生态问责、媒体报道与企业绿色工艺创新——基于中央环保督察的准自然实验研究
Ecological Accountability, Media Reports and Enterprises’ Green Process Innovation: A Quasi-natural Experiment from Central Environmental Inspection
DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20210921.204
[1]雷星晖,张金涛,苏涛永,郁雨竹.生态问责、媒体报道与企业绿色工艺创新——基于中央环保督察的准自然实验研究[J/OL].外国经济与管理,2022,44(04):51-64[2026-11-20].https://doi.org/10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20210921.204.
摘要
生态问责制度是推进我国生态文明建设的重要抓手。基于中央环保督察这项生态问责的执行机制,本文借助自然实验的设计检验了生态问责对企业绿色工艺创新的影响,并探讨了媒体报道的情境作用。本文以在沪深A股上市的工业企业为样本,使用多期双重差分法研究发现:生态问责对企业绿色工艺创新有显著的正向影响,体现在中央环保督察显著促进了企业增加绿色工艺创新投入。进一步研究发现,这一影响在不同的媒体报道情境下存在显著差异。具体而言,生态问责对绿色工艺创新的促进作用在媒体报道较少或负面报道较多的企业中显著,但在媒体报道较多或正面报道较多的企业中不显著。本文拓展了生态问责作用情境的研究,不仅是对现有文献的有益补充,还为政府完善生态问责的实施机制及如何促进企业绿色工艺创新提供了启示。
Ecological accountability is a key factor to promote ecological civilization construction in China. As its implementation mechanism, central environmental inspection is regarded as the toughest and unprecedented environmental policy in China(Chen et al., 2019). Prior studies have found that central environmental inspection plays a positive role in environmental supervision(Li et al., 2020), as the cross-hierarchy governance of “top-driven” in the design of its implementation mechanism strengthens the rigid binding force of environmental law enforcement. Especially for enterprises which cause serious environmental pollution, central environmental inspection urges them to reduce pollution emissions through improving production processes. Based on the quasi-natural experiment of central environmental inspection, we use the multiphase DID method to examine the effect of ecological accountability on enterprises’ green process innovation, and the moderating effect of media reports.
We use the data from industrial enterprises listed in Shanghai and Shenzhen A-shares from 2012 to 2018, and take heavy-polluting enterprises as the treatment group and non-heavy-polluting enterprises as the control group. The results show that central environmental inspection significantly promotes enterprises to increase their investments in green process innovation, which indicates that ecological accountability has a significantly positive effect on green process innovation. We further demonstrate that the effect of ecological accountability on green process innovation has heterogeneity in different media reporting contexts. Specifically, the positive effect of ecological accountability on green process innovation is significant for enterprises with less media reports or more negative media reports rather than enterprises with more media reports or more positive media reports. Besides, the robustness of the results is verified by parallel trend test, randomness test of policy time and heterogeneity test of media reports.
The contributions are as follows: Firstly, prior studies have investigated the incentive effect of central environmental inspection on green technology innovation(Li et al., 2021). This paper further enriches the literature through studying the effect of central environmental inspection on green process innovation. Secondly, whereas existing literature mainly discusses the role of central environmental inspection in the political context(Cheng & Hu, 2019; Wang et al., 2021), it further expands the research on the context of ecological accountability through exploring the moderating role of media reports. The conclusions provide some policy inspirations: It is necessary to strengthen the external supervision role of media reports on the environmental pollution behavior of enterprises, which can make up for the shortcomings of the implementation mechanism in central environmental inspection. In addition, the external supervision that enterprises face should be strengthened to encourage them to develop green process innovation.
关键词: 生态问责,绿色工艺创新,中央环保督察,媒体报道