为了全局“随机应变”:战略性即兴行为与竞争优势形成机制
Play to the Score for the Bigger Picture: Strategic Improvisation and Formation Mechanism of Competitive Advantage
DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.2018.03.002
[1]于思远,张阳,唐震,陶颜.为了全局“随机应变”:战略性即兴行为与竞争优势形成机制[J/OL].外国经济与管理,2018,40(03):20-33[2026-11-20].https://doi.org/10.16538/j.cnki.fem.2018.03.002.
摘要
企业的战略性即兴行为,即企业在面临由环境变化引起的非预期情况时,自发地利用现有资源,协同相关主体所采取的计划与实施同步发生的、创造性的应对行为。本文通过对两家大型企业的纵向对比案例研究,试图打开企业所采取的战略性即兴行为与其竞争优势之间的“黑箱”。研究发现:首先,企业在发展的不同阶段均会自发采取即时的、含有创造性意图的战略性即兴行为,并且可将其分为应激防御型、主动出击型两类。其次,企业所采取的战略性即兴行为会产生新的行动模式、机制、设施和新的解释框架。最后,战略性即兴行为形成的组织记忆促使企业降低生产运营成本,为顾客创造更多价值,为企业带来竞争优势。其中,战略性即兴行为所产生的新的行动模式、机制、设施倾向于演化成显性的、陈述性的企业记忆,而新的解释框架则会演化成隐性的、过程性的企业记忆。本文的结论可以丰富现有的战略性即兴研究,对于弥补资源基础观在企业能力与竞争优势之间作用机制的逻辑断层有一定的理论价值。
Along with the dynamic changes in technological and institutional environment, the external environment faced by enterprises is complex and unpredictable. Due to this fact, traditional plan-execute strategy cannot be unfolded smoothly. Hence enterprises adopt strategic improvisation to resist the risk caused by environmental uncertainty, improve sensing capability of environment changes, and enhance the capability of planning and executing strategy. Not only that, but strategic improvisation can fill in the gap in enterprise basic strategy and also becomes the core. Therefore, strategic improvisation is of great significance to managers. Strategic improvisation can be understood as unhindered actions employed by an organization spontaneously and intuitively when encountering an unexpected interruption or change of activity under time pressure. When improvising strategically, an organization needs bricolage, coordinates relevant subjects, and plans and executes at the same time. Since strategic improvisation plays a crucial role in management, then whether it can bring competitive advantage to enterprises with latecomer disadvantage is worth further study.
Based on the vertical comparison of big firms, this exploratory multi-case study tends to open the black box between strategic improvisation and competitive advantage of organizations by identifying strategic improvisation employed by firms at different development stages, untangling the evolutionary process and analyzing the mechanism between strategic improvisation and competitive advantage.
It comes to the following findings: firstly, enterprises perform in-time and novel strategic improvisation spontaneously at all stages. Strategic improvisation, based on different types of unpredicted events and organizational responses, can be categorized into two groups, namely improvisation as a defensive response to urgent and unexpected events in turbulent environment, and improvisation as active offensives. Secondly, outcomes from strategic improvisation are new behavioral productions, artificial productions and interpretive productions, which can affect companies at the strategic level. Thirdly, outcomes from strategic improvisation can evolve into organizational memory. Organizational memory can facilitate enterprises to reduce costs and create more value for customers; therefore, it becomes the source of endogenic competitive advantage. To be specific, new behavioral and artificial productions that come from strategic improvisation evolve into explicit declarative organizational memory, and new interpretive productions evolve into tacit procedural organizational memory.
This paper makes main contributions as follows: firstly, this paper tends to bridge the gap in the traditional RBV model with the attempt to add the concept of enterprises’ behaviors between the existing model of " capability-competitive advantage”; secondly, the conceptual model (" strategic improvisation”-" organizational memory”-" competitive advantage”) proposed in this paper argues that strategic improvisation is the root of enterprises’ competitive advantage, and hence enriches the existing research in this field; thirdly, this paper deepens the understanding of the mechanism between organizational memory and competitive advantage by arguing that although different levels of improvisation produce some forms of results, only organizational memory formed by the evolution of strategic improvisation is the source of organizational competitive advantage.
关键词: 组织即兴,战略管理,竞争优势