“言由心生”还是“言不由衷”:管理层语调是绿色创新的信号吗?
Speaking from the Heart or Insincerely: Is the Management Tone a Sign of Green Innovation?
DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20220327.401
[1]于芝麦.“言由心生”还是“言不由衷”:管理层语调是绿色创新的信号吗?[J/OL].外国经济与管理,2022,44(06):18-33[2026-11-20].https://doi.org/10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20220327.401.
摘要
以2006—2019年沪深A股上市公司数据为研究样本,基于言语行为理论探讨了管理层语调与企业绿色创新之间的关系。研究表明,管理层语调的积极程度越高越能促进企业绿色创新水平提升,说明管理层语调的积极程度对绿色创新具有预示作用;区分绿色创新类型发现,管理层语调积极程度对社会型绿色创新的预示作用更明显。进一步研究发现,较高的市场竞争压力和较低的融资约束程度有利于强化管理层语调积极程度对绿色创新的预示作用,且该效应在社会型绿色创新中更显著。管理层异常语调操纵对企业绿色创新有预测作用,尤其是社会型绿色创新;而反映公司日常发展的正常语调对企业绿色创新的预测作用不明显。此外,管理层语调积极程度预示了企业绿色创新,进而有利于企业价值的提升。研究丰富了管理层语调特征对企业行为影响的研究,解释了管理层语调积极程度对绿色创新产生预示作用所依赖的情境因素,为完善管理层语调作用的研究提供了理论支持和经验证据。
Green innovation has become an effective way to coordinate economic growth and environmental protection because of the combination of “green development” and “innovation-driven” characteristics. Enterprises are the main force to carry out green innovation, and the implementation of green innovation strategy cannot be separated from the support of managers. Managers run enterprises on behalf of shareholders and have more idiosyncratic information about enterprises than shareholders. When quantitative disclosure is strictly controlled, managers will use MD&A in the annual report to deliver text information about enterprises’ future development and strategic planning, which is a window for the management to transmit signals about corporate value to the outside world. However, executives of listed companies are often exposed as “inconsistent between words and deeds”, so is the management tone “from the heart” or “insincere”? Whether the management tone can explain green innovation behavior remains to be tested.
Given this, based on the speech act theory, this paper explores the relationship between management tone and green innovation based on the data of A-share listed companies in Shanghai and Shenzhen from 2006 to 2019. The results show that there is a significant positive correlation between the positive degree of management tone and the level of green innovation, indicating that the positive degree of management tone has a predictive effect on green innovation. By differentiating the types of green innovation, the positive degree of management tone has a more significant predictive effect on social green innovation. Furthermore, we find that higher market competition pressure and lower degree of financing constraint can enhance the predictive effect of positive management tone on green innovation (especially social green innovation). Management abnormal tone manipulation can predict green innovation (especially social green innovation). In addition, the positive tone of management predicts the green innovation of enterprises, which is conducive to the improvement of corporate value. This paper enriches the research on the impact of management intonation characteristics on enterprise behavior, explains the situational factors that the positive degree of management tone depends on to have a predictive effect on green innovation, and provides theoretical support and empirical evidence for improving the research on the effect of management tone.
The research contributions of this paper are as follows: (1) With the help of speech act theory, it examines the relationship between management tone and green innovation, expands the research scope of factors influencing green innovation from the psychological perspective of managers’ emotions and mentality, and discusses the predictive effect of abnormal tone manipulation and normal tone on green innovation. (2) It innovatively divides green innovation into self-interest green innovation and social green innovation, in order to identify the predictive effect of positive management tone on which type of green innovation is more significant, which is a reference for future investors, and enriches the practice system of China under the background of MD&A text information in the value of the enterprise environment strategy research.
关键词: 管理层语调积极程度,绿色创新,社会型绿色创新,言语行为理论,异常语调操纵