人工智能反馈:文献述评与研究展望

Artificial Intelligence Feedback: A Literature Review and Prospects

关健,李文朴,何国华,张新安

2025 第 47 卷 第 03 期 页码 83-100

DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20240622.301

PDF全文下载 HTML全文

摘要

绩效反馈是激励并促进个体进步最重要的方式之一。随着人工智能技术的进步,由AI提供的反馈在实践中得到日益广泛的应用,在质量上也开始逐步超越人类管理者所提供的绩效反馈,已经成为组织管理研究中的一个重要话题。然而,现有文献对AI反馈的研究分散在组织管理、教育和医疗等不同学科领域,这导致AI反馈相关研究在研究范式、理论视角和实证方法等方面具有较大差异,且现有文献对AI反馈带来的不同效应在理论机制方面尚未形成一致的认识。鉴于此,本文首先厘清了AI反馈的概念内涵和外延;然后,系统地归纳和总结了AI反馈产生影响的配置效应和披露效应机制,构建了AI反馈的研究框架;接下来,介绍和总结了现有AI反馈研究常用或具有深远启示意义的理论机制,并讨论了理论的使用方式;最后,在此基础上,提出了五个具有科学价值和现实意义的未来研究方向。

Performance feedback is one of the most critical ways to motivate and facilitate individual progress. With the advancement of artificial intelligence (AI) technology, feedback provided by AI is increasingly applied in practice, gradually surpassing the quality of performance feedback delivered by human managers. It has become a significant topic in organizational management research. However, existing literature on AI feedback is scattered across different disciplines such as organizational management, education, and healthcare. This dispersion has led to significant differences in research paradigms, theoretical perspectives, and empirical methods within the study of AI feedback. Furthermore, existing literature has not yet formed a unified understanding of the theoretical mechanisms behind the varying effects of AI feedback. In light of this, this paper first clarifies the concept of AI feedback. Next, it systematically summarizes and reviews the deployment effect and disclosure effect through which AI feedback exerts its influence, thereby constructing a research framework for AI feedback. Then, it introduces and summarizes the commonly used or profoundly insightful theoretical mechanisms in existing AI feedback research and discusses the ways these mechanisms are applied. Finally, it proposes five future research directions that hold both scientific value and practical significance.

参考文献

5 梁肖梅, 汪秀琼, 叶广宇, 等. 绩效反馈理论述评: 知识框架与研究展望[J]. 南开管理评论, 2023, 26(3): 197-212. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1008-3448.2023.03.019
14 Bandura A. Social cognitive theory: An agentic perspective[J]. Annual Review of Psychology, 2001, 52: 1-26. DOI:10.1146/annurev.psych.52.1.1
15 Bauer K, von Zahn M, Hinz O. Expl(AI)ned: The impact of explainable artificial intelligence on users’ information processing[J]. Information Systems Research, 2023, 34(4): 1582-1602. DOI:10.1287/isre.2023.1199
16 Bigman Y E, Gray K. People are averse to machines making moral decisions[J]. Cognition, 2018, 181: 21-34. DOI:10.1016/j.cognition.2018.08.003
17 Cadario R, Longoni C, Morewedge C K. Understanding, explaining, and utilizing medical artificial intelligence[J]. Nature Human Behaviour, 2021, 5(12): 1636-1642. DOI:10.1038/s41562-021-01146-0
18 Castelo N, Ward A F. Conservatism predicts aversion to consequential artificial intelligence[J]. PLoS One, 2021, 16(12): e0261467. DOI:10.1371/journal.pone.0261467
19 Dello Russo S, Mirfakhar A S, Miraglia M. What is the narrative for practice? A review of recommendations on feedback and a guide to writing impactful practical implications[J]. Applied Psychology, 2023, 72(4): 1624-1652. DOI:10.1111/apps.12450
20 Dietvorst B J, Simmons J P, Massey C. Algorithm aversion: People erroneously avoid algorithms after seeing them err[J]. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 2015, 144(1): 114-126. DOI:10.1037/xge0000033
21 Dietvorst B J, Simmons J P, Massey C. Overcoming algorithm aversion: People will use imperfect algorithms if they can (even slightly) modify them[J]. Management Science, 2018, 64(3): 1155-1170. DOI:10.1287/mnsc.2016.2643
22 Gray H M, Gray K, Wegner D M. Dimensions of mind perception[J]. Science, 2007, 315(5812): 619-619. DOI:10.1126/science.1134475
23 Gray K, Wegner D M. Feeling robots and human zombies: Mind perception and the uncanny valley[J]. Cognition, 2012, 125(1): 125-130. DOI:10.1016/j.cognition.2012.06.007
24 Ilgen D R, Fisher C D, Taylor M S. Consequences of individual feedback on behavior in organizations[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology, 1979, 64(4): 349-371. DOI:10.1037/0021-9010.64.4.349
25 Jia N, Luo X M, Fang Z, et al. When and how artificial intelligence augments employee creativity[J]. Academy of Management Journal, 2024, 67(1): 5-32. DOI:10.5465/amj.2022.0426
26 Kellogg K C, Valentine M A, Christin A. Algorithms at work: The new contested terrain of control[J]. Academy of Management Annals, 2020, 14(1): 366-410. DOI:10.5465/annals.2018.0174
27 Lechermeier J, Fassnacht M. How do performance feedback characteristics influence recipients’ reactions? A state-of-the-art review on feedback source, timing, and valence effects[J]. Management Review Quarterly, 2018, 68(2): 145-193. DOI:10.1007/s11301-018-0136-8
28 Lindebaum D, Ashraf M. The ghost in the machine, or the ghost in organizational theory? A complementary view on the use of machine learning[J]. Academy of Management Review, 2024, 49(2): 445-448. DOI:10.5465/amr.2021.0036
29 Logg J M, Minson J A, Moore D A. Algorithm appreciation: People prefer algorithmic to human judgment[J]. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 2019, 151: 90-103. DOI:10.1016/j.obhdp.2018.12.005
30 London M, Smither J W. Feedback orientation, feedback culture, and the longitudinal performance management process[J]. Human Resource Management Review, 2002, 12(1): 81-100.
31 Luo X M, Qin M S, Fang Z, et al. Artificial intelligence coaches for sales agents: Caveats and solutions[J]. Journal of Marketing, 2021, 85(2): 14-32. DOI:10.1177/0022242920956676
32 Luo X M, Tong S L, Fang Z, et al. Frontiers: Machines vs. humans: The impact of artificial intelligence chatbot disclosure on customer purchases[J]. Marketing Science, 2019, 38(6): 937-947.
33 Marafie Z, Lin K J, Wang D B, et al. AutoCoach: An intelligent driver behavior feedback agent with personality-based driver models[J]. Electronics, 2021, 10(11): 1361. DOI:10.3390/electronics10111361
34 Nussberger A M, Luo L, Celis L E, et al. Public attitudes value interpretability but prioritize accuracy in artificial intelligence[J]. Nature Communications, 2022, 13(1): 5821. DOI:10.1038/s41467-022-33417-3
35 Ötting S K, Masjutin L, Steil J J, et al. Let’s work together: A meta-analysis on robot design features that enable successful human–robot interaction at work[J]. Human Factors, 2022, 64(6): 1027-1050. DOI:10.1177/0018720820966433
36 Parent-Rocheleau X, Parker S K. Algorithms as work designers: How algorithmic management influences the design of jobs[J]. Human Resource Management Review, 2022, 32(3): 100838. DOI:10.1016/j.hrmr.2021.100838
37 Pereira V, Hadjielias E, Christofi M, et al. A systematic literature review on the impact of artificial intelligence on workplace outcomes: A multi-process perspective[J]. Human Resource Management Review, 2023, 33(1): 100857. DOI:10.1016/j.hrmr.2021.100857
38 Roesler E, Manzey D, Onnasch L. A meta-analysis on the effectiveness of anthropomorphism in human-robot interaction[J]. Science Robotics, 2021, 6(58): eabj5425. DOI:10.1126/scirobotics.abj5425
39 Sharma A, Lin I W, Miner A S, et al. Human–AI collaboration enables more empathic conversations in text-based peer-to-peer mental health support[J]. Nature Machine Intelligence, 2023, 5(1): 46-57. DOI:10.1038/s42256-022-00593-2
40 Tong S L, Jia N, Luo X M, et al. The Janus face of artificial intelligence feedback: Deployment versus disclosure effects on employee performance[J]. Strategic Management Journal, 2021, 42(9): 1600-1631. DOI:10.1002/smj.3322
41 Vrontis D, Christofi M, Pereira V, et al. Artificial intelligence, robotics, advanced technologies and human resource management: A systematic review[J]. The International Journal of Human Resource Management, 2022, 33(6): 1237-1266. DOI:10.1080/09585192.2020.1871398
42 Yam K C, Bigman Y E, Tang P M, et al. Robots at work: People prefer—and forgive—service robots with perceived feelings[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology, 2021, 106(10): 1557-1572. DOI:10.1037/apl0000834
43 Yam K C, Goh E Y, Fehr R, et al. When your boss is a robot: Workers are more spiteful to robot supervisors that seem more human[J]. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 2022, 102: 104360. DOI:10.1016/j.jesp.2022.104360
44 Yam K C, Tan T, Jackson J C, et al. Cultural differences in people’s reactions and applications of robots, algorithms, and artificial intelligence[J]. Management and Organization Review, 2023, 19(5): 859-875. DOI:10.1017/mor.2023.21