基于元分析的多元领导力效能研究

A Meta-Analysis Research on Plural Leadership Effectiveness

吕鸿江,钱楚慧,赵兴华

2018 第 40 卷 第 09 期 页码 126-142

DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.2018.09.010

PDF全文下载 HTML全文

摘要

多元领导力是群体领导力模式的重要发展趋势。本文借鉴Denis等(2001,2012)在群体领导力基础上构建的多元领导力概念及分类,运用元分析方法检验了多元领导力对领导力效能的影响及情境因素和方法因素的调节作用,进而解释了以往多元领导力影响领导力效能问题存在分歧的原因。本文基于对1991—2017年60篇独立研究样本的元分析发现:多元领导力能有效提升领导力效能;相对于提升绩效而言,多元领导力能更显著地促进心理和行为过程;而且,共享和关系领导力侧重于改进心理和行为,分布和集体领导力则有助于提升绩效;当团队平均任期和文化差异以及领导力测量方法变化时,多元领导力对领导力效能的影响会变化,但团队类型和数据属性的变化不会影响多元领导力对领导力效能的影响。上述结论厘清并丰富了多元领导力影响领导力效能的已有成果,也为企业根据自身情况成功实施多元领导力提供了指导。

Plural leadership is an important development trend of the group leadership mode. At present, a large quantity of literature has conducted theoretical and empirical research on plural leadership, among which, the most key concern is the leadership effectiveness of plural leadership. From the early exploration of relationship between two variables to the introduction of mediating mechanisms and moderator variables that influence the strength or direction of this relationship, academics have conducted in-depth studies. However, there are still different views around the current research on the effectiveness of plural leadership. For example, bounded by a particular research design, the analysis conclusions on the relationship between plural leadership and leadership effectiveness have different perspectives on the strength, direction and statistical significance of correlations, and the increase in the number of related studies in recent years has exacerbated these divergences. We believe that there are two potential reasons to explain these inconsistencies. First, previous quantitative literature that analyzes these differences by the meta-analysis method tend to mix different types of plural leadership concepts and fail to truly reflect the effectiveness of plural leadership. Second, current empirical literature that adopts different indicators to measure leadership effectiveness and lack uniformity for various research situations and data measurement methods, may also lead to different leadership effectiveness outcomes of plural leadership.   In order to avoid the above two problems, drawing on the concept and classification of plural leadership constructed by Denis, et al.(2001, 2012)based on group leadership, this study examines the effect of plural leadership on leadership effectiveness and the moderator effects of situational factors and methodological factors through the meta-analysis method, then explores in depth the inconsistent reasons of this relationship between plural leadership and leadership effectiveness in previous studies. Four inclusion criteria are used to collect samples from the eastern and western resources. First, the research must include relevant variables for plural leadership and leadership effectiveness. Second, we only focus on empirical research, excluding review articles, case studies and other research. Third, effect statistics between two variables must be reported in the study. Fourth, if the same sample is repeatedly published in different studies, we only select larger sample size and more detailed studies in the present study. Based on 60 independent research samples from 1991 to 2017 years that are finally included, we code the samples and resolve the disagreement through discussion or other means, then analyze the data by utilizing the Comprehensive Meta-Analysis(CMA)Version 2 program.  Meta-analysis results show that: plural leadership can effectively promote leadership effectiveness; in terms of performance improvement, plural leadership can significantly improve psychological and behavioral processes; moreover, shared and relational leadership focuses on promoting psychological and behavioral processes, while distributed and collective leadership contributes to performance improvement; when team average tenure, cultural differences and leadership measures change, the effect of plural leadership on leadership effectiveness will vary, but changes in team types and data attributes do not affect the impact of plural leadership on leadership effectiveness. The above conclusions clarify and enrich the existing research results on the link between plural leadership and leadership effectiveness. Moreover, it is of great practical significance for enterprises seeking to transform the leadership model to successfully implement plural leadership among team members, and to guide the contingency implementation of plural leadership management methods based on their own characteristics, team mission requirements and organizational environment choices.

参考文献

1 曹晶, 杨斌, 杨百寅. 行业环境调节作用下集体领导力的动态变化与企业绩效[J]. 管理学报,2015, (7): 993-1000 DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1672-884x.2015.07.008
3 韩宏稳, 杨世信. 共享型领导对团队创造力的影响及内在机制研究[J]. 现代管理科学,2016, (1): 118-120 DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1007-368X.2016.01.039
5 马璐, 王丹阳. 共享型领导对员工主动创新行为的影响[J]. 科技进步与对策,2016, (22): 131-136 DOI:10.6049/kjjbydc.201611X108
6 谢永平, 郑倩林. 信息多样化与创业团队绩效关系研究——以共享领导为中介变量[J]. 科技进步与对策,2016, (12): 8-15 DOI:10.6049/kjjbydc.2015120505
8 Bergman J Z, Rentsch J R, Small E E, et al. The shared leadership process in decision-making teams[J]. The Journal of Social Psychology,2012, 152(1): 17-42 DOI:10.1080/00224545.2010.538763
9 Bligh M C, Pearce C L, Kohles J C. The importance of self-and shared leadership in team based knowledge work: A meso-level model of leadership dynamics[J]. Journal of Managerial Psychology,2006, 21(4): 296-318 DOI:10.1108/02683940610663105
11 Colbert A E, Barrick M R, Bradley B H. Personality and leadership composition in top management teams: Implications for organizational effectiveness[J]. Personnel Psychology,2014, 67(2): 351-387 DOI:10.1111/peps.2014.67.issue-2
12 Contractor N S, DeChurch L A, Carson J, et al. The topology of collective leadership[J]. The Leadership Quarterly,2012, 23(6): 994-1011 DOI:10.1016/j.leaqua.2012.10.010
13 Daniels M A, Greguras G J. Exploring the nature of power distance: Implications for micro- and macro-level theories, processes, and outcomes[J]. Journal of Management,2014, 40(5): 1202-1229 DOI:10.1177/0149206314527131
15 Denis J L, Langley A, Sergi V. Leadership in the plural[J]. Academy of Management Annals,2012, 6(1): 211-283 DOI:10.5465/19416520.2012.667612
16 D’Innocenzo L, Mathieu J E, Kukenberger M R. A meta-analysis of different forms of shared leadership-team performance relations[J]. Journal of Management,2016, 42(7): 1964-1991 DOI:10.1177/0149206314525205
17 Drescher M A, Korsgaard M A, Welpe I M, et al. The dynamics of shared leadership: Building trust and enhancing performance[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology,2014, 99(5): 771-783 DOI:10.1037/a0036474
18 Drescher G, Garbers Y. Shared leadership and commonality: A policy-capturing study[J]. The Leadership Quarterly,2016, 27(2): 200-217 DOI:10.1016/j.leaqua.2016.02.002
21 Hmieleski K M, Cole M S, Baron R A. Shared authentic leadership and new venture performance[J]. Journal of Management,2012, 38(5): 1476-1499 DOI:10.1177/0149206311415419
22 Hoch J E, Kozlowski S W J. Leading virtual teams: Hierarchical leadership, structural supports, and shared team leadership[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology,2014, 99(3): 390-403 DOI:10.1037/a0030264
23 Ishikawa J. Transformational leadership and gatekeeping leadership: The roles of norm for maintaining consensus and shared leadership in team performance[J]. Asia Pacific Journal of Management,2012, 29(2): 265-283 DOI:10.1007/s10490-012-9282-z
24 Komives S R, Lucas N, McMahon T R. Exploring leadership: For college students who want to make a difference[M]. San Francisco: John Wiley & Sons, 2009.
25 Lin Z, Yang H, Arya B, et al. Structural versus individual perspectives on the dynamics of group performance: Theoretical exploration and empirical investigation[J]. Journal of Management,2005, 31(3): 354-380 DOI:10.1177/0149206304272150
27 Lipsey M W, Wilson D B. Practical meta-analysis[M]. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE Publications, 2001.
28 Liu S B, Hu J, Li Y H, et al. Examining the cross-level relationship between shared leadership and learning in teams: Evidence from China[J]. The Leadership Quarterly,2014, 25(2): 282-295 DOI:10.1016/j.leaqua.2013.08.006
30 Nicolaides V C, LaPort K A, Chen T R, et al. The shared leadership of teams: A meta-analysis of proximal, distal, and moderating relationships[J]. The Leadership Quarterly,2014, 25(5): 923-942 DOI:10.1016/j.leaqua.2014.06.006
31 Pearce C L, Ensley M D. A reciprocal and longitudinal investigation of the innovation process: The central role of shared vision in product and process innovation teams(PPITs)[J]. Journal of Organizational Behavior,2004, 25(2): 259-278 DOI:10.1002/(ISSN)1099-1379
32 Robert L P. A multi-level analysis of the impact of shared leadership in diverse virtual teams[A]. Proceedings of the 2nd ACM conference on computer supported cooperative work[C]. San Antonio, TX, United States: ACM, 2013.
34 Serban A, Roberts A J B. Exploring antecedents and outcomes of shared leadership in a creative context: A mixed-methods approach[J]. The Leadership Quarterly,2016, 27(2): 181-199 DOI:10.1016/j.leaqua.2016.01.009
35 Wang D N, Waldman D A, Zhang Z. A meta-analysis of shared leadership and team effectiveness[J]. Journal of Applied Psychology,2014, 99(2): 181-198 DOI:10.1037/a0034531
36 White L, Currie G, Lockett A. Pluralized leadership in complex organizations: Exploring the cross network effects between formal and informal leadership relations[J]. The Leadership Quarterly,2016, 27(2): 280-297 DOI:10.1016/j.leaqua.2016.01.004