包容研究前沿述评与展望

A Literature Review of Inclusion and Prospects

景保峰,周霞

2017 第 39 卷 第 12 期 页码 3-22

DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.2017.12.001

PDF全文下载 HTML全文

摘要

随着多样性研究的持续深入,包容成为管理学研究领域的一个热点话题。本文从个体认知、集体认知、行为实践三个角度,回顾、分析有关包容的国内外研究成果,阐述包容感、包容氛围和包容实践的内涵、理论基础、与相似构念的异同、结构维度及测量量表,总结它们的影响因素、影响后果及其中介和调节作用机制,提出未来应该开发本土化包容测量工具,丰富包容的前因、影响结果及作用机制,完善包容研究的方法设计,推进包容的跨文化比较研究。本文为国内学者把握组织管理领域包容的研究脉络和未来研究思路提供了重要的参考。

With the acceleration of economic globalization, the organizational environment of enterprises is undergoing changes, and employee diversity has become a prominent feature in the workplace. Poor management on diversity can lead to hostility, conflicts in the workplace and high turnover rate, which triggers serious challenges to organizational management. As the continuous research on diversity management, the focus of research turns to inclusion, namely, from a perspective of the integration of diversity, it encourages the participation and input of all members in the organization, and tries to make full use of the potential benefits of diversity. Inclusion is an inherent requirement for the effective management of diversity and is a hot topic in the field of management research. To master the concept, formation and functions of inclusion is of great theoretical and practical significance to Chinese organization management. There are a large number of valuable research findings on inclusion in western countries. The research has lagged behind in China. This paper reviews relevant research findings of inclusion from the perspectives of individual cognition, collective cognition and practice at home and abroad. It expounds the connotation of perception of inclusion, inclusive climate & inclusive practice, and analyzes similarities and differences between diversity, exclusion, assimilation, differentiation, social identification, perceptions of insider status and inclusion. Due to the differences in research problem and perspective, concept definition and operationalization, the measurement of inclusion is still at the development stage. There are many different scales. More researches used Mor Barak’ perceptions of inclusion scale and Nishii’ inclusive climate scale. Jansen developed perceived team inclusion scale by taking strict scale development program, which has not been widely accepted, and its division of sub-dimensions remains to be further demonstrated. Some scholars proposed inclusion structural dimension, but did not give scales. The influencing factors of inclusion include demographic variables, personalities, leader and colleague behaviors, individual dissimilarity, diversity methods and practice, communication style and climate, policy and culture of work and family life, and so on. Diversity practice has impacts on inclusive practice, and leadership behavior affects inclusive climate. Inclusion affects employee performance, behavior, attitudes, job stress, fairness and other variables. The mediation and moderation mechanism of the influence process is concerned by a small number of studies. Inclusive climate and practice have an impact on performance and behavior, and related research is deficient. Inclusive climate moderates the effects of team diversity. High inclusive climate encourages the potential value of workplace diversity to be fully utilized, which brings beneficial results to the organizations. There are few studies that perception of inclusion and inclusive practice moderate the effect of diversity practice and management on employee and organization performance. Most studies are conducted at an individual level. Finally, the future research ideas are put forward: to develop localization measuring tools of inclusion, to enrich antecedents, effect outcomes of inclusion and its mechanisms, to improve the method design of inclusion research, and to promote cross-cultural comparative research on inclusion. The contributions of this paper are to grasp the latest research progress and development trend from the perspectives of individual cognition, collective cognition and behavioral practice, to clarify existing problems and possible future research directions, and to provide new theoretical perspectives for motivating employees. It is important to supplement the existing management theories to explain organizational behaviors, and is of great inspiration to the promotion of inclusion research and inclusive management in China.

参考文献

1 陈帅. 知识视角下团队断裂带与团队绩效的关系研究[D]. 杭州: 浙江大学, 2012.
2 首都企业家俱乐部. 包容的力量: 宋志平的企业心路[M]. 3版. 北京: 企业管理出版社, 2012.
3 朱瑜, 钱姝婷. 包容型领导研究前沿探析与未来展望[J]. 外国经济与管理, 2014, (2): 55–64, 80.
4 Acquavita S P, Pittman J, Gibbons M, et al. Personal and organizational diversity factors’ impact on social workers’ job satisfaction: Results from a national internet-based survey[J]. Administration in Social Work, 2009, 33(2): 151–166. DOI:10.1080/03643100902768824
5 Andrews R, Ashworth R. Representation and inclusion in public organizations: Evidence from the U.K. civil service[J]. Public Administration Review, 2015, 75(2): 279–288. DOI:10.1111/puar.12308
8 Bernstein R S, Bilimoria D. Diversity perspectives and minority nonprofit board member inclusion[J]. Equality, Diversity and Inclusion: An International Journal, 2013, 32(7): 636–653. DOI:10.1108/EDI-02-2012-0010
10 Boekhorst J A. The role of authentic leadership in fostering workplace inclusion: A social information processing perspective[J]. Human Resource Management, 2015, 54(2): 241–264. DOI:10.1002/hrm.2015.54.issue-2
12 Bosselaar T. Feeling like a part of the team: The role of perceived inclusion and diversity beliefs in the association between team gender diversity and team performance[D]. Utrecht: Utrecht University, 2015.
16 Carapinha R. Gender differences in perceived organizational exclusion-inclusion: The importance of status closure and role investments[D]. Boston: Boston College, Graduate School of Social Work, 2013.
17 Carmeli A, Reiter-Palmon R, Ziv E. Inclusive leadership and employee involvement in creative tasks in the workplace: The mediating role of psychological safety[J]. Creativity Research Journal, 2010, 22(3): 250–260. DOI:10.1080/10400419.2010.504654
19 Chen C C. The mediating effect of employees’ experience of inclusion and the moderating effect of individual work values on the relationship of authentic leadership style and organizational commitment[D]. San Diego: Alliant International University, 2011.
21 Costa C J. Productive aging in the workplace: Understanding factors that promote or impede psychological engagement in work[D]. Boston: Boston College, Graduate School of Social Work, 2011.
23 Cottrill K R. Antecedents and outcomes of inclusion: Exploring authentic leadership, organizational climate for ethics, organization-based self-esteem, and organizational citizenship behaviors[D]. Los Angeles: Alliant International University, 2011.
27 Downey S N, van der Werff L, Thomas K M, et al. The role of diversity practices and inclusion in promoting trust and employee engagement[J]. Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 2015, 45(1): 35–44. DOI:10.1111/jasp.2015.45.issue-1
30 Findler L, Wind L H, Mor Barak M E. The challenge of workforce management in a global society: Modeling the relationship between diversity, inclusion, organizational culture, and employee well-being, job satisfaction and organizational commitment[J]. Administration in Social Work, 2007, 31(3): 63–94. DOI:10.1300/J147v31n03_05
31 Gajendran R S, Joshi A. Inclusion and identification in virtual workgroups: (When) does leader-member virtual communication matter?[A]. 71st annual meeting of the academy of management - West meets east: enlightening, balancing, transcending, AOM 2011[C]. San Antonio, TX, United States: Academy of Management, 2011.
32 Gotsis G, Grimani K. Diversity as an aspect of effective leadership: Integrating and moving forward[J]. Leadership & Organization Development Journal, 2016a, 37(2): 241–264.
33 Gotsis G, Grimani K. The role of servant leadership in fostering inclusive organizations[J]. Journal of Management Development, 2016b, 35(8): 985–1010. DOI:10.1108/JMD-07-2015-0095
36 Holvino E, Ferdman B M, Merrill-Sands D. Creating and sustaining diversity and inclusion in organizations: Strategies and approaches[A]. Stockdale M S, Crosby F J. The psychology and management of workplace diversity[M]. Malden, MA: Blackwell, 2004: 245–276.
37 Hwang J, Hopkins K M. A structural equation model of the effects of diversity characteristics and inclusion on organizational outcomes in the child welfare workforce[J]. Children and Youth Services Review, 2015, 50: 44–52. DOI:10.1016/j.childyouth.2015.01.012
40 Jansen W S, Otten S, van der Zee K I. Being different at work: How gender dissimilarity relates to social inclusion and absenteeism[J]. Group Processes & Intergroup Relations, 2016a, 20(6): 879–893, doi: 10.1177/1368430215625783. DOI:10.1177/1368430215625783
41 Jansen W S, Vos M W, Otten S, et al. Colorblind or colorful? How diversity approaches affect cultural majority and minority employees[J]. Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 2016b, 46(2): 81–93. DOI:10.1111/jasp.2016.46.issue-2
42 Kim J, Park H S. The effect of uniform virtual appearance on conformity intention: Social identity model of deindividuation effects and optimal distinctiveness theory[J]. Computers in Human Behavior, 2011, 27(3): 1223–1230. DOI:10.1016/j.chb.2011.01.002
44 Kulkarni M. Contextual factors and help seeking behaviors of people with disabilities[J]. Human Resource Development Review, 2012, 11(1): 77–96. DOI:10.1177/1534484311416488
45 Li C R, Lin C J, Tien Y H, et al. A multilevel model of team cultural diversity and creativity: The role of climate for inclusion[J]. The Journal of Creative Behavior, 2017, 51(2): 163–179. DOI:10.1002/jocb.2017.51.issue-2
46 Lirio P, Lee M D, Williams M L, et al. The inclusion challenge with reduced-load professionals: The role of the manager[J]. Human Resource Management, 2008, 47(3): 443–461. DOI:10.1002/(ISSN)1099-050X
47 Lizano E L, Travis D J, Pollack A. Developing an engaged and innovative workforce: The vital role of organizational support for wellness and inclusion across cultural contexts[A]. Society for social work and research 2015 annual conference[C]. New Orleans, LA: SSWR, 2015.
48 Matz-Costa C, Carapinha R, Pitt-Catsouphes M. Putting age in context: Relational age and inclusion at the workplace[J]. Indian Journal of Gerontology, 2012, 26(1): 50–74.
49 McNamara T K, Pitt-Catsouphes M. Relative age, supervisor support and perceived work group inclusion: The role of core self-evaluations[J]. Journal of Intergenerational Relationships, 2016, 14(4): 301–319. DOI:10.1080/15350770.2016.1229551
50 Mor Barak M E, Cherin D A, Berkman S. Organizational and personal dimensions in diversity climate: Ethnic and gender differences in employee perceptions[J]. The Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, 1998, 34(1): 82–104. DOI:10.1177/0021886398341006
51 Mor Barak M E. Managing diversity: Toward a globally inclusive workplace[M]. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE, 2005.
52 Mor Barak M E, Levin A, Nissly J A, et al. Why do they leave? Modeling child welfare workers’ turnover intentions[J]. Children and Youth Services Review, 2006, 28(5): 548–577. DOI:10.1016/j.childyouth.2005.06.003
53 Mor-Barak M E, Cherin D A. A tool to expand organizational understanding of workforce diversity: Exploring a measure of inclusion-exclusion[J]. Administration in Social Work, 1998, 22(1): 47–64. DOI:10.1300/J147v22n01_04
54 Nelissen P T J H, Hülsheger U R, van Ruitenbeek G M C, et al. How and when stereotypes relate to inclusive behavior toward people with disabilities[J]. The International Journal of Human Resource Management, 2016, 27(14): 1610–1625. DOI:10.1080/09585192.2015.1072105
57 O’Hara K B, Beehr T A, Colarelli S M. Organizational centrality: A third dimension of intraorganizational career movement[J]. The Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, 1994, 30(2): 198–216. DOI:10.1177/0021886394302004
58 Pan Z, Lu Y B, Gupta S. How heterogeneous community engage newcomers? The effect of community diversity on newcomers’ perception of inclusion: An empirical study in social media service[J]. Computers in Human Behavior, 2014, 39: 100–111. DOI:10.1016/j.chb.2014.05.034
59 Paolillo A, Silva S A, Pasini M. Promoting safety participation through diversity and inclusion climates[J]. International Journal of Workplace Health Management, 2016, 9(3): 308–327. DOI:10.1108/IJWHM-01-2015-0002
60 Pearce J L, Randel A E. Expectations of organizational mobility, workplace social inclusion, and employee job performance[J]. Journal of Organizational Behavior, 2004, 25(1): 81–98. DOI:10.1002/(ISSN)1099-1379
61 Pelled L H, Ledford G E Jr, Mohrman S A. Demographic dissimilarity and workplace inclusion[J]. Journal of Management Studies, 1999, 36(7): 1013–1031. DOI:10.1111/1467-6486.00168
62 Pfundmair M, Graupmann V, Du H F, et al. Suddenly included: Cultural differences in experiencing re-inclusion[J]. International Journal of Psychology, 2015, 50(2): 85–92. DOI:10.1002/ijop.2015.50.issue-2
63 Roberson Q M. Disentangling the meanings of diversity and inclusion in organizations[J]. Group & Organization Management, 2006, 31(2): 212–236.
64 Ryan A M, Kossek E E. Work-life policy implementation: Breaking down or creating barriers to inclusiveness?[J]. Human Resource Management, 2008, 47(2): 295–310. DOI:10.1002/(ISSN)1099-050X
69 Tajfel H. Differentiation between social groups: Studies in the social psychology of intergroup relations[M]. London, England: Academic Press, 1978.
70 Tajfel H, Turner J C. The social identity theory of intergroup behavior[A]. Worchel S, Austin W G. Psychology of intergroup relations[M]. Chicago, IL: Nelson-Hall, 1986: 7–24.
71 Tang N Y, Jiang Y, Chen C Y, et al. Inclusion and inclusion management in the Chinese context: An exploratory study[J]. The International Journal of Human Resource Management, 2015, 26(6): 856–874. DOI:10.1080/09585192.2014.985326
72 Tang N Y, Zheng X S, Chen C Y. Managing Chinese diverse workforce: Toward a theory of organizational inclusion[J]. Nankai Business Review International, 2017, 8(1): 39–56. DOI:10.1108/NBRI-03-2016-0010
75 Tremblay M. Humor in teams: Multilevel relationships between humor climate, inclusion, trust, and citizenship behaviors[J]. Journal of Business and Psychology, 2017, 32(4): 363–378. DOI:10.1007/s10869-016-9445-x
76 Waters R D, Bortree D S. Improving volunteer retention efforts in public library systems: How communication and inclusion impact female and male volunteers differently[J]. International Journal of Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Marketing, 2012, 17(2): 92–107. DOI:10.1002/nvsm.v17.2