混合型组织:概念与类别再探究
Hybrid Organizations: Re-exploration on Concept and Category
DOI: 10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20210918.102
[1]肖红军,阳镇,商慧辰.混合型组织:概念与类别再探究[J/OL].外国经济与管理,2022,44(01):84-104[2026-11-20].https://doi.org/10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20210918.102.
摘要
本文构建了“理论视角—定义逻辑”的混合型组织概念认知范式,基于理论视角将混合型组织本质的已有认知归纳为治理方式观、建构形式观和组织形态观,认为它们可以收敛于组织形态观;基于定义逻辑将混合型组织概念的已有界定方式归结为以“元素混合”为核心和逻辑起点的定义方法、以“特征介于”为核心和逻辑起点的定义方法,并结合二者形成基于元素混合的特征刻画法。在此基础上提出了具有包容性与解释张力的混合型组织元定义和反映混合型组织运行完整“画像”的操作性定义,以期引导人们走出混合型组织的“概念丛林”。本文对混合型组织既有的多种分类方法进行了批判性审视,建立了“元素特征组合—混合度”的混合型组织类别识别与判定框架,并聚焦于组织社会学领域的混合型组织类型,将组织的商业性与社会性两个维度、混合度阈值与类别结合起来,考虑最低混合强度要求,廓清了不同类别混合型组织所处的区域边界。
With the evolution of the “new public management” movement and the accelerating trend of commercial socialization in the 21st century, the boundary between the public sector, the private sector and the third sector has become more and more blurred, and a large number of hybrid organizations with both market orientation and social value creation orientation have emerged in the market. Accordingly, the growing popularity of hybrid organizations in practice has also accelerated the academic research on the basic theory of hybrid organizations and the growth of hybrid organizations. However, although the basic concept of hybrid organization has been interpreted by many scholars, it also intensifies the cognitive differences of hybrid organizations and the process of “concept jungle”, resulting in a great degree of cognitive and operational confusion on the identification, classification and judgment of hybrid organizations. This paper provides a critical review framework for the existing classification methods of hybrid organizations, and promotes the academic community to get out of the multiple fog and “concept jungle” of the conceptual theory of hybrid organizations. At the practical level, it helps organizations realize the transformation and innovation of hybrid organizations under the guidance of sustainable development, and provides operable identification and judgment methods.
The research logic of this paper is to systematically deconstruct the multiple schools of the concept interpretation of hybrid organizations. Based on the literature related to hybrid organizations, it analyzes the multiple theoretical schools of the concept definition of hybrid organizations, extracts the theoretical logic and definition perspective of hybrid organizations, and finally clarifies the origin and development of hybrid organization characteristics and theoretical schools. Based on the differences of theoretical perspectives, the concept definition and essential cognition of hybrid organizations belong to three theoretical perspectives: governance style view, construction form view and organization form view. Based on the differences in defining logical aspects, the definition methods of hybrid organization concept can be divided into two categories, including the definition method with “element hybrid” as the logical starting point and the definition method with “interval location method” as the logical starting point.
On this basis, this paper focuses on the fuzzy and controversial boundaries of hybrid organizations from the perspective of organizational sociology and economic sociology, and then puts forward the classification and discrimination method of “element combination – hybrid degree” to get out of the “concept jungle” and category differences of hybrid organizations. Specifically, this paper puts forward the concepts of hybrid degree threshold, hybrid degree category and hybrid intensity, takes the commerciality and sociality of organizations as two axes, identifies and defines the curve interval distribution of the five types of hybrid organizations, extends the linear spectrum of hybrid organizations of Alter (2007) to the non-linear curve envelope space, and expands the research on the cognitive and category judgment methods of hybrid organizations. Finally, this paper puts forward the future prospect of hybrid organization research, and believes that we need to focus on the basic theory of hybrid organizations, the measurement and evaluation system of “hybrid degree”, the performance evaluation and value creation effect of hybrid organizations, and the cross-level research of hybrid organizations.
关键词: 混合型组织,企业社会责任,社会企业,共益企业,混合度