悖论式领导如何让员工两全其美?——心理安全感和工作繁荣感的多重中介作用
How Does Paradoxical Leadership Enhance Individual Ambidexterity? The Composite Multiple Mediating Role of Psychological Safety and Thriving at Work
DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.2018.03.008
[1]王朝晖.悖论式领导如何让员工两全其美?——心理安全感和工作繁荣感的多重中介作用[J/OL].外国经济与管理,2018,40(03):107-120[2026-11-20].https://doi.org/10.16538/j.cnki.fem.2018.03.008.
摘要
员工在工作场所中面临效率和创新的冲突,如何让员工采取双元行为,实现两全其美是双元型组织构建中亟待深入研究的议题。悖论式领导是一种兼具矛盾思维和整合思维的新型领导风格,已成为领导力研究领域的最新议题之一,现有文献较少探讨该领导模式在促进员工双元行为中的作用。以一线服务员工作为调查对象,分析了悖论式领导是否以及如何促进员工双元行为。通过问卷调查法得到316名一线员工的有效数据,采用结构方程模型进行假设检验。研究结果表明:悖论式领导能够正向促进员工的双元行为,心理安全感和工作繁荣感在悖论式领导和员工双元行为的关系中起同步和连续中介作用。为促进员工双元行为,管理者应从兼顾绩效和支持两种领导行为,营造良好的心理安全氛围,提升员工的工作繁荣感等方面入手。
The increasingly dynamic global business environment has brought tension and conflicts into the organizational life of employees. At the individual level, ambidexterity is the individual ability to pursue both exploitation and exploration and combine and gain synergies between them. Although researchers recognize the importance of resolving contradictory behaviors to organizational ambidexterity, most studies focus on organizational level and top management to find resolutions of tension and conflicts. At present, the research on individual ambidexterity mainly focuses on the following three aspects: the first is to explore the individual characteristics that are conducive to the integration of conflicting activities; the second is from a perspective of organizational context; the third argues that informal social networks of employees promote their ambidextrous behaviors. However, few studies have focused on the role of leadership in promoting the ambidextrous behavior of front-line employees. In the research practice, although some scholars have found that paradoxical leadership behavior can promote employees’ performance, but neglect the discussion of individual ambidextrous behavior at the micro-level. Researchers fail to answer the question of whether paradoxical leadership can promote the ambidextrous behaviors of employees. To address these concerns, this paper intends to answer the above questions from two perspectives. First of all, recent studies by foreign scholars show that paradoxical leadership includes not only performance dimension but also supportive dimension. Performance dimension means that supervisors set higher performance goals for subordinates to tap potential of subordinates, while supportive dimension refers to supervisors’ trust, guidance and assistance to subordinates. This paper examines the impact of the complementarity of performance and support on employee ambidexterity. Secondly, psychological security is an important psychological factor that affects employees’ ambidextrous behaviors based on the intrinsic motivation theory. Therefore, this paper chooses psychological security as an intermediate variable. In a recent study, some researchers point out that thriving at work impacts employees’ ambidextrous behaviors. Therefore, this paper chooses thriving at work as the mediating variable in addition to the psychological mechanism and puts forward the logic path, namely paradoxical leadership-thriving at work-employee ambidextrous behavior. Based on the data collected from a survey of 316 frontline employees, this paper uses structural equation to analyze the data. It arrives at the main findings as follows: firstly, paradoxical leadership has a significant positive impact on the ambidextrous behavior of front-line employees; secondly, the influence of paradoxical leadership on employee ambidexterity is completely through psychological security and thriving at work; thirdly, there is no significant difference in the specific intermediary role of psychological security and thriving at work, however, the individual mediation effect of thriving at work is significantly greater than chain mediation effect resulting from its combination with psychological safety. Our study contributes to the literature in two significant ways. Firstly, the paradoxical leadership is divided into two dimensions: performance and support. By analyzing the role of complementarity in promoting ambidextrous activities of employees, this paper expands the research level of traditional relationship of leadership-organization ambidexterity. It provides a new perspective for revealing the microscopic foundation of organizational ambidexterity. Secondly, through the introduction of two intermediary variables, psychological safety and thriving at work, proposes and tests a dual psychological pathway through which paradoxical leadership relates to ambidextrous behavior. As prior research has examined a motivation-based explanation, our focus on the thriving framework extends it to individual ambidexterity research and provides an opportunity to test the utility of these complementarity perspectives in demonstrating the sense of agency that provides the psychological underpinning of ambidexterity behavior.
关键词: 悖论式领导,双元行为,心理安全感,工作繁荣感