用户生成内容激励机制研究综述及展望

A Literature Review of the Incentive of User-Generated Content and Prospects

秦芬,李扬

2018 第 40 卷 第 08 期 页码 141-152

DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.2018.08.011

PDF全文下载 HTML全文

摘要

用户生成内容指用户在社交媒体、电商网站、在线问答社区等平台上发表的文字、图片、音频、视频等各种形式的内容。用户生成内容对消费者决策、平台定位等都至关重要,但是目前很多平台面临用户生成内容不足或贡献不大的局面,为了激励用户创造内容,平台或企业采用了多种激励方式,各激励方式的效果成为学术界一个重要的研究主题。本文对现有的用户生成内容激励机制文献进行了梳理,首先概述了用户生成内容的概念及分类;然后从经济激励、非经济激励和联合激励三个维度对已有文献进行了综述,总结了影响激励效果的因素及各种激励方式的优点和不足;最后从经济激励形式的拓展、引入惩罚机制和多平台联合激励等角度展望了未来的研究方向,希望为未来的研究提供基础和新思路,并帮助企业和平台制定合适的激励政策。

User-generated content is the content created by users on Internet platforms such as social media, e-commerce websites, video-sharing websites, which has the forms of text, image, audio, video and so on. User-generated content is crucial to the orientation of platforms, the survey of enterprises and the choice of consumers, but its shortage and under-contribution are major problems on many platforms, which are related to its inherent attributes of public goods and users’ fatigue effects. In order to encourage users to generate content, a variety of incentive systems are adopted, and the effect of which has become a hot research topic in recent years. Given that study on this issue is new and largely fragmented, it will be theoretically important to understand what has been studied. In this study, we conduct a systematic review of related literature. For one thing, we discuss the concept and classification of user-generated content from multiple angles , and compare them with electronic word of mouth, value creating and so on; then we classify incentive systems into the economic type, the non-economic type and their combination. More importantly, we evaluate the advantages and disadvantages of various incentive systems and sum up the influencing factors of their effects. Various incentive systems take advantage of different user motivations, so we also analyze them. Economic incentives include offering monetary rewards, discounts and coupons, other user donations and so on. This type of incentive plays a role in stimulating all users to generate content in the short term, but it is not feasible in the long run, especially for active users. It even has a negative impact on the content quality. Non-economic motivation systems have more forms, commonly including gamification designs, reputation visualization and providing norms. Points system, ranking system and peer-rating system are essential elements in the gamification solution, which can inspire users to contribute more information in general, especially at the period of approaching certain level, taking advantage of their motivation of pursuing honors, external rewards, attentions and so on. However, the effect of the points system incentive is periodic. After achieving the fixed target, users’ contribution frequency reduces significantly, and with the users’ level increasing, the average quality of content declines. Reputation visualization contains displaying data associated with users or content, for instance, the shared number, contributors’ personal information, etc. Research results show that this kind of motivation can positively affect the users’ contribution behavior for a long time, and when reviewers’ personal information is disclosed, their comments are more positive, but for users pursuing reputation, the frequency of creating content decreases as the content can not affect the number of followers. Providing social norms can also be a positive stimulus, but external standards have no effect on the inactive users. The combination of economic incentives and non-economic incentives can be conducted simultaneously or in different stages, which can avoid the corrosive effect of money for active users. Future studies can consider giving users a large number of economic rewards, introducing punishment mechanisms and joint incentives of multiple platforms. By providing a systematic review of different incentive methods and their benefits and shortcomings, we believe that we will contribute to the understanding of the UGC incentive systems, give a useful basis for UGC research, and help enterprises or platforms to make appropriate incentive policies in the future.

参考文献

2 王军. 不同激励理论在团队激励中的应用[J]. 科技管理研究, 2010, (19): 106–109. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1000-7695.2010.19.028
3 杨风雷, 黎建辉. 用户生成内容中的垃圾意见研究综述[J]. 计算机应用研究, 2011, (10): 3601–3605. DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1001-3695.2011.10.001
8 Aaltonen A, Seiler S. Cumulative growth in user-generated content production: Evidence from Wikipedia[J]. Management Science, 2016, 62(7): 2054–2069. DOI:10.1287/mnsc.2015.2253
9 Burtch G, Hong Y L, Bapna R, et al. Stimulating online reviews by combining financial incentives and social norms[J]. Management Science, 2017, doi: 10.1287/mnsc.2016.2715. DOI:10.1287/mnsc.2016.2715
10 Cabral L, Li L F. A dollar for your thoughts: Feedback-conditional rebates on ebay[J]. Management Science, 2015, 61(9): 2052–2063. DOI:10.1287/mnsc.2014.2074
11 Chen Y, Harper F M, Konstan J, et al. Social comparisons and contributions to online communities: A field experiment on movielens[J]. American Economic Review, 2010, 100(4): 1358–1398. DOI:10.1257/aer.100.4.1358
12 Deangelis D, Barber S. Systemic reciprocal rewards: Motivating expert participation in online communities with a novel class of incentives[J]. International Journal of Agent Technologies and Systems, 2014, 6(2): 30–50. DOI:10.4018/IJATS
13 Easley D, Ghosh A. Incentives, gamification, and game theory: An economic approach to badge design[A]. Proceedings of the 14th ACM conference on electronic commerce[C]. Philadelphia: ACM, 2013: 359–376.
14 Farzan R, DiMicco J M, Millen D R, et al. Results from deploying a participation incentive mechanism within the enterprise[A]. Proceedings of the SIGCHI conference on human factors in computing systems[C]. Florence: ACM, 2008a: 563–572.
15 Forman C, Ghose A, Wiesenfeld B. Examining the relationship between reviews and sales: The role of reviewer identity disclosure in electronic markets[J]. Information Systems Research, 2008, 19(3): 291–313. DOI:10.1287/isre.1080.0193
16 Fradkin A, Grewal E, Holtz D. The determinants of online review informativeness: Evidence from field experiments on Airbnb[M]. Mimeo: MIT Press, 2017.
18 Geri N, Gafni R, Bengov P. Crowdsourcing as a business model: Extrinsic motivations for knowledge sharing in user-generated content websites[J]. Journal of Global Operations and Strategic Sourcing, 2017, 10(1): 90–111. DOI:10.1108/JGOSS-05-2016-0018
19 Goes P B, Lin M F, Au Yeung C M. " Popularity effect” in user-generated content: Evidence from online product reviews[J]. Information Systems Research, 2014, 25(2): 222–238. DOI:10.1287/isre.2013.0512
20 Goes P B, Guo C H, Lin M F. Do incentive hierarchies induce user effort? Evidence from an online knowledge exchange[J]. Information Systems Research, 2016, 27(3): 497–516. DOI:10.1287/isre.2016.0635
21 Helm R, Möller M, Mauroner O, et al. The effects of a lack of social recognition on online communication behavior[J]. Computers in Human Behavior, 2013, 29(3): 1065–1077. DOI:10.1016/j.chb.2012.09.007
23 Huang Y, Singh P, Mukhopadhyay T. Crowdsourcing contests: A dynamic structural model of the impact of incentive structure on solution quality[A]. Proceedings of the 33rd international conference on information system[C]. Orlando: International Conference on Information Systems, 2012: 2505–2521.
24 Jain S, Chen Y L, Parkes D C. Designing incentives for online question-and-answer forums[J]. Games and Economic Behavior, 2014, 86: 458–474. DOI:10.1016/j.geb.2012.11.003
25 Khansa L, Ma X, Liginlal D, et al. Understanding members’ active participation in online question-and-answer communities: A theory and empirical analysis[J]. Journal of Management Information Systems, 2015, 32(2): 162–203. DOI:10.1080/07421222.2015.1063293
28 Krishnamurthy S, Dou W Y. Note from special issue editors: Advertising with user-generated content: A framework and research agenda[J]. Journal of Interactive Advertising, 2008, 8(2): 1–4. DOI:10.1080/15252019.2008.10722137
29 Levina N, Arriaga M. Distinction and status production on user-generated content platforms: Using Bourdieu’s theory of cultural production to understand social dynamics in online fields[J]. Information Systems Research, 2014, 25(3): 468–488. DOI:10.1287/isre.2014.0535
30 Li Z L, Huang K W, Cavusoglu H. Can we gamify voluntary contributions to online Q&A communities? Quantifying the impact of badges on user engagement[A]. Proceedings of 2012 workshop on information systems and economics[C]. Orlando, Florida: WISE, 2012.
32 Mackiewicz J. Motivating quality: Motivating quality: The impact of amateur editors’ suggestions on user-generated content at Epinions.com[J]. Journal of Business and Technical Communication, 2014, 28(4): 419–446. DOI:10.1177/1050651914535930
33 Mutter T, Kundisch D. Behavioral mechanisms prompted by virtual rewards: The small-area hypothesis[A]. Proceedings of ECIS 2015 completed research papers[C]. Münster: European Conference on Information Systems, 2015: 137.
34 Park J, Van Der Schaar M. A game theoretic analysis of incentives in content production and sharing over peer-to-peer networks[J]. IEEE Journal of Selected Topics in Signal Processing, 2010, 4(4): 704–717. DOI:10.1109/JSTSP.2010.2048609
35 Pavlou P, Wang S T. How do monetary incentives affect online product reviews and sales?[A]. Proceedings of e-business and ecommerce[C]. Puerto Rico: Americas Conference on Information Systems, 2015: 35.
36 Poch R, Martin B. Effects of intrinsic and extrinsic motivation on user-generated content[J]. Journal of Strategic Marketing, 2015, 23(4): 305–317. DOI:10.1080/0965254X.2014.926966
39 Qiao D D, Lee S Y, Whinston A, et al. Incentive provision and pro-social behaviors[A]. Proceedings of the 50th Hawaii international conference on system sciences[C]. HICSS, 2017: 5599–5608.
40 Sato K, Hashimoto R, Yoshino M, et al. Incentive mechanism considering variety of user cost in P2P content sharing[A]. Proceedings of 2008 IEEE global telecommunications conference[C]. New Orleans, LO: IEEE, 2008: 1–5.
42 Shen W Q, Hu Y J, Ulmer J R. Competing for attention: An empirical study of online reviewers’ strategic behavior[J]. Mis Quarterly, 2015, 39(3): 683–696. DOI:10.25300/MISQ
43 Shriver S K, Nair H S, Hofstetter R. Social ties and user-generated content: Evidence from an online social network[J]. Management Science, 2013, 59(6): 1425–1443. DOI:10.1287/mnsc.1110.1648
44 Stephen A, Bart Y, Du Plessis C, et al. Does paying for online product reviews pay off? The effects of monetary incentives on content creators and consumers[A]. Gürhan-Canli Z, Otnes C, Zhu R. Advances in consumer research volume 40[C]. Association for Consumer Research, 2012: 1–44.
45 Sun Y C, Dong X J, McIntyre S. Motivation of user-generated content: Social connectedness moderates the effects of monetary rewards[J]. Marketing Science, 2017, 36(3): 329–337. DOI:10.1287/mksc.2016.1022
46 Toubia O, Stephen A T. Intrinsic vs. image-related utility in social media: Why do people contribute content to twitter?[J]. Marketing Science, 2013, 32(3): 368–392. DOI:10.1287/mksc.2013.0773
47 Von Rechenberg T, Gutt D, Kundisch D. Goals as reference points: Empirical evidence from a virtual reward system[J]. Decision Analysis, 2016, 13(2): 153–171. DOI:10.1287/deca.2016.0331
49 Wang S A, Pavlou P, Gong J. Monetary incentives, online reviews, and product sales: An empirical investigation[A]. Proceedings of economics and value of IS[C]. International Conference on Information Systems, 2016: 9.
50 Yan B, Jian L. Beyond reciprocity: The bystander effect of knowledge response in online knowledge communities[J]. Computers in Human Behavior, 2017, 76: 9–18. DOI:10.1016/j.chb.2017.06.040
51 Yen W C. Understanding customers’ willingness to participate in co-creation: The fit perspective[A]. Proceedings of the 19th pacific Asia conference on information systems[C]. Singapore: PACIS, 2015: 175.
52 Yu G P, Zou D Q. A referral rewards incentive design on travel consumer-generated content[A]. Proceedings of the 15th international conference on electronic business[C]. CEUR-WS, 2015: 30–39.
55 Zhao L, Detlor B, Connelly C E. Sharing knowledge in social Q&A sites: The unintended consequences of extrinsic motivation[J]. Journal of Management Information Systems, 2016, 33(1): 70–100. DOI:10.1080/07421222.2016.1172459