创业失败情境下的反事实思维研究框架构建
A Theoretical Framework for Counterfactual Thinking in the Context of Entrepreneurial Failure
DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.2018.04.001
[1]郝喜玲,张玉利,刘依冉,潘燕萍.创业失败情境下的反事实思维研究框架构建[J/OL].外国经济与管理,2018,40(04):3-15[2026-11-20].https://doi.org/10.16538/j.cnki.fem.2018.04.001.
摘要
反事实思维帮助个体分析和解构过去以便更好理解现在,并且为未来行为和事件做准备。创业失败意味着创业实际结果与创业者预期结果或目标偏离,这种偏差能够刺激、激发创业者进行反事实思维。在综述心理学和创业领域内反事实思维研究基础上,从主、客观两方面论证创业者特征、创业失败事件与失败后反事实思维关系,并且讨论了反事实思维对创业者失败后恢复和学习的作用机制,构建理论框架基础上提出未来研究展望。“双创”背景下分析创业失败后创业者的认知和思维,有助于理解从失败中恢复和学习的机制,训练创业者从失败中学习的技巧和策略,对于创业者本人和整个社会都具有重要现实意义和价值。
The concept of counterfactual thinking, which is derived from economics, describes how individuals deconstruct past judgment and decision-making. Baron (1998) introduced this concept into entrepreneurship research, offering a new perspective for analyzing the cognitive process of entrepreneurs. Counterfactual thinking is the imagination, reflection and re-construction of the events that have occurred in the past, with a purpose of preparing for future actions and events. Entrepreneurial failure presents a situation that there is a deviation from expectations or the original goals, which is more likely to activate counterfactual thinking. Counterfactual thinking is affected by a variety of factors, such as the event itself and characterizes of individuals. This paper focuses on the questions: how do different characteristics of entrepreneurs and entrepreneurial failure induce different types of counterfactual thinking? what are the cognitive and emotional consequences of different types of counterfactual thinking? This paper firstly reviews the research on counterfactual thinking in the field of psychology and entrepreneurship. Further we analyze the relationship among counterfactual thinking, entrepreneurs and entrepreneurial failure, and discuss the effect mechanism of counterfactual thinking on recovery and learning from failure. In terms of the characteristics of entrepreneurs, we mainly discuss the influences of entrepreneurs’ regulatory focus, construal level and attribution style on counterfactual thinking. To be more specific, we argue that entrepreneurs’ promotion focus induces upward counterfactual thinking while prevention focus induces downward counterfactual thinking; entrepreneurs’ high level of construction induces upward counterfactual thinking while low level of construction induces downward counterfactual thinking; entrepreneurs’ internal attribution induces upward counterfactual thinking while external attribution induces downward counterfactual thinking. In terms of failure event, we mainly discuss how failure costs, time since failure, and the possibility of reproducing failure information influence counterfactual thinking. We argue that shorter failure time, lower costs of failure, and lower possibility of reproducing failure information are more likely to induce downward counterfactual thinking. In the following sections, this paper explores how counterfactual thinking influences recovery and learning from entrepreneurial failure. After failure, entrepreneurs are more likely to engage in downward comparison, using downward counterfactual thinking to reduce grief, shame, depression, anger, anxiety, despair, anger, guilt and other negative emotions, and producing more positive emotions in order to maintain their self-esteem, self-confidence and self-efficacy. Involving in downward counterfactual thinking helps to alleviate negative emotions, but may not facilitate information acquisition and processing after failure. Thus, downward counterfactual thinking may prevent entrepreneurs from learning from failure. In contrast, by upward counterfactual thinking, entrepreneurs can revise the invalid beliefs and update the existing cognitive system through comparing the alternatives. Therefore, upward counterfactual thinking after failure helps entrepreneurs to learn from failure. Finally, this paper puts forward theoretical framework and future research directions. Future research should consider the impacts of other factors on counterfactual thinking, like personality. In addition, future research can also divide counterfactual thinking into different types based on psychological research and develop the scale with high reliability and validity, which will support related empirical research. This paper analyzes cognitive and thinking model of entrepreneurs after entrepreneurial failure, so as to understand the mechanism of recovery and learning from failure, also to train skills and strategies of learning from failure for entrepreneurs. Therefore it has important practical significance and value for entrepreneurs and the society in the era of mass entrepreneurship and innovation.
关键词: 创业失败,反事实思维,情绪,认知,创业失败成本