higher Education,2013.
58 Stone F M.Coaching,counseling & mentoring:How to choose & use the right technique to boost employee performance[M].2nd ed.New York,NY:AMACOM,2007.
59 Sun L Y,Pan W,Chow I H S.The role of supervisor political skill in mentoring:Dual motivational perspectives[J].Journal of Organizational Behavior,2014,35(2):213-233.
60 Theeboom T,Beersma B,van Vianen A E M.Does coaching work? A meta-analysis on the effects of coaching on individual level outcomes in an organizational context[J].The Journal of Positive Psychology,2014,9(1):1-18.
61 Turner C,McCarthy G.Coachable moments:Identifying factors that influence managers to take advantage of coachable moments in day-to-day management[J].International Journal of Evidence Based Coaching and Mentoring,2015,13(1):1-13.
62 Walumbwa F O,Cropanzano R,Goldman B M.How leader-member exchange influences effective work behaviors:Social exchange and internal-external efficacy perspectives[J].Personnel Psychology,2011,64(3):739-770.
63 Wang Y L.R& D employees' innovative behaviors in Taiwan:HRM and managerial coaching as moderators[J].Asia Pacific Journal of Human Resources,2013,51(4):491-515.
64 Yukl G,Mahsud R.Why flexible and adaptive leadership is essential[J].Consulting Psychology Journal:Practice and Research,2010,62(2):81-93.
65 Zhang L Y.Multidimensional managerial coaching behavior and its impact on employee performance[A].Proceedings of the 15th annual international conference on management science and engineering[C].Long Beach,CA:IEEE,2008:977-983.
66 Zhang Y W,LePine J A,Buckman B R,et al.It's not fair…or is it? The role of justice and leadership in explaining work stressor-job performance relationships[J].Academy of Management Journal,2014,57(3):675-697.