管理者双元性研究现状探析和未来展望
Manager Ambidexterity: A Literature Review and Prospects
DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.2018.08.009
[1]李悦.管理者双元性研究现状探析和未来展望[J/OL].外国经济与管理,2018,40(08):112-124[2026-11-20].https://doi.org/10.16538/j.cnki.fem.2018.08.009.
摘要
双元性研究旨在探讨如何管理组织中探索和开发活动的张力,管理者双元性是当前该研究领域的一个热点话题。本文首先剖析了管理者双元性的内涵,厘清了个体层面探索和开发活动的关系,将管理者双元性特征归纳为“均衡”“切换”和“协同”三个方面。其次,对管理者双元性的测量方式进行了总结和分析。再次,梳理了管理者双元性的前因并对这些前因和管理者双元性三种特征的关系进行了分析,然后梳理了管理者双元性对管理者自身及下属的各种积极和消极影响。最后,针对现有研究的不足,从测量方式、前因研究、影响效应研究以及管理层级和职能细分四个方面对未来研究进行了展望。
Scholars have increasingly argued that organizational ambidexterity may in part root in managers’ ambidextrous behaviors. Although some studies provide valuable descriptions of managers’ ambidextrous behaviors, ambidexterity research at this level of analyses would benefit from further conceptualization. Based on previous studies, three related characteristics of manager ambidexterity are proposed and clarified as " coexistence”, " switch” and " synergy” in terms of how to balance explorative and exploitative activities. First, coexistence means that ambidextrous managers achieve a balance between exploration and exploitation activities by unbalancing to counter the tendency to become more exploitation oriented, because of their risk aversion and inclination toward efficiency. Second, switch means that managing the tension between exploration and exploitation requires ambidextrous managers’ behavioral flexibility to switch between different and often paradoxical activities in correspondence to the environmental demands. Last, synergy involves shifting levels of analysis to identify potential linkages which means holding sustained attention to possible synergies between exploitation and exploration activities. The former is referred to as the " Combined Dimension of Ambidexterity” and the latter as the " Balance Dimension of Ambidexterity”. Unfortunately, the combination of both dimensions has never been used in the empirical study, so it is still not clear about inter-relationships and combined effects of these two dimensions, and this gap should be addressed in future studies. Studies on antecedents to manager ambidexterity have provided insights into the factors that might contribute to managers’ ambidextrous behaviors, including variables at both individual and organizational levels. Based on the three characteristics of manager ambidexterity proposed by this paper, how and why are those factors linked to a manger’s success in balancing exploration and exploitation activities is comprehensively elaborated. There are primarily two streams of research in terms of the effect of manager ambidexterity, one is its impact on the performance of individual managers, and the other is the influence of managerial ambidextrous leading styles on the performance of subordinate individuals or teams from the perspective of leadership behaviors. Generally speaking, our understanding about the conditions under which ambidextrous managers may be most effective is far from complete, and therefore more research is needed for a better understanding about how and when manager ambidexterity leads to success at the individual, team and organizational levels. Finally, this paper closes with a point of view on the promising areas for ongoing research, including measurement issues, antecedents, effects, and hierarchical and functional related issues.
关键词: 管理者双元性,双元领导风格,矛盾式领导风格,探索活动,开发活动