叙事取向的创业研究:创业研究的另一种视角
Narratives in the Entrepreneurship Study: Alternative Perspectives on Entrepreneurship Research
DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.2018.09.002
[1]杜晶晶,王晶晶,陈忠卫.叙事取向的创业研究:创业研究的另一种视角[J/OL].外国经济与管理,2018,40(09):18-29[2026-11-20].https://doi.org/10.16538/j.cnki.fem.2018.09.002.
摘要
叙事取向的创业研究是在“语言学转向”的背景下,强调语言和语言生成,以话语、故事分析为方法论工具的创业研究。作为与实证主义相对的一种研究范式,它为探究创业过程的复杂性和多样性提供了一种更为有效的尝试和手段。在总结回顾了创业叙事的缘起、研究范围、重要立场后,本文选择了5个在创业领域有较高影响力期刊的34篇文章进行梳理和总结,回顾了叙事取向创业研究的主要研究脉络与研究方法,并从方法及内容上对未来叙事取向创业研究的发展方向进行了展望。研究结果对于系统梳理创业叙事这一前沿研究领域,了解和发扬叙事取向的创业研究有着重要价值。
Narratives in entrepreneurship focus on the use and generation of words, which is based on the methods of discourse and story analysis under the background of linguistic turn. As an opposite research paradigm compared with positivism, narratives in the entrepreneurship study have opened a new door in exploring the complexity and diversity of entrepreneurial process. Narratives provide an approach that promises insights into the prosaic or everyday aspects of entrepreneurship which has also been labeled as " a science of imagination” for what entrepreneurship might offer as a contribution to scholarship(Gartner, 2007). Despite the rising interest in narrative approaches in entrepreneurship literature, we must acknowledge that the broad label of narrative research encompasses research that varies in the " kinds of data, theoretical perspective, epistemological position, research questions, even in definition of narrative”(Riessman, 2008), which issues great challenges to entrepreneurship researchers who want to analyze their own narrative materials. Meanwhile, not enough attention has been paid to the " narrative turn” in entrepreneurship research in domestic academia, with the lack of research papers as well as introductory articles. To address this challenge, especially for domestic scholars who are not adept in using narrative methods, this paper combs the research frame and methodologies in entrepreneurial narratives systematically. Based on the analysis of selected papers from top 5 journals in entrepreneurship research, it defines the definition, research scopes and basic standpoints of entrepreneurial narratives with a review of extant contributions of narrative materials to entrepreneurship research. After that, the main topics of entrepreneurial narrative literature are generalized and reviewed in the aspects of entrepreneurial identities, entrepreneurial learning, entrepreneurial failure, entrepreneurial opportunity, narrative competence, and organizational identity. The research methods of entrepreneurial narratives are also summarized, highlighting the vast number of approaches used by researchers in the field, which can be classified as the " analysis of narrative”, " narrative analysis”, or both according to Polkinghorne(1995). Finally, this paper draws conclusions and suggests for further research directions in both methodologies and relevant research themes. For example, rebuilding entrepreneurship, thick description of entrepreneurs career paths, mechanisms of organizational dynamics and entrepreneurial narratives under the internet context. The conclusions are of great importance to the exploration of entrepreneurial narratives and the advancement of narratives in entrepreneurship research. The primary contributions of this paper are as follows: First, we make a thorough exploration of the origin and benchmark of entrepreneurial narratives which demonstrates its uniqueness in organizational studies. Second, a research framework is provided covering the main topics of entrepreneurial narratives and the relationship between different themes through a careful literature review. Finally, approaches gathered from varied fields from early literary criticisms to contemporary critical analyses are compared as to demonstrate and reflect upon how narrative approaches can contribute to entrepreneurship research. While the empirical approach still dominates the mainstream of management studies, the promotion of narratives in entrepreneurship provides a more inspiring way in exploring the complexity of entrepreneurial activities.
关键词: 叙事,创业叙事,故事,身份,意义建构