精神型领导对员工工匠精神的影响

The Impact of Spiritual Leadership on Employees’ Craftsman Spirit

刘园园,刘平青,杨征,刘淑桢,崔遵康

2022 第 44 卷 第 02 期 页码 102-116

DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20210809.302

PDF全文下载 HTML全文

摘要

制造业的转型升级离不开员工工匠精神的培育。工匠精神主要来自于个体内在精神性追求,它的形成离不开个体对意义的追寻。而精神型领导通过满足员工精神性需求来激发员工内在工作动力,与工匠精神具有天然的契合性。本文通过对424份领导—员工配对数据的分析发现:精神型领导可以通过工作意义感召使员工完成工作意义建构,进而通过员工的工作意义感知促进其工匠精神的形成;当员工与组织价值观相匹配时,员工更容易基于领导者的意义感召完成意义建构,从而形成更高水平的工匠精神;在同样感知到工作意义的员工中,成就动机强的员工更容易形成高水平的工匠精神。文章为组织通过一定的领导行为激发员工的工匠精神提供了参考,对于组织甄选更容易培育工匠精神的员工也有启示意义。

With the continuous development of economy and society, products and services in the new era are required to be of higher quality, so the Times call for craftsman spirit to promote high-quality social development. Craftsman spirit is embodied in the individual’s love for work, inner sense of mission and adherence to excellent quality. It mainly comes from the individual’s inner spiritual pursuit, which requires the individual to have internal power, and its formation cannot be separated from the individual’s pursuit of the meaning of work. Spiritual leadership is a kind of leadership behavior that affirms and supports the spiritual existence of employees, satisfies their spiritual needs and stimulates their inner motivation by conveying organizational vision, giving hope and faith and expressing altruistic love. Given this, this paper argues that the above natural fit between spiritual leadership and craftsman spirit makes spiritual leadership significantly improve craftsman spirit, and this process is realized through the mediating role of the meaning of work. Moreover, value fit and achievement motivation play the two-stage moderating role.

In order to obtain more objective and effective data, this study sets up the leader-employee paired questionnaire, in which the employees are responsible for filling in the contents such as spiritual leadership values, achievement motivation, work meaning perception and control variables, and the leaders are responsible for filling in the control variables and evaluating the craftsman spirit of employees. At the same time, we collect data across three waves. At time 1, we collect spiritual leadership (antecedent) and control variables in the employee questionnaire; at time 2, we only include participants who respond to the first survey to provide information on meaning of work (mediator) and value fit (moderator); at time 3, craftsman spirit (outcome variable) in the leadership questionnaire and achievement motivation (moderator) in the employee questionnaire are collected. The study finally obtains 424 pairs of valid data, while the confirmatory factor analysis, correlation analysis, and cross-layer regression analysis are adopted to generate empirical results.

The findings show that spiritual leadership is positively related to craftsman spirit; spiritual leadership significantly promotes craftsman spirit and through which it further enhances the meaning of work; value fit enhances the impact of spiritual leadership on the meaning of work, and based on which it further increases craftsman spirit; among employees who also perceive the meaning of work, those with high achievement motivation significantly enhance craftsman spirit. In sum, this paper verifies the mediating role of the meaning of work, and also examines the two-stage moderating effect of value fit and achievement motivation.

Based on the sense-making theory, this paper explores the impact of sense-giving of spiritual leadership on employees’ work sense-making and craftsman spirit. This paper makes several contributions to the literature: First, according to the logic of the motivating factor, process mechanism and effect result of meaning construction, it analyzes the stimulating effect of spiritual leadership on employees’ craftsman spirit, reveals the importance of the individual’s inner meaning pursuit, and inspires managers to stimulate employees’ craftsman spirit from the perspectives of spirit and internal driving force. Second, from the perspective of the connection between “sense-giving” and “cognitive framework”, it reveals the two-stage moderating mechanism of value fit and achievement motivation on craftsman spirit, which proves that the effective unity of work situation and employee characteristics is a powerful driving force to enhance craftsman spirit. This paper provides a reference for how organizations can inspire employees’ craftsman spirit through leadership behaviors, and also has enlightenment for organizations to select employees who are easier to cultivate craftsman spirit.

参考文献

4 高中华, 赵晨, 付悦, 等. 团队情境下忧患型领导对角色绩效的多层链式影响机制研究[J]. 管理世界,2020, 36(9): 186-201,216. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1002-5502.2020.09.016
6 叶龙, 刘园园, 郭名. 包容型领导对技能人才工匠精神的影响[J]. 技术经济,2018, 37(10): 36-44. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1002-980X.2018.10.005
8 Bayighomog S W, Araslı H. Workplace spirituality-customer engagement Nexus: The mediated role of spiritual leadership on customer-oriented boundary-spanning behaviors[J]. The Service Industries Journal,2019, 39(7-8): 637-661. DOI:10.1080/02642069.2019.1570153
9 Cable D M, DeRue D S. The convergent and discriminant validity of subjective fit perceptions[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology,2002, 87(5): 875-884. DOI:10.1037/0021-9010.87.5.875
10 Fry L W, Vitucci S, Cedillo M. Spiritual leadership and army transformation: Theory, measurement, and establishing a baseline[J]. The Leadership Quarterly,2005, 16(5): 835-862. DOI:10.1016/j.leaqua.2005.07.012
11 Ghadi M Y, Fernando M, Caputi P. Transformational leadership and work engagement: The mediating effect of meaning in work[J]. Leadership & Organization Development Journal,2013, 34(6): 532-550.
12 Maitlis S. The social processes of organizational sensemaking[J]. Academy of Management Journal,2005, 48(1): 21-49. DOI:10.5465/amj.2005.15993111
13 Schoen J L. Effects of implicit achievement motivation, expected evaluations, and domain knowledge on creative performance[J]. Journal of Organizational Behavior,2015, 36(3): 319-338. DOI:10.1002/job.1982
14 Wang Z, Xu H Y. When and for whom ethical leadership is more effective in eliciting work meaningfulness and positive attitudes: The moderating roles of core self-evaluation and perceived organizational support[J]. Journal of Business Ethics,2019, 156(4): 919-940. DOI:10.1007/s10551-017-3563-x
15 Wu J Y, Li C. Exploration of mediating models between spiritual leadership and organizational citizenship behavior: The importance of organization based self-esteem in service industries[J]. International Journal of Organizational Innovation,2015, 8(2): 128-136.
16 Yang F, Huang X Y, Wu L S. Experiencing meaningfulness climate in teams: How spiritual leadership enhances team effectiveness when facing uncertain tasks[J]. Human Resource Management,2019, 58(2): 155-168. DOI:10.1002/hrm.21943