突出用户相似性还是突出产品相似性?——推荐解释框架对消费者点击意愿的影响研究

Highlight Similarity between Users or Similarity between Products? The Impact of Recommendation Interpretation Frameworks on Consumer Click Intention

王永贵,刘冬梅

2024 第 46 卷 第 03 期 页码 3-17

DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20230610.102

PDF全文下载 HTML全文

摘要

本文基于社会影响理论,通过3个实验考察了突出用户之间相似性的框架和突出产品之间相似性的框架对消费者点击意愿的影响,并剖析了感知产品匹配性在其中所发挥的中介效应以及产品类型和推荐数量在其中所扮演的调节角色。研究表明:与突出产品之间相似性的框架相比,突出用户之间相似性的框架会使消费者产生更高的感知产品匹配性,进而增强其点击意愿。但这种框架效应会受到产品类型的调节作用:对于享乐型产品而言,突出用户之间相似性的框架往往更加有效;而对于实用型产品而言,突出产品之间相似性的框架则更加有效。而且推荐解释的框架效应只有在推荐数量为一个时才发生;当推荐数量为多个时,感知产品匹配性和点击意愿在两种推荐解释框架条件下均无显著差异。本文不仅推进了个性化推荐方向的研究,也拓展了社会影响理论和框架效应理论在市场营销领域的应用研究,并为企业实施个性化推荐策略提供了重要的实践启示。

Based on the social influence theory, this paper examines the impact of frameworks that highlight similarity between users and similarity between products on consumer click intention through three experiments, and analyzes the mediating effect of perceived product matching and the moderating role played by product types and recommendation quantity. The study shows that compared to frameworks that highlight similarity between products, frameworks that highlight similarity between users can generate higher perceived product matching among consumers, thereby enhancing their click intention. But this framing effect is moderated by product types: For hedonic products, frameworks that highlight similarity between users are often more effective; for practical products, frameworks that highlight similarity between products are more effective. Moreover, the framing effect of recommendation interpretation only occurs when the number of recommendations is one; when the number of recommendations is multiple, there is no significant difference in perceived product matching and click intention between the two recommendation interpretation frameworks. This paper not only advances the research progress of personalized recommendation, but also expands the application research of the social influence theory and the framework effect theory in the field of marketing, and provides important practical inspiration for enterprises to implement personalized recommendation strategies.

参考文献

1 陈梅梅, 刘利梅, 施驰玮, 等. 推荐规模对个性化推荐系统用户决策的影响研究[J]. 南开管理评论, 2020, 23(1): 180-188. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1008-3448.2020.01.017
2 陈明亮, 蔡日梅. 电子商务中产品推荐代理对消费者购买决策的影响[J]. 浙江大学学报(人文社会科学版), 2009, 39(5): 138-148. DOI:10.3785/j.issn.1008-942X.2009.02.131
7 刘楠, 李爱梅, 丁浩, 等. “多多益善”还是“过犹不及”?——选择超载与消费者决策行为研究[J]. 外国经济与管理, 2017, 39(9): 70-82. DOI:10.16538/j.cnki.fem.2017.09.006
9 孙鲁平, 张丽君, 汪平. 网上个性化推荐研究述评与展望[J]. 外国经济与管理, 2016, 38(6): 82-99. DOI:10.16538/j.cnki.fem.2016.06.006
13 Adomavicius G, Bockstedt J C, Curley S P, et al. Effects of online recommendations on consumers’ willingness to Pay[J]. Information Systems Research, 2018, 29(1): 84-102. DOI:10.1287/isre.2017.0703
14 Ariely D, Lynch Jr J G, Aparicio IV M. Learning by collaborative and individual-based recommendation agents[J]. Journal of Consumer Psychology, 2004, 14(1-2): 81-95. DOI:10.1207/s15327663jcp1401&2_10
15 Barasz K, Kim T, John L K. The role of (dis)similarity in (mis)predicting others’ preferences[J]. Journal of Marketing Research, 2016, 53(4): 597-607. DOI:10.1509/jmr.15.0226
16 Bollen D, Knijnenburg B P, Willemsen M C, et al. Understanding choice overload in recommender systems[A]. Proceedings of the fourth ACM conference on recommender systems[C]. Barcelona, Spain: ACM, 2010.
17 Botti S, McGill A L. The locus of choice: Personal causality and satisfaction with hedonic and utilitarian decisions[J]. Journal of Consumer Research, 2011, 37(6): 1065-1078. DOI:10.1086/656570
18 Brown J J, Reingen P H. Social ties and word-of-mouth referral behavior[J]. Journal of Consumer Research, 1987, 14(3): 350-362. DOI:10.1086/209118
19 Carter T J, Gilovich T. The relative relativity of material and experiential purchases[J]. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 2010, 98(1): 146-159. DOI:10.1037/a0017145
20 Chang K T T, Chen W, Tan B C Y. Advertising effectiveness in social networking sites: Social ties, expertise, and product type[J]. IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management, 2012, 59(4): 634-643. DOI:10.1109/TEM.2011.2177665
21 Chen L, Pu P. Experiments on user experiences with recommender interfaces[J]. Behaviour & Information Technology, 2014, 33(4): 372-394.
22 Deng H L, Wang W Q, Li S S, et al. Can positive online social cues always reduce user avoidance of sponsored search results?[J]. MIS Quarterly, 2022, 46(1): 35-70. DOI:10.25300/MISQ/2021/14962
23 Dhar R, Wertenbroch K. Consumer choice between hedonic and utilitarian goods[J]. Journal of Marketing Research, 2000, 37(1): 60-71. DOI:10.1509/jmkr.37.1.60.18718
24 Gai P J, Klesse A K. Making recommendations more effective through framings: Impacts of user- versus item-based framings on recommendation click-throughs[J]. Journal of Marketing, 2019, 83(6): 61-75. DOI:10.1177/0022242919873901
25 Ghoshal A, Kumar S, Mookerjee V. Impact of recommender system on competition between personalizing and non-personalizing firms[J]. Journal of Management Information Systems, 2015, 31(4): 243-277. DOI:10.1080/07421222.2014.1001276
26 Hayes A F. Introduction to mediation, moderation, and conditional process analysis: A regression-based Approach[M]. New York, NY: Guilford, 2013.
27 Hennig-Thurau T, Marchand A, Marx P. Can automated group recommender systems help consumers make better choices?[J]. Journal of Marketing, 2012, 76(5): 89-109. DOI:10.1509/jm.10.0537
28 Hirschman E C, Holbrook M B. Hedonic consumption: Emerging concepts, methods and propositions[J]. Journal of Marketing, 1982, 46(3): 92-101. DOI:10.1177/002224298204600314
29 Ho S Y, Lim K H. Nudging moods to induce unplanned purchases in imperfect mobile personalization contexts[J]. MIS Quarterly, 2018, 42(3): 757-778. DOI:10.25300/MISQ/2018/14083
30 Kelman H C. Compliance, identification, and internalization three processes of attitude change[J]. Journal of Conflict Resolution, 1958, 2(1): 51-60. DOI:10.1177/002200275800200106
31 Khan U, Dhar R. Price-framing effects on the purchase of hedonic and utilitarian bundles[J]. Journal of Marketing Research, 2010, 47(6): 1090-1099. DOI:10.1509/jmkr.47.6.1090
32 Knijnenburg B P, Willemsen M C, Gantner Z, et al. Explaining the user experience of recommender systems[J]. User Modeling and User-adapted Interaction, 2012, 22(4-5): 441-504. DOI:10.1007/s11257-011-9118-4
33 Lee E M, Park S Y, Rapert M I, et al. Does perceived consumer fit matter in corporate social responsibility issues?[J]. Journal of Business Research, 2012, 65(11): 1558-1564. DOI:10.1016/j.jbusres.2011.02.040
34 Levin I P, Gaeth G J. How consumers are affected by the framing of attribute information before and after consuming the product[J]. Journal of Consumer Research, 1988, 15(3): 374-378. DOI:10.1086/209174
35 Liao M Q, Sundar S S. When e-commerce personalization systems show and tell: Investigating the relative persuasive appeal of content-based versus collaborative filtering[J]. Journal of Advertising, 2022, 51(2): 256-267. DOI:10.1080/00913367.2021.1887013
36 Ma L Y, Krishnan R, Montgomery A L. Latent homophily or social influence? An empirical analysis of purchase within a social network[J]. Management Science, 2015, 61(2): 454-473. DOI:10.1287/mnsc.2014.1928
37 Meyners J, Barrot C, Becker J U, et al. The role of mere closeness: How geographic proximity affects social influence[J]. Journal of Marketing, 2017, 81(5): 49-66. DOI:10.1509/jm.16.0057
38 Mittelman M, Andrade E B, Chattopadhyay A, et al. The offer framing effect: Choosing single versus bundled offerings affects variety seeking[J]. Journal of Consumer Research, 2014, 41(4): 953-964. DOI:10.1086/678193
39 Moore S G. Attitude predictability and helpfulness in online reviews: The role of explained actions and reactions[J]. Journal of Consumer Research, 2015, 42(1): 30-44. DOI:10.1093/jcr/ucv003
40 Park C W, Jun S Y, MacInnis D J. Choosing what I want versus rejecting what I do not want: An application of decision framing to product option choice decisions[J]. Journal of Marketing Research, 2000, 37(2): 187-202. DOI:10.1509/jmkr.37.2.187.18731
41 Park E, Rishika R, Janakiraman R, et al. Social dollars in online communities: The effect of product, user, and network characteristics[J]. Journal of Marketing, 2018, 82(1): 93-114. DOI:10.1509/jm.16.0271
42 Rook D W, Fisher R J. Normative influences on impulsive buying behavior[J]. Journal of Consumer Research, 1995, 22(3): 305-313. DOI:10.1086/209452
43 Senecal S, Nantel J. The influence of online product recommendations on consumers’ online choices[J]. Journal of Retailing, 2004, 80(2): 159-169. DOI:10.1016/j.jretai.2004.04.001
44 Spiller S A, Belogolova L. On consumer beliefs about quality and taste[J]. Journal of Consumer Research, 2017, 43(6): 970-991.
45 Sun M, Zhang X Q, Zhu F. U-shaped conformity in online social networks[J]. Marketing Science, 2019, 38(3): 461-480. DOI:10.1287/mksc.2018.1133
46 Tversky A, Kahneman D. The framing of decisions and the psychology of choice[J]. Science, 1981, 211(4481): 453-458. DOI:10.1126/science.7455683
47 Wang W Q, Benbasat I. Recommendation agents for electronic commerce: Effects of explanation facilities on trusting beliefs[J]. Journal of Management Information Systems, 2007, 23(4): 217-246. DOI:10.2753/MIS0742-1222230410
48 Whitley S C, Trudel R, Kurt D. The influence of purchase motivation on perceived preference uniqueness and assortment size choice[J]. Journal of Consumer Research, 2018, 45(4): 710-724. DOI:10.1093/jcr/ucy031
49 Wood W. Attitude change: Persuasion and social influence[J]. Annual Review of Psychology, 2000, 51: 539-570. DOI:10.1146/annurev.psych.51.1.539
50 Xiao B, Benbasat I. E-commerce product recommendation agents: Use, characteristics, and impact[J]. MIS Quarterly, 2007, 31(1): 137-209. DOI:10.2307/25148784
51 Xu J J, Benbasat I, Cenfetelli R T. The relative effect of the convergence of product recommendations from various online sources[J]. Journal of Management Information Systems, 2020, 37(3): 788-819. DOI:10.1080/07421222.2020.1790192
52 Yan L, Keh H T, Chen J M. Assimilating and differentiating: The curvilinear effect of social class on green consumption[J]. Journal of Consumer Research, 2021, 47(6): 914-936. DOI:10.1093/jcr/ucaa041
53 Yaniv I, Choshen-Hillel S, Milyavsky M. Receiving advice on matters of taste: Similarity, majority influence, and taste discrimination[J]. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 2011, 115(1): 111-120. DOI:10.1016/j.obhdp.2010.11.006
54 Zhao K X, Stylianou A C, Zheng Y M. Sources and impacts of social influence from online anonymous user reviews[J]. Information & Management, 2018, 55(1): 16-30.