隐私经济学:研究述评与展望

A Review and Prospects of the Economics of Privacy

汪敏达,李建标

2022 第 44 卷 第 04 期 页码 3-17

DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20211222.101

PDF全文下载 HTML全文

摘要

隐私是自然人的私人生活安宁和不愿为他人知晓的私密空间、私密活动、私密信息。隐私经济学广义上关注个人、组织和政府之间在公共领域和私人领域中的权利平衡,狭义上聚焦于个人信息的保护与分享之间的权衡。隐私经济学涉及的领域和主题比较广泛,目前的研究结论并不统一,因此系统地总结隐私经济学研究具有重要的理论和实践意义。本文基于供给—需求—均衡—经济后果的分析框架梳理了已有的研究,包括供给个人信息的决策、对个人信息的需求与利用、对个人信息的定价、隐私保护的社会经济后果、数据产权划分等。未来的研究拓展需要关注个人数据的产权研究、隐私经济学理论研究的经验检验、隐私相关决策的认知神经机制以及中国情境下的隐私研究等。本文的贡献在于定位了隐私经济学研究的核心问题,建构了以隐私供求双方策略和均衡为逻辑主线的隐私经济学研究框架,系统总结了隐私经济学的主要研究领域并展望了研究方向。

Privacy is the tranquility of the private life of a natural person, and the private space, private activities, and private information that he is unwilling to be known to others. In a broad scope, the economics of privacy concerns the balancing of public and private spheres between individual, organizations and government. In a narrow scope, the economics of privacy also concerns the individual or societal tradeoffs between personal information protection and sharing. There are many themes and areas of the economics of privacy but no consistent conclusion. Therefore, it is of important theoretical and practical significance to review the existing studies of the economics of privacy and their findings to motivate further researches. We provide a “supplement-demand-equilibrium-economic consequence” framework to review the classical and most recent studies on many important issues, such as the decisions about disclosure of personal information, usage and demand of personal information, pricing on personal information as well as the consequence of privacy protection or the arrangement of the right of privacy.

The existing studies demonstrate that the personal information disclosure is not a totally rational decision-making procedure, and non-standard preference and beliefs such as ambiguity aversion, time inconsistence, framing effect, non-Bayesian belief updating all impact the personal information sharing and protection. It is not necessarily profitable for firms to use behavior-based price discrimination based on collecting and digging personal data because customers will switch to the opponent of the firm and the competition will be more aggressive. Therefore, the welfare of customers may even be higher facing targeting pricing. The targeting advertising may be more effective when the platform becomes unable to use customers’ privacy, since privacy regulation may make the customers concern less about their privacy and the averse to privacy loss is lower. The power of incumbent firms may increase through the collection of personal data. Privacy protection leads to the income redistribution effect, and influences innovation significantly. To maintain economic growth and technology adaptation, it is necessary to find a proper property right institution of personal data to solute the tradeoff between economic efficiency and privacy. However, it is hard to design such a mechanism to facilitate the sharing and protection of the right of privacy, and the anti-discrimination, income equalization and social order effect of privacy protection is also needed to be considered.

We then highlight some directions of future research, which may include the regulation on property right of personal data, more empirical researches, the neural underlying and nudge mechanism of personal information disclosure, and the economics of privacy in Chinese situation. Our contribution to previous studies is three-fold: We clarify the core questions that the economics of privacy tries to answer; we then provide a framework based on the strategic behavior and equilibrium of the privacy supplement and demand side agencies to systemically survey the economics of privacy; furthermore, we highlight some future topics of privacy economics studies.

参考文献

2 李三希, 武玙璠, 鲍仁杰. 大数据、个人信息保护和价格歧视——基于垂直差异化双寡头模型的分析[J]. 经济研究,2021, 56(1): 43-57. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1005-2674.2021.01.010
4 张建强, 刘娟, 仲伟俊. 广告精准度与广告效果: 基于隐私关注的现场实验[J]. 管理科学,2019, 32(6): 123-132. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1672-0334.2019.06.010
5 Abowd J M, Schmutte I M. An economic analysis of privacy protection and statistical accuracy as social choices[J]. American Economic Review,2019, 109(1): 171-202. DOI:10.1257/aer.20170627
6 Acemoglu D, Makhdoumi A, Malekian A, et al. Too much data: Prices and inefficiencies in data markets[R]. NBER Working Paper, 2019.
7 Acquisti A, Grossklags J. Uncertainty, ambiguity and privacy[R]. Carnegie Mellon University Working Paper, 2005.
8 Acquisti A, Grossklags J. What can behavioral economics teach us about privacy?[A]. Acquisti A, Gritzalis S, Lambrinoudakis C, et al. Digital Privacy: Theory, Technologies, and Practices[M]. Auerbach Publications, 2007.
9 Acquisti A, John L, Loewenstein G. What is privacy worth[J]. The Journal of Legal Studies,2013, 42(2): 249-274. DOI:10.1086/671754
11 Adjerid I, Peer E, Acquisti A. Beyond the privacy paradox: Objective versus relative risk in privacy decision making[J]. MIS Quarterly,2018, 42(2): 465-488. DOI:10.25300/MISQ/2018/14316
12 Agan A, Starr S. Ban The box, criminal records, and statistical discrimination: A field experiment[J]. Quarterly Journal of Economics,2018, 133: 191-235. DOI:10.1093/qje/qjx028
13 Belleflamme P, Lam W M W, Vergote W. Competitive imperfect price discrimination and market power[J]. Marketing Science,2020, 39(5): 996-1015. DOI:10.1287/mksc.2020.1234
14 Benndorf V, Kübler D, Normann H T. Privacy concerns, voluntary disclosure of information, and unraveling: An experiment[J]. European Economic Review,2015, 75: 43-59. DOI:10.1016/j.euroecorev.2015.01.005
16 Beresford A R, Kübler D, Preibusch S. Unwillingness to pay for privacy: A field experiment[J]. Economics Letters,2012, 117(1): 25-27. DOI:10.1016/j.econlet.2012.04.077
17 Bergemann D, Bonatti A. Selling cookies[J]. American Economic Journal:Microeconomics,2015, 7(3): 259-294. DOI:10.1257/mic.20140155
19 Casadesus-Masanell R, Hervas-Drane A. Competing with privacy[J]. Management Science,2015, 61(1): 229-246. DOI:10.1287/mnsc.2014.2023
20 Chen Y X, Zhang Z J. Dynamic targeted pricing with strategic consumers[J]. International Journal of Industrial Organization,2009, 27(1): 43-50. DOI:10.1016/j.ijindorg.2008.03.002
21 Chen Z J, Choe C, Matsushima N. Competitive personalized pricing[J]. Management Science,2020, 66(9): 4003-4023. DOI:10.1287/mnsc.2019.3392
22 Choi J P, Jeon D S, Kim B C. Privacy and personal data collection with information externalities[J]. Journal of Public Economics,2019, 173: 113-124. DOI:10.1016/j.jpubeco.2019.02.001
23 Cong L W, Xie D X, Zhang L T. Knowledge accumulation, privacy, and growth in a data economy[J]. Management Science,2021, 67(10): 6480-6492. DOI:10.1287/mnsc.2021.3986
24 De Corniere A, De Nijs R. Online advertising and privacy[J]. The RAND Journal of Economics,2016, 47(1): 48-72. DOI:10.1111/1756-2171.12118
25 Dengler S, Prüfer J. Consumers’ privacy choices in the era of big data[J]. Games and Economic Behavior,2021, 130: 499-520. DOI:10.1016/j.geb.2021.09.007
26 Doleac J L, Hansen B. The unintended consequences of “ban the box”: Statistical discrimination and employment outcomes when criminal histories are hidden[J]. Journal of Labor Economics,2020, 38(2): 321-374. DOI:10.1086/705880
27 Dosis A, Sand-Zantman W. The ownership of data[R]. ESSEC Working Paper, 2020.
28 Gal-Or E, Gal-Or R, Penmetsa N. The role of user privacy concerns in shaping competition among platforms[J]. Information Systems Research,2018, 29(3): 698-722. DOI:10.1287/isre.2017.0730
29 Garratt R J, Van Oordt M R C. Privacy as a public good: A case for electronic cash[J]. Journal of Political Economy,2021, 129(7): 2157-2180. DOI:10.1086/714133
30 Goldfarb A, Tucker C. Online display advertising: Targeting and obtrusiveness[J]. Marketing Science,2011, 30(3): 389-404. DOI:10.1287/mksc.1100.0583
31 Hermalin B E, Katz M L. Privacy, property rights and efficiency: The economics of privacy as secrecy[J]. Quantitative Marketing and Economics,2006, 4(3): 209-239. DOI:10.1007/s11129-005-9004-7
32 Huck S, Weizsacker G. Markets for leaked information[R]. SSRN Working Paper, 2016.
33 Hughes-Cromwick E, Coronado J. The value of US government data to US business decisions[J]. Journal of Economic Perspectives,2019, 33(1): 131-46. DOI:10.1257/jep.33.1.131
34 Ichihashi S. Online privacy and information disclosure by consumers[J]. American Economic Review,2020, 110(2): 569-595. DOI:10.1257/aer.20181052
35 Jones C I, Tonetti C. Nonrivalry and the economics of data[J]. American Economic Review,2020, 110(9): 2819-2858. DOI:10.1257/aer.20191330
37 Kummer M, Schulte P. When private information settles the bill: Money and privacy in Google’s market for smartphone applications[J]. Management Science,2019, 65(8): 3470-3494. DOI:10.1287/mnsc.2018.3132
39 Montes R, Sand-Zantman W, Valletti T M. The value of personal information in online markets with endogenous privacy[J]. Management Science,2019, 65(3): 955-1453. DOI:10.1287/mnsc.2017.2841
40 Norberg P A, Horne D R, Horne D A. The privacy paradox: Personal information disclosure intentions versus behaviors[J]. Journal of Consumer Affairs,2007, 41(1): 100-126. DOI:10.1111/j.1745-6606.2006.00070.x
41 Samuelson P. Privacy as intellectual property[J]. Stanford Law Review,2000, 52(5): 1125-1173. DOI:10.2307/1229511
42 Taylor C, Wagman L. Consumer privacy in oligopolistic markets: Winners, losers, and welfare[J]. International Journal of Industrial Organization,2014, 34: 80-84. DOI:10.1016/j.ijindorg.2014.02.010
43 Vijayakumar N, Flournoy J C, Mills K L, et al. Getting to know me better: An fMRI study of intimate and superficial self-disclosure to friends during adolescence[J]. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,2020, 118(5): 885-899. DOI:10.1037/pspa0000182