“老好人”能当好团队领导吗?——团队领导宜人性与团队创造力的关系
Can the “Good Man” be a Good Team Leader? A Research on the Relationship between Leaders’ Agreeableness and Team Creativity
DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.2018.12.008
[1]李召敏,赵曙明.“老好人”能当好团队领导吗?——团队领导宜人性与团队创造力的关系[J/OL].外国经济与管理,2018,40(12):109-124[2026-11-20].https://doi.org/10.16538/j.cnki.fem.2018.12.008.
摘要
中国人自古有“不得罪人”“以和为贵”等方面的文化沉淀。受传统文化的影响,中国企业在团队管理实践中不免出现团队领导的“老好人”式管理。团队领导当“老好人”是会促进还是会阻碍团队创造力的提升,这在理论探讨和管理实践上是个有趣的议题。在倡导企业创新驱动的新时代背景下,本文针对团队领导“老好人”现象,从信息加工视角,运用自我分类理论观点,建立团队领导宜人性、团队信息深度加工与团队创造力之间传导作用机制研究模型。本研究通过对中国企业166个团队进行问卷调查,收集了132份有效团队样本数据,并采取调节路径分析方法进行了实证分析。研究发现,团队领导宜人性会通过团队信息深度加工影响团队创造力,过高或过低的宜人性都不利于团队创新。有“老好人”倾向的团队领导应展现中等水平的宜人性特征,防止陷入过低或过高宜人性的怪圈,并应重视推动团队信息的深度加工,这样才能最大限度地促进团队创造力的提升。本研究拓展了团队领导个性特征对团队创造力的影响机制研究,同时对于中国企业领导干部提高团队创造力也具有一定的指导意义。
Influenced by traditional Confucianism for a long time, the Chinese have had cultural deposits such as " not give offence” and " harmony is more expensive” since ancient times. In the context of Chinese culture which pays attention to " guanxi” and circles, Chinese enterprises inevitably have the " good man” management of team leaders in the practice of team management. This phenomenon can cause some problems such as lack of creativity in the team. For team leaders, is to be a " good man” an effective promotion or a serious obstacle for team creativity? This is an interesting topic in theoretical discussion and management practice. Based on the Big Five personality theory, this study selects the agreeableness concept which accorded with the " good man” phenomenon of team leaders, and conducts a corresponding analysis. Under the new era of advocating innovation driven by enterprises, this study analyzes the influencing mechanism of team leaders’ agreeableness on team creativity in Chinese cultural context, which not only can enrich the theoretical research on personality characteristics of team leaders, but also has practical significance for Chinese enterprise leaders to improve team creativity. Aiming at the " good man” phenomenon of team leaders, this study explores three issues. First, how does team leaders’ agreeableness affect team creativity? Second, how does team leaders’ agreeableness affect elaboration of team task-relevant information? Third, does elaboration of team task-relevant information play a mediating conductive role in the relationship between team leaders’ agreeableness and team creativity? To answer the three questions mentioned above, this paper constructs a conduction mechanism model among team leaders’ agreeableness, elaboration of team task-relevant information and team creativity based on the self categorization theory from the perspective of information processing. We have conducted large-scale questionnaire surveys of 166 enterprises’ teams in China, and finally obtained 132 valid samples data. This paper conducts an empirical analysis by using the moderated path analysis. The empirical study shows that team leaders’ agreeableness has an inverted U-shape effect on elaboration of team task-relevant information and team creativity respectively, and elaboration of team task-relevant information shows a mediating role between team leaders’ agreeableness and team creativity. At the theoretical level, this paper reveals the conduction mechanism and influence path among team leaders’ agreeableness, elaboration of team task-relevant information and team creativity. It enriches the research on the impact of team leaders’ personality characteristics on team creativity. In the management practice, in order to maximize team creativity, team leaders need to show a moderate level of agreeableness, prevent falling into the strange circle of too low or too high agreeableness, and pay attention to promote elaboration of team task-relevant information. In the process of training leading cadres, on the one hand, enterprises should regard the control ability of team leaders’ agreeableness as an important aspect of talent inspection; on the other hand, it needs to establish a set of team cultures and systems to control the " good man” phenomenon of team leaders.
关键词: 团队领导,宜人性,团队信息深度加工,团队创造力,自我分类理论