创业活动有效性:一项关于创业者的Meta分析检验
Entrepreneurship Effectiveness: A Meta-Analysis on Entrepreneurs
DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.2018.06.003
[1]吕佳,郭元源,程聪.创业活动有效性:一项关于创业者的Meta分析检验[J/OL].外国经济与管理,2018,40(06):29-43[2026-11-20].https://doi.org/10.16538/j.cnki.fem.2018.06.003.
摘要
以往关于创业活动绩效影响因素的研究一直存在诸多分歧。以62项实证研究(104个独立样本)为对象,采用Meta分析技术全面考察了创业者个体特质与创业绩效之间的影响机制问题,其中,本文主要从创业精神、社会资本和学习能力三个维度来刻画创业者个体特质,并从成长绩效和生存绩效两个方面来衡量创业有效性,同时检验了创业者文化情境与创业环境对创业者与创业绩效之间作用关系的调节作用。研究发现,创业者的社会资本对企业成长绩效具有显著的促进作用,而学习能力则显著提升企业生存绩效。另外,文化情境和创业环境对于创业者的社会资本、学习能力与创业绩效之间都起到了正向调节作用。研究结果对于全面、深入认识影响创业活动有效性的前因机制具有重要的启发意义。
Entrepreneurial activities have always been one of the important driving forces for the economic development of all countries in the world. As the implementer of the whole entrepreneurial activity, the entrepreneur plays a very important role in entrepreneurial activities. Scholars have pointed that entrepreneurs’ individual characteristics are one of the important factors to explain how entrepreneurial vision changes into entrepreneurial action, and the entrepreneurial performance is influenced by cultural differences, perceptions of the external environment and social norms. The core of the entrepreneurs’ individual characteristics, such as entrepreneurial spirit quality, social relationship and learning ability, are the important factors that affect the entrepreneurial process and its performance. However, due to the differences of sample selection and research perspective, scholars have different understandings on the influence mechanism of entrepreneurs’ individual characteristics on entrepreneurial performance. Therefore, this study attempts to use the meta-analysis to make a comprehensive comparative analysis of the previous studies on the relationship between entrepreneurs and entrepreneurial performance, hoping to draw a theoretical framework for the integrated relationship between entrepreneurs and entrepreneurial performance. This study discusses the general influence mechanism of entrepreneurs’ individual characteristics on entrepreneurial performance from three aspects: entrepreneur spirit, social capital and learning ability. Entrepreneurial performance is divided into survival performance and growth performance. Besides, due to the individual characteristics and behaviors of entrepreneurs are influenced by personal growth environment and social experience. The communication and interaction mechanism in the entrepreneurial process is mainly influenced by local policies, institutions and specific trading patterns. Therefore, in this paper, we add two influential factors of entrepreneurial culture background and entrepreneurial environment, and discuss the possible moderating effect of entrepreneurs’ cultural background and entrepreneurial environment. In the process of data-analysis, we conduct the meta binary heterogeneity test first, and the results show there are significant different mechanisms among the entrepreneur spirit, social capital, learning capability and entrepreneurial performance. More specifically, entrepreneur spirit and social capital, social capital and learning ability have significant differences on the impact of growth performance respectively. Entrepreneur spirit and social capital, entrepreneur spirit and learning ability also have significant differences on the impact of survival performance respectively. In addition, there are significant differences between entrepreneurs’ cultural background and entrepreneurial environment on the impact of entrepreneurial performance. Secondly, meta-regression analysis shows that social capital and learning ability have a significant impact on entrepreneurial performance: social capital is the main factor that influences growth performance, and learning ability can significantly affect the survival performance; entrepreneurial environment plays an important moderating role in the relationship between entrepreneurs and entrepreneurial performance, growth performance, survival performance.
关键词: 创业精神,社会资本,学习能力,创业绩效,Meta分析