消费者行为研究中的田野实验:概念、操作介绍与开展建议

Field Experiment in Consumer Behavior Research: Definitions, Manipulation Methods, and Suggestions

柳武妹,黄河清,叶富荣

2020 第 42 卷 第 03 期 页码 35-56

DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20200204.301

PDF全文下载 HTML全文

摘要

田野实验是一种与实验室实验相对应的实验研究方法。该类实验尽管相比实验室实验内部效度较低(噪音控制弱),但因为情境真实和外部效度高而近几年来受到学术界的持续关注。自2017年JMR、JCR和JM相继出版田野实验的专刊以来(Gneezy,2017;Meyer,2017;Morales等,2017),经笔者统计,2018年和2019年发表在JCR、JMR、JM上接近1/4的消费者行为研究都宣称自己使用了田野实验。然而,仔细阅读这些田野实验的文章后笔者发现,有些关于田野实验的问题并没有被彻底回答清楚,包括究竟什么是田野实验?田野实验有哪些判别标准?由于对田野实验的内涵界定存在不一致,一些文章宣称自己使用了田野实验,但实际上却不是严格意义上的田野实验。更重要的,我国营销学术界对田野实验本身的关注度和重视度还非常不足,发表的田野实验文章数量还非常有限。本文在JCR、JMR、JM、JCP这四份消费者行为顶级和权威期刊近5年(2014年8月—2019年11月)刊发的108篇使用了至少一项田野实验的文献的基础之上,将重点厘清田野实验的概念,并总结归纳前人在田野实验中为了增强情境真实性和外部效度做了什么,最后提出田野实验的开展建议。笔者希望,这篇文章能为国内营销学者和对田野实验感兴趣的其他领域学者日后开展田野实验提供操作层面的参考。

Field experiment is an experimental research method corresponding to lab experiment. It has received continuous attention in recent years because of its high realism and external validity. However, past research did not reach consensus on the definition of field experiment, which puzzled the readers to understand the meaning of field experiment and to carry out a real field experiment. This research gap motivated the current paper.

First, we collect previous scholars’ definitions of field experiment. Based on these past definitions, we put forward a relatively clear definition of and a criterion for field experiment. In the same part, we further distinguish the definitions of field experiment between those of some other related terms such as lab experiment, quasi experiment, field study and realistic experiment in-the-field. This part is followed by introducing two subcategories of field experiment, namely, independent field experiment and collaborative field experiment, and discussing the advantages and disadvantages of field experiment. We argue that although field experiment has disadvantages in uncovering the underlying mechanism, controlling noise, analyzing data, etc, it can improve the realism and external validity of a scholarly work. Importantly, it can increase the publication likelihood of the scholarly work to some extent.

Next, we analyze a total of 108 articles which include at least one field experiment in four leading marketing journals, i.e. JCR, JMR, JM and JCP. The time span of these articles ranges from August 2014 to November 2019. Based on the summary of these 108 field experiment articles, we elaborate on the general methods of IV manipulation and DV observation. Specifically, we divide IVs of these 108 articles into several categories: individual characteristics, product stimuli, environmental situations, and other categories, etc. These IVs are mainly manipulated through natural display, actual recording and language highlighting. Regarding DVs, we find that the DVs of these 108 articles are generally observed by adopting the “pay-what-you-want” paradigm, recording participants’ actual choices, recording participants’ food intake quantity and product purchase quantity, counting website visits and clicks, and recording relevant behaviors such as information sharing and information collection, etc.

In the following part, we provide a few suggestions on how to conduct two different types of field experiment (independent field experiment and collaborative field experiment). For independent field experiment, researchers can consider designing experiment flexibly, placing extra emphasis on increasing the authenticity of experiment, and avoiding participants’ awareness. While for collaborative field experiment, researchers can consider using a large sample size, understanding the needs of non-academic partners, and bringing practical benefits to non-academic partners, etc. Sometimes researchers also need to meet the anonymity requirements of non-academic partners.

In the final part, we discuss when researchers should carry out field experiment and when they should not. We argue that field experiment is not necessary, perfect and omnipotent, so researchers should choose appropriate research methods according to their own research objectives, research characteristics and resource constraints. We hope this paper could provide reference value for domestic researchers who plan to carry out field experiment in the future.

参考文献

2 冯小亮, 任巍. 社会影响易感性和虚拟产品采用: 用户等级和产品类型的调节作用[J]. 南开管理评论,2018, (5): 73-82. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1008-3448.2018.05.009
3 郭秀艳. 实验心理学[M]. 北京: 人民教育出版社, 2004.
5 贾旭东, 谭新辉. 经典扎根理论及其精神对中国管理研究的现实价值[J]. 管理学报,2010, (5): 656-665. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1672-884X.2010.05.004
7 尼尔·J 萨尔金德(著), 童定(译). 心理学研究方法/心理学译丛[M]. 第9版. 北京: 中国人民大学出版社, 2019.
9 小卡尔·麦克丹尼尔, 罗杰·盖茨(著), 李桂华(译). 当代市场调研[M].第10版. 北京: 机械工业出版社, 2019.
10 Allen A M, Eilert M, Peloza J. How deviations from performance norms impact charitable donations[J]. Journal of Marketing Research,2018, 55(2): 277-290. DOI:10.1509/jmr.15.0509
11 Argo J J, Dahl D W, Morales A C. Consumer contamination: How consumers react to products touched by others[J]. Journal of Marketing,2006, 70(2): 81-94. DOI:10.1509/jmkg.70.2.081
12 Argo J J, Dahl D W, Morales A C. Positive consumer contagion: Responses to attractive others in a retail context[J]. Journal of Marketing Research,2008, 45(6): 690-701. DOI:10.1509/jmkr.45.6.690
13 Atasoy O, Morewedge C K. Digital goods are valued less than physical goods[J]. Journal of Consumer Research,2018, 44(6): 1343-1357. DOI:10.1093/jcr/ucx102
15 Baca-Motes K, Brown A, Gneezy A, et al. Commitment and behavior change: Evidence from the field[J]. Journal of Consumer Research,2013, 39(5): 1070-1084. DOI:10.1086/667226
16 Barasch A, Zauberman G, Diehl K. How the intention to share can undermine enjoyment: Photo-taking goals and evaluation of experiences[J]. Journal of Consumer Research,2018, 44(6): 1220-1237. DOI:10.1093/jcr/ucx112
17 Biswas D, Szocs C. The smell of healthy choices: Cross-modal sensory compensation effects of ambient scent on food purchases[J]. Journal of Marketing Research,2019, 56(1): 123-141. DOI:10.1177/0022243718820585
18 Castro I A, Morales A C, Nowlis S M. The influence of disorganized shelf displays and limited product quantity on consumer purchase[J]. Journal of Marketing,2013, 77(4): 118-133. DOI:10.1509/jm.11.0495
19 Chang H H, Hung I W. Mirror, mirror on the retail wall: Self-focused attention promotes reliance on feelings in consumer decisions[J]. Journal of Marketing Research,2018, 55(4): 586-599. DOI:10.1509/jmr.15.0080
21 Fajardo T M, Townsend C, Bolander W. Toward an optimal donation solicitation: Evidence from the field of the differential influence of donor-related and organization-related information on donation choice and amount[J]. Journal of Marketing,2018, 82(2): 142-152. DOI:10.1509/jm.15.0511
22 Fiske S T. How to publish rigorous experiments in the 21st century[J]. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology,2016, 66: 145-147. DOI:10.1016/j.jesp.2016.01.006
23 Gneezy A. Field experimentation in marketing research[J]. Journal of Marketing Research,2017, 54(1): 140-143. DOI:10.1509/jmr.16.0225
24 Grewal L, Hmurovic J, Lamberton C, et al. The self-perception connection: Why consumers devalue unattractive produce[J]. Journal of Marketing,2019, 83(1): 89-107. DOI:10.1177/0022242918816319
26 Guha A, Biswas A, Grewal D, et al. An empirical analysis of the joint effects of shoppers’ goals and attribute display on shoppers’ evaluations[J]. Journal of Marketing,2018, 82(3): 142-156. DOI:10.1509/jm.16.0247
27 Hock S J, Bagchi R. The impact of crowding on calorie consumption[J]. Journal of Consumer Research,2018, 44(5): 1123-1140. DOI:10.1093/jcr/ucx088
29 Huang X, Zhang M, Hui M K, et al. Warmth and conformity: The effects of ambient temperature on product preferences and financial decisions[J]. Journal of Consumer Psychology,2014, 24(2): 241-250. DOI:10.1016/j.jcps.2013.09.009
30 Jami A. Having control over and above situations: The influence of elevated viewpoints on risk taking[J]. Journal of Marketing Research,2019, 56(2): 230-244. DOI:10.1177/0022243718813544
31 Kim T, Barasz K, John L K. Why am I seeing this ad? The effect of ad transparency on ad effectiveness[J]. Journal of Consumer Research,2019a, 45(5): 906-932. DOI:10.1093/jcr/ucy039
32 Kim J C, Wadhwa M, Chattopadhyay A. When busy is less indulging: Impact of busy mindset on self-control behaviors[J]. Journal of Consumer Research,2019b, 45(5): 933-952. DOI:10.1093/jcr/ucy069
33 Knoeferle K M, Paus V C, Vossen A. An upbeat crowd: Fast in-store music alleviates negative effects of high social density on customers’ spending[J]. Journal of Retailing,2017, 93(4): 541-549. DOI:10.1016/j.jretai.2017.06.004
34 Lalwani A K, Wang J J. How do consumers’ cultural backgrounds and values influence their coupon proneness? A multimethod investigation[J]. Journal of Consumer Research,2019, 45(5): 1037-1050. DOI:10.1093/jcr/ucy033
35 Laporte S, Briers B. Similarity as a double-edged sword: The positive and negative effects of showcasing similar previous winners on perceived likelihood of winning in sweepstakes[J]. Journal of Consumer Research,2019, 45(6): 1331-1349. DOI:10.1093/jcr/ucy041
36 Li X S, Chan K W, Kim S. Service with emoticons: How customers interpret employee use of emoticons in online service encounters[J]. Journal of Consumer Research,2019, 45(5): 973-987. DOI:10.1093/jcr/ucy016
37 Lowe M L, Loveland K E, Krishna A. Quiet disquiet: Anxiety and risk avoidance due to nonconscious auditory priming[J]. Journal of Consumer Research,2019, 46(1): 159-179. DOI:10.1093/jcr/ucy068
38 McGrath J E. Dilemmatics: The study of research choices and dilemmas[J]. American Behavioral Scientist,1981, 25(2): 179-210. DOI:10.1177/000276428102500205
39 Meyer R. Introduction to the journal of marketing research special section on field experiments[J]. Journal of Marketing Research,2017, 54(1): 138-139. DOI:10.1509/jmr.54.150
40 Morales A C, Amir O, Lee L. Keeping it real in experimental research—Understanding when, where, and how to enhance realism and measure consumer behavior[J]. Journal of Consumer Research,2017, 44(2): 465-476. DOI:10.1093/jcr/ucx048
41 Noseworthy T J, Trudel R. Looks interesting, but what does it do? Evaluation of incongruent product form depends on positioning[J]. Journal of Marketing Research,2011, 48(6): 1008-1019. DOI:10.1509/jmr.10.0384
42 Otterbring T, Ringler C, Sirianni N J, et al. The abercrombie & fitch effect: The impact of physical dominance on male customers’ status-signaling consumption[J]. Journal of Marketing Research,2018, 55(1): 69-79. DOI:10.1509/jmr.15.0247
43 Paharia N, Swaminathan V. Who is wary of user design? The role of power-distance beliefs in preference for user-designed products[J]. Journal of Marketing,2019, 83(3): 91-107. DOI:10.1177/0022242919830412
44 Puzakova M, Kwak H. Should anthropomorphized brands engage customers? The impact of social crowding on brand preferences[J]. Journal of Marketing,2017, 81(6): 99-115. DOI:10.1509/jm.16.0211
45 Romero M, Craig A W, Kumar A. Mapping time: How the spatial representation of time influences intertemporal choices[J]. Journal of Marketing Research,2019, 56(4): 620-636. DOI:10.1177/0022243719827967
46 Sevilla J, Isaac M S, Bagchi R. Format neglect: How the use of numerical versus percentage rank claims influences consumer judgments[J]. Journal of Marketing,2018, 82(6): 150-164. DOI:10.1177/0022242918805455
47 Shen L X, Hsee C K, Talloen J H. The fun and function of uncertainty: Uncertain incentives reinforce repetition decisions[J]. Journal of Consumer Research,2019, 46(1): 69-81. DOI:10.1093/jcr/ucy062
48 Simester D. Field experiments in marketing[A]. Banerjee A V, Duflo E. Handbook of field experiments[C]. North Holland: Elsevier, 2017: 465-497.
49 Simpson B, White K, Laran J. When public recognition for charitable giving backfires: The role of independent self-construal[J]. Journal of Consumer Research,2018, 44(6): 1257-1273. DOI:10.1093/jcr/ucx101
50 VanEpps E M, Downs J S, Loewenstein G. Advance ordering for healthier eating? Field experiments on the relationship between the meal order-consumption time delay and meal content[J]. Journal of Marketing Research,2016, 53(3): 369-380. DOI:10.1509/jmr.14.0234
51 Wadhwa M, Kim J C, Chattopadhyay A, et al. Unexpected-framing effect: Impact of framing a product benefit as unexpected on product desire[J]. Journal of Consumer Research,2019, 46(2): 223-245. DOI:10.1093/jcr/ucz008
52 Wang H S, Noble C H, Dahl D W, et al. Successfully communicating a cocreated innovation[J]. Journal of Marketing,2019, 83(4): 38-57. DOI:10.1177/0022242919841039
53 Wang J, Hong J W, Zhou R R. How long did I wait? The effect of construal levels on consumers’ wait duration judgments[J]. Journal of Consumer Research,2018, 45(1): 169-184. DOI:10.1093/jcr/ucx117
54 Winterich K P, Nenkov G Y, Gonzales G E. Knowing what it makes: How product transformation salience increases recycling[J]. Journal of Marketing,2019, 83(4): 21-37. DOI:10.1177/0022242919842167
55 Yang Z Y, Sun S J, Lalwani A K, et al. How does consumers’ local or global identity influence price-perceived quality associations? The role of perceived quality variance[J]. Journal of Marketing,2019, 83(3): 145-162. DOI:10.1177/0022242918825269