年功导向人力资源实践对组织越轨行为的影响:组织政治知觉的中介作用
The Effect of Seniority-based HR Practice on Workplace Deviance: The Mediating Role of Perceptions of Organizational Politics
DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.2018.02.005
[1]吴坤津,刘善仕,王红丽.年功导向人力资源实践对组织越轨行为的影响:组织政治知觉的中介作用[J/OL].外国经济与管理,2018,40(02):68-81[2026-11-20].https://doi.org/10.16538/j.cnki.fem.2018.02.005.
摘要
在企业中,年功通常包含工龄(员工在组织中持续服务的时间长度)和年龄两个要素。强调年功的人力资源实践能否有效缓解员工的组织政治知觉,从而使员工安分守己,不会做出有损组织的行为,是一个值得探讨的问题。本文采用问卷调查法,以48家企业和918名员工的配对数据为样本,对这一问题展开了探讨。研究发现,年功导向人力资源实践能够有效降低员工组织越轨行为;同时,年功导向人力资源实践会促使员工形成较为保守和被动的策略倾向,产生保持沉默静待好处的组织政治知觉;并且,年功导向人力资源实践有助于缓解员工对其他个体自利行为的感知,以及在薪酬和晋升方面自己利益受到侵害的感知,从而降低一般政治行为的政治知觉以及薪酬和晋升政策的政治知觉;最后,年功导向人力资源实践能够通过使员工产生保持沉默静待好处的组织政治知觉,从而减少员工的组织越轨行为。研究结论为本土化人力资源实践的合理化解释提供了理论依据,扩展了对本土化人力资源实践影响效应的认识;同时也证明了组织政治知觉的跨文化差异性。
Seniority usually refers to tenure and age in enterprises. It is an objective criterion. Employees are given higher status passively depending on the growth of seniority. Generally speaking, resources scarcity and discretion in resources allocation may lead to organizational politics. Employees’ perceptions of organizational politics may bring negative effects to organizations. As an objective criterion, seniority almost eliminates subjective judgment on allocating resources to a large extent, which is accepted by employees as a fair method. But whether seniority-based allocation system can ease the perceptions of organizational politics and reduce employees’ workplace deviance has not been explored. To address this question, this paper explores the effect of seniority-based HR practice on workplace deviance and mediating role of perceptions of organizational politics. Seniority-based HR practice refers to practice of allocating resources based on employees’ seniority. Giving priority to seniority, employees have different responsibilities and obligations respectively according to their seniority. This constrains employees’ behaviors and encourages employees to comply with organizational norms. Accordingly, it explores whether seniority-based HR practice can reduce employees’ workplace deviance. Based on this, we further explore the mediating role of perceptions of organizational politics between seniority-based HR practice and workplace deviance. Under the constraints of seniority, employees are given higher status passively depending on the growth of years. They can not engage in politicking to meet their needs. Therefore, seniority-based HR practice may relieve employees’ perceptions of organizational politics and make them behave conservatively, which may prompt employees to reduce workplace deviance. Using the data from 918 employees and their immediate supervisors in 48 firms, we perform multilevel analysis to test the research model and find most of the hypotheses are supported. First, the results indicate that seniority-based HR practice is negatively related to workplace deviance. Second, seniority-based HR practice is positively related to the perceptions of keeping silence to wait for benefits, and is negatively related to the perceptions of general political behavior and the perceptions of pay and promotion policies. Finally, results partially support the mediating model. A significant indirect effect is found from the seniority-based HR practice to workplace deviance via perceptions of keeping silence to wait for benefits, but not via perceptions of general political behavior and perceptions of pay and promotion politics. This paper contributes to the existing literature in three aspects. Firstly, it shows the positive effect of seniority-based HR practice on workplace deviance, which proves the value of seniority-based HR practice and provides a theoretical basis for the rationalization of indigenous human resources practice. Secondly, it indicates different effects of seniority-based HR practice on different dimensions of perceptions of organizational politics in Chinese context, which proves the cross-cultural differences of perceptions of organizational politics. Finally, by analyzing the mediating effect of perceptions of organizational politics, it argues that the effect of seniority-based HR practice on workplace deviance is mainly via individual internalization of ethics and value, rather than the perceptions of other employees’ behaviors. This conclusion extends the understanding of the effect of seniority-based HR practice.
关键词: 年功,人力资源实践,组织政治知觉,组织越轨行为