“战略即实践”学派述评——兼与“知行合一”观对话

Strategy as Practice: A Critical Review and a Conversation with “Zhi-xing-he-yi” Perspective

肖建强,孙黎,罗肖依

2018 第 40 卷 第 03 期 页码 3-19

DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.2018.03.001

PDF全文下载 HTML全文

摘要

在西方现代社会理论“实践转向”的大背景下,战略管理研究中兴起了“战略即实践”的视角,将战略实践活动、惯例以及实践者作为核心研究对象。经过二十多年的发展,“战略即实践”学派初步形成。它关注“生活世界”,以诠释学中的“筑造”模式和“栖居”模式为本体论基础,重新界定了战略研究中“结构”与“能动性”的关系,扩展了战略研究的边界,并与制度理论、惯例理论、身份理论、叙事理论进行了对话与融合。本文回顾并讨论了这一学派发展的基本脉络、哲学基础、基本原理、应用范例以及发展面临的挑战,指出了它对推动中国本土管理“实践转向”的启示。此外,本文从行动者、行动导向、行动逻辑等方面比较了它与中国古典“知行合一”观的异同,展望了研究本土管理实践和建构理论的新机会。

This paper offers a comprehensive and critical review of the " strategy as practice” (SAP) perspective in strategy field and makes a conversation between SAP and Chinese traditional " zhi-xing-he-yi” perspective. SAP perspective emerges under the " practice turn” in western contemporary social theories. Practice theorists adopt a holism view about the world rather than dualism, with a focus on the micro activities of people and the interconnection of these activities with macro social structure or bigger phenomenon. Rooted in practice theories, the SAP perspective emphasizes that strategy is something people do, different from traditional strategy research treating strategy as something organizations have.

Drawing partly from process as well as other-related approaches to strategy, SAP researchers start to form a distinctive academic school with many influential, theoretical, and empirical publications. Early SAP studies attempt to investigate how managers " do strategy” or the strategizing activities of strategy practitioners. The 3P framework (practice, praxis, and practitioner) completes the " practice turn” in strategy; practice refers to the various tools, norms, and procedures of strategy work, praxis refers to the activities involved in strategy-making, and practitioners are all those involved in, or seeking to influence strategy-making. The philosophical foundation of the SAP perspective is phenomenology and hermeneutics that care about the life-world. Building and dwelling are two epistemological worldviews for researching strategy as practice. SAP research has re-conceptualized the " structure-agency” relation, and has extended the boundary of strategy research with three fundamental principles, i.e. practice constrains and enables actions, understanding strategy-making is the primary goal of praxis studies, and we should pay attention to the multiple roles and identities of practitioners.

SAP school also has many conversations with other theoretical approaches of organization studies. SAP and institutional theory share identical theoretical foundations and can learn from each other for further development. Routine dynamics theory is compatible with SAP perspective and can contribute to SAP research as well. Identity theory suggests that identity and strategy are mutually constructed through practice, thus it is tightly connected with SAP. Narrative theory, which pays attention to the production, consumption, reading and understanding of texts or narratives, is a theoretical foundation of SAP.

Two challenges lay ahead of SAP research. One is practical relevance and the other is future direction. Seemingly paradoxical, the practice approach to strategy faces the practical relevance challenge that can be alleviated with the idea of conceptual relevance of practice research according to extant studies. Considerations about the future directions of SAP follow the practical relevance challenge and some scholars have made their suggestions. When comparing SAP with traditional " zhi-xing-he-yi” perspective, we find that they share most philosophical ideas. They both look at the world with a " relational” and process view. The difference between two perspectives is that " zhi-xing-he-yi” requires a higher moral standard of practice and encodes two directions of practice (inside-out and outside-in).

SAP perspective contributes vital insights to the dialogue about indigenous management research within Chinese academic communities. The fast growing and distinctive management practice of Chinese companies, together with the economic and social transition, makes China now a great context for management and strategy researchers to build indigenous theories. Studies from the SAP perspective offer opportunities for studying the " doing” of indigenous practitioners, either individuals or organizations. As Peter Drucker said, " management is practice; its essence is not knowing but doing”. This paper introduces the SAP perspective, relates it to Chinese traditional philosophical wisdom about knowing and doing, and hopefully will help to facilitate a " practice turn” in indigenous management research.

参考文献

1 陈春花. 浅论管理研究与管理实务的结合[J]. 管理学报, 2017, (8): 1123–1127.
4 孙黎, 李平. 好理论, 坏管理[J]. 中欧商业评论, 2014, (9): 34–39.
5 徐淑英, 任兵, 吕力. 管理理论构建论文集[M]. 北京: 北京大学出版社, 2016.
6 Bourdieu P, Nice R. Outline of a theory of practice[M]. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1977.
7 Bourdieu P, Nice R. The logic of practice[M]. Cambridge: Polity, 1990.
8 Chia R, Holt R. Strategy as practical coping: A Heideggerian perspective[J]. Organization Studies, 2006, 27(5): 635–655. DOI:10.1177/0170840606064102
9 Chia R, MacKay B. Post-processual challenges for the emerging strategy-as-practice perspective: Discovering strategy in the logic of practice[J]. Human Relations, 2007, 60(1): 217–242. DOI:10.1177/0018726707075291
10 Chia R, Rasche A. Epistemological alternatives for researching strategy as practice: Building and dwelling worldviews[A]. Golsorkhi D, Rouleau L, Seidl D, et al. Cambridge handbook of strategy as practice[M]. 2nd ed. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2015.
11 Feldman M S. Theory of routine dynamics and connections to strategy as practice[A]. Golsorkhi D, Rouleau L, Seidl D, et al. Cambridge handbook of strategy as practice[M]. 2nd ed. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2015.
12 Feldman M S, Orlikowski W J. Theorizing practice and practicing theory[J]. Organization Science, 2011, 22(5): 1240–1253. DOI:10.1287/orsc.1100.0612
13 Fenton C, Langley A. Strategy as practice and the narrative turn[J]. Organization Studies, 2011, 32(9): 1171–1196. DOI:10.1177/0170840611410838
14 Jarzabkowski P. Strategy as practice: Recursiveness, adaptation, and practices-in-use[J]. Organization Studies, 2004, 25(4): 529–560. DOI:10.1177/0170840604040675
15 Jarzabkowski P. Shaping strategy as a structuration process[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2008, 51(4): 621–650.
16 Jarzabkowski P, Kaplan S, Seidl D, et al. On the risk of studying practices in isolation: Linking what, who, and how in strategy research[J]. Strategic Organization, 2016, 14(3): 248–259. DOI:10.1177/1476127015604125
17 Jarzabkowski P, Seidl D. The role of meetings in the social practice of strategy[J]. Organization Studies, 2008, 29(11): 1391–1426. DOI:10.1177/0170840608096388
18 Jarzabkowski P, Spee A P. Strategy-as-practice: A review and future directions for the field[J]. International Journal of Management Reviews, 2009, 11(1): 69–95. DOI:10.1111/ijmr.2009.11.issue-1
19 Jarzabkowski P, Wolf C. An activity theory approach to strategy as practice[A]. Golsorkhi D, Rouleau L, Seidl D, et al. Cambridge handbook of strategy as practice[M]. 2nd ed. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2015.
20 Johnson G, Langley A, Melin L, et al. Introducing the strategy as practice perspective[A]. Johnson G, Langley A, Melin L, et al. Strategy as practice: Research directions and resources[M]. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2007.
21 Johnson G, Melin L, Whittington R. Micro strategy and strategizing: Towards an activity-based view[J]. Journal of Management Studies, 2003, 40(1): 3–22. DOI:10.1111/1467-6486.t01-2-00002
22 Johnson G, Prashantham S, Floyd S W, et al. The ritualization of strategy workshops[J]. Organization Studies, 2010, 31(12): 1589–1618. DOI:10.1177/0170840610376146
23 Kaplan S. Strategy and PowerPoint: An inquiry into the epistemic culture and machinery of strategy making[J]. Organization Science, 2011, 22(2): 320–346. DOI:10.1287/orsc.1100.0531
24 Langley A. The ongoing challenge of developing cumulative knowledge about strategy as practice[A]. Golsorkhi D, Rouleau L, Seidl D, et al. Cambridge handbook of strategy as practice[M]. 2nd ed. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2015.
25 Lawrence T B, Suddaby R. Institutions and institutional work[A]. Clegg S R, Hardy C, Lawrence T B, et al. Handbook of organization studies[M]. 2nd ed. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE, 2006.
26 Lawrence T B, Suddaby R, Leca B. Institutional work: Actors and agency in institutional studies of organizations[M]. New York: Cambridge University Press, 2009.
27 Navis C, Glynn M A. Legitimate distinctiveness and the entrepreneurial identity: Influence on investor judgments of new venture plausibility[J]. Academy of Management Review, 2011, 36(3): 479–499.
28 Oliver D. Identity work as a strategic practice[A]. Golsorkhi D, Rouleau L, Seidl D, et al. Cambridge handbook of strategy as practice[M]. 2nd ed. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2015.
29 Orlikowski W J. Using technology and constituting structures: A practice lens for studying technology in organizations[J]. Organization Science, 2000, 11(4): 404–428. DOI:10.1287/orsc.11.4.404.14600
30 Orlikowski W J. Practice in research: Phenomenon, perspective and philosophy[A]. Golsorkhi D, Rouleau L, Seidl D, et al. Cambridge handbook of strategy as practice[M]. 2nd ed. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2015.
31 Sandberg J, Dall’Alba G. Returning to practice anew: A life-world perspective[J]. Organization Studies, 2009, 30(12): 1349–1368. DOI:10.1177/0170840609349872
32 Sandberg J, Tsoukas H. Grasping the logic of practice: Theorizing through practical rationality[J]. Academy of Management Review, 2011, 36(2): 338–360.
33 Schatzki T R, Cetina K K, von Savigny E. The practice turn in contemporary theory[M]. London: Routledge, 2001.
34 Seidl D. General strategy concepts and the ecology of strategy discourses: A systemic-discursive perspective[J]. Organization Studies, 2007, 28(2): 197–218. DOI:10.1177/0170840606067994
35 Seidl D, Whittington R. Enlarging the strategy-as-practice research agenda: Towards taller and flatter ontologies[J]. Organization Studies, 2014, 35(10): 1407–1421. DOI:10.1177/0170840614541886
36 Smets M, Aristidou A, Whittington R. Towards a practice-driven institutionalism[A]. Greenwood R, Oliver C, Lawrence T B, et al. The SAGE handbook of organizational institutionalism[M]. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE, 2017.
37 Smets M, Morris T, Greenwood R. From practice to field: A multilevel model of practice-driven institutional change[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2012, 55(4): 877–904. DOI:10.5465/amj.2010.0013
38 Splitter V, Seidl D. Practical relevance of practice-based research on strategy[A]. Golsorkhi D, Rouleau L, Seidl D, et al. Cambridge handbook of strategy as practice[M]. 2nd ed. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2015.
39 Suddaby R, Seidl D, Lê J K. Strategy-as-practice meets neo-institutional theory[J]. Strategic Organization, 2013, 11(3): 329–344. DOI:10.1177/1476127013497618
40 Tsoukas H. Making strategy: Meta-theoretical insights from Heideggerian phenomenology[A]. Golsorkhi D, Rouleau L, Seidl D, et al. Cambridge handbook of strategy as practice[M]. 2nd ed. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2015.
41 Vaara E, Whittington R. Strategy-as-practice: Taking social practices seriously[J]. Academy of Management Annals, 2012, 6(1): 285–336. DOI:10.1080/19416520.2012.672039
42 Whittington R. Strategy as practice[J]. Long Range Planning, 1996, 29(5): 731–735. DOI:10.1016/0024-6301(96)00068-4
43 Whittington R. Completing the practice turn in strategy research[J]. Organization Studies, 2006, 27(5): 613–634. DOI:10.1177/0170840606064101
44 Whittington R. Strategy practice and strategy process: Family differences and the sociological eye[J]. Organization Studies, 2007, 28(10): 1575–1586. DOI:10.1177/0170840607081557