拍卖市场设计的理论发展与新拍卖形式的创新——2020年度诺贝尔经济学奖得主主要经济理论贡献述评
Theoretical Development of Auction Market Design and Innovations of New Auction Formats — A Review of Main Contributions by 2020 Nobel Economics Laureates
DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20201101.101
[1]李宝良,郭其友.拍卖市场设计的理论发展与新拍卖形式的创新——2020年度诺贝尔经济学奖得主主要经济理论贡献述评[J/OL].外国经济与管理,2020,42(11):140-152[2026-11-20].https://doi.org/10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20201101.101.
摘要
罗伯特•威尔逊和保罗•米尔格罗姆因对“拍卖理论的改进和新拍卖形式的发明”所做的突出贡献荣膺2020年度诺贝尔经济学奖。本文重点评述了他们在拓展拍卖理论使其更符合现实更加实用,以及创造性地设计新拍卖形式以应对多件物品拍卖的挑战方面的成就,并总结了他们在拍卖市场设计过程中重要的经验教训。首先,他们对拍卖理论的改进和新拍卖形式的发明,是围绕如何充分利用分散于私人的信息以实现资源的有效配置这一核心问题展开的,这实际上也是经济政策制定和经济体制改革的主要问题之一;其次,他们为现代经济学研究树立了经典的范例,即研究问题来源于实践又反馈于实践,借助博弈论的分析工具又推动了博弈论的发展,既充分体现了理论与实践的相互促进,又展现了现代经济学的典型演进过程;最后,他们对拍卖市场设计的研究,充分展示了机制设计问题中细节的重要性。总之,他们在拍卖市场设计上的贡献,对我国的经济理论研究以及拍卖市场设计问题,乃至更一般的机制设计问题都有一定的参考价值和借鉴意义。
Robert Wilson and Paul Milgrom won the Sveriges Riksbanks Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel 2020 for “improvements to auction theory and inventions of new auction formats”. This paper focuses on how they expand the auction theory to make it more realistic and practical, and how to creatively design new auction formats to meet the challenges posed by the auction of multiple objects, as well as the experience and lessons in the process of auction market design and reference value of their contributions. To sum up, there are three aspects that merit attention:
First of all, auction is a way to “utilize the knowledge scattered among all the people (Hayek, 1945)”. Their improvements to auction theory and the invention of new auction formats are all centered on the core problem of how to make full use of the information scattered in private to realize the efficient allocation of resources. From this point of view, auction studies how private information can be aggregated and revealed under different auction formats, how efficient the equilibrium results can achieve, and how to improve it through mechanism design. These problems are also one of the main problems of economic policy and economic system reform. Therefore, their contributions not only have direct reference value for auction market design in China, but also have important reference value for more general problems in economic policy-making and economic system reform.
Secondly, their contributions to auction research set up a classic example for modern economics research. Modern economics provide economists with a lot of theoretical benchmarks to examine the real world. By comparing the differences between the real world and the benchmark, economists find out which assumptions of the benchmark model are inconsistent with the reality, and modify them, so as to expand and enrich the content of economic theory. Their development of auction theory is centered on the modification of the premise of income equivalence theorem, which is the embodiment of this typical process of economic research. In addition, many of their problems in the research of auction market design come from auction practice and are committed to solving practical problems; auction research opens up a new field for game theory, which in turn consolidates the theoretical basis of game theory. This embodies the typical evolution process of mutual promotion between theory and practice in the process of modern economic research.
Last but not least, their research on auction market design shows the importance of details in auction market design. In fact, the revenue equivalence theorem which is the benchmark of auction theory is arrived at under strict assumptions. The change of the assumptions will change the strategic equivalence of various mainstream standard auction formats. In real life, we need to choose the appropriate auction format according to the specific conditions. The auction market design is more easily affected by the details in the auction of multiple objects. Therefore, specific market auction design depends on the specific situation. Auction market design should consider the specific environment of specific problems. Careful consideration of various possible problems and careful design of various details are the most important things to consider in the process of solving economic problems with reference to auction market design.
关键词: 罗伯特•威尔逊,保罗•米尔格罗姆,拍卖理论,拍卖市场设计,赢家的诅咒