在线同侪反馈内容特征对用户持续更新贡献的影响研究——基于网络嵌入视角
The Impact of the Content Characteristics of Online Peer Feedback on Users’ Continuous Update Contributions: From the Perspective of Network Embeddedness
DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20241118.402
[1]尹苗苗,吴钰,李纪莹,彭秀青.在线同侪反馈内容特征对用户持续更新贡献的影响研究——基于网络嵌入视角[J/OL].外国经济与管理,2025,47(07):85-100[2026-11-20].https://doi.org/10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20241118.402.
摘要
用户不断更新已有创新想法是在线用户创新社区得以持续发展的重要驱动力。本文基于反馈干预理论,从网络嵌入视角揭示在线同侪反馈内容特征对用户持续更新贡献的影响机理。通过持续追踪乐高Ideas社区720个用户13个月的创新贡献情况,围绕在线同侪反馈的内容特征(建设性反馈和多样性反馈)展开实证检验,研究发现:(1)多样性反馈与用户持续更新贡献之间存在倒U形关系,建设性反馈积极影响用户持续更新贡献。(2)关系嵌入和结构嵌入作为重要的情境因素,强化了多样性反馈与用户持续更新贡献之间的“过犹不及”效应,但是关系嵌入削弱了建设性反馈与用户持续更新贡献之间的积极影响。研究结论不仅拓展了反馈干预理论的应用范围,还为在线用户创新社区激励用户高质量地持续贡献提供了建议和启示。
By continuously tracking the users’ innovative posts of the “Product Ideas” section of the Lego IDEAS community from January 2022 to January 2023, this paper obtains the data of 1,032 innovations posted by 720 users and 93,783 comments posted by 23,663 users. Furthermore, the text content analysis method is used to deconstruct online peer feedback, which is divided into constructive feedback and diverse feedback, and the hierarchical regression analysis and robustness testing methods are used to empirically test the theoretical hypothesis. The results show that there is an inverted U-shaped relationship between diverse feedback and users’ continuous update contributions, and constructive feedback positively affects users’ continuous update contributions. As important contextual factors, relational embeddedness and structural embeddedness strengthen the “too much of a good thing” effect between diverse feedback and users’ continuous update contributions, but relational embeddedness weakens the positive effect between constructive feedback and users’ continuous update contributions.
关键词: 多样性反馈,建设性反馈,关系嵌入,结构嵌入,用户持续更新贡献