环境事项关注与审计费用——来自绿色审计的经验证据
Attention to Environmental Issues and Audit Fees: Empirical Evidence from Green Auditing
DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20250409.202
[1]伍翕婷,游家兴.环境事项关注与审计费用——来自绿色审计的经验证据[J/OL].外国经济与管理,2025,47(10):3-20[2026-11-20].https://doi.org/10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20250409.202.
摘要
《中国注册会计师审计准则第1631号——财务报表审计中对环境事项的考虑》积极推动“绿色审计”,旨在规范审计师在财务报表审计中考虑企业的环境事项。在此背景下,本文以2004—2023年中国A股上市公司为研究样本,借助上述审计准则的实施,实证检验环境事项关注对企业审计费用的影响。研究结果表明,相较于非国家重点监控企业,该准则的实施会显著增加国家重点监控企业的审计费用,其背后的关键原因是审计师为了考量企业的环境事项对审计的影响,需要承担更高的风险和付出更多的努力。异质性分析表明,当国家重点监控企业的绿色创新水平越低或地区环境执法力度越强时,上述影响越显著。进一步研究表明,该准则的实施虽然增加了国家重点监控企业的审计成本,但能够显著提升其审计质量,具有正向的外部效应。此外,本文还发现当上市企业下属的国家重点监控子公司数量越多,或者上市企业属于废气、废水类别的国家重点监控企业时,绿色审计带来的审计费用的增量效应更加显著。本文不仅有助于学术界全面理解与绿色相关的审计准则的实施效果,而且在全社会日益关注环境议题的背景下,强调了将环境事项纳入企业审计范畴的重要性,为政策制定者和企业管理层提供了有益参考。
The implementation of environmental auditing standards has changed auditors’ external practice environment, requiring auditors to include enterprises’ environmental issues into the scope of financial statement auditing. Taking China’s A-share listed enterprises from 2004 to 2023 as the research sample, this paper empirically tests the impact of attention to environmental issues on audit fees. The results indicate that environmental auditing standards significantly increase the audit fees of national key monitored enterprises, and its underlying reason is that auditors need to bear higher risks and make more efforts to consider the impact of environmental issues on auditing. Heterogeneity analysis shows that the lower the green innovation level of national key monitored enterprises or the stronger the regional environmental law enforcement, the more significant the above impact. Further research shows that although the implementation of the standards increases the audit costs of national key monitored enterprises, it significantly improves the quality of auditing. In addition, the incremental effect of audit fees brought by green auditing is more significant when the number of national key monitored subsidiaries under listed companies is larger, or when listed companies belong to national key monitored enterprises in the categories of waste gas and wastewater. This paper not only helps the academic community to comprehensively understand the implementation effect of green-related auditing standards, but also emphasizes the importance of incorporating environmental issues into the scope of auditing, providing useful references for policymakers and corporate management.
关键词: 绿色审计,环境审计准则,环境事项关注,审计费用,审计努力